whufc wrote:He did take 3/95 in the first innings of a test match, an average of just over 30 (if all the bowlers did that we would have bowled them out for 300) for a spinner is not to bad.
He took more wickets and a better economy than Siddle, who alot of people thought bowled well.
To be honest i don't think he bowled "that" bad
I think you've got to have the variety of a spinner in your team unless it's a pitch like the WACA, even if that spinner is not as skilled as you'd ideally want. Yes, the Windies got away with it but, let's be honest, Hilf/Johnson/Siddle/Clark don't hold a candle to Marshall/Holding/Garner/Walsh or any other combination from 1978-1995.
In between signatures .....