LBW law

[stampy]

i dont need to learn anything, DRS in relation to lbw decisions is flawed, end of story ffs

[Ron Burgundy]

No shit. But do you want an overhaul of the LBW law? Or do you want an overhaul of DRS?

Make up your mind

[stampy]

both!!!!!!!!!!!

[The Sleeping Giant]

Try baseball. Might be more to your liking.

[stampy]

everyone has an opinion, you got a problem with that obviously

[CENTURION]

there you go, Clarke out, didn't refer, appeal should have instigated the DRS.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Sri Lanka had the option to refer ans didn't. What's the problem?

[CENTURION]

Sri Lanka had the option to refer ans didn't. What's the problem?

the umpire maybe didn't give it out because of the DRS in place. he probably thought, that's bloody close, surely they will ask for a review? I feel that without the DRS he would have given it, so either use the DRS for all appeals, or piss it off.

[Squids]

Bloody 87

[CENTURION]

Bloody 87

so what? when does it turn up? I can't remember the last time. put it this way, more batsmen get out on other numbers.

[Dogmatic]

How is an umpire expected to make the right call when a leggie is going around the wicket?

The same way he is expected to make any other decision.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Sri Lanka had the option to refer ans didn't. What's the problem?

the umpire maybe didn't give it out because of the DRS in place. he probably thought, that's bloody close, surely they will ask for a review? I feel that without the DRS he would have given it, so either use the DRS for all appeals, or piss it off.

Lot of ifs and maybes there. Obviously the umpire thought it wasn't out.
Would rather get rid of drs than review every appeal. What would happen in India when there are 2-3 appeals every over.

[CENTURION]

Sri Lanka had the option to refer ans didn't. What's the problem?

the umpire maybe didn't give it out because of the DRS in place. he probably thought, that's bloody close, surely they will ask for a review? I feel that without the DRS he would have given it, so either use the DRS for all appeals, or piss it off.

Lot of ifs and maybes there. Obviously the umpire thought it wasn't out.
Would rather get rid of drs than review every appeal. What would happen in India when there are 2-3 appeals every over.

yes, get rid of the DRS. now, I'm going to The Bath.

[The Sleeping Giant]

How is an umpire expected to make the right call when a leggie is going around the wicket?

The same way he is expected to make any other decision.

The rule as it stands is easily judged.

[daysofourlives]

there you go, Clarke out, didn't refer, appeal should have instigated the DRS.

So if Clarke dances 3 metres down the wicket and gets hit on the pad and its going onto hit according to DRS you want it given out

[daysofourlives]

everyone has an opinion, you got a problem with that obviously

No just your opinion

I thought i was wrong once but i was mistaken

[stampy]

everyone has an opinion, you got a problem with that obviously

No just your opinion

I thought i was wrong once but i was mistaken

nah TSG has a problem with others opinions as well

[The Sleeping Giant]

Not really. If you do have an opinion, you shouldn't get upset if someone disagrees. That's the important thing. It would be boring if everyone thought the same way. Unless it was my way. The world would be awesome.

[mal]

Not really. If you do have an opinion, you shouldn't get upset if someone disagrees. That's the important thing. It would be boring if everyone thought the same way. Unless it was my way. The world would be awesome.

Quote by The Sniping Giant :
If you have an opinion , you should'nt get upset if someone disagrees
Coming from you what a crock of s..t



In at least the last FEW years you have disagreed with me or ridiculed many many posts of mine
Some I deserved , yeah I can admit that, thats part of my posting style

Ask yourself this
How many times have you agreed with anything Ive posted , or complimented any post of mine ?



Of late Ive been adopting your style , biting back at you
After a FEW days , Im wearisome of this approach , Ive just about had it
I dont get much pleasure out of attempts to belittle you
Stooping to your level is shamefool

[The Sleeping Giant]

Whatever mal. At least I'm not getting any pain in the arse pm's from you. You can always use the block feature. I don't mind.

Say g'day too that other sook for me.