Aus vs SAF Series

[whufc]

Need to get the line and length right next session.

The saffers batting line up seems to be one which will grind and wear the bowling attack out rather than explosive batting which takes the game away in one session.

Anything less than 2 wickets next session and we are in serious trouble obvious hey

[therisingblues]

At lunch, SAF 1/90 off 27.

Batting R B
GC Smith lbw Pattinson 10 (27)
AN Petersen not out 45 (80)
HM Amla not out 29 (57)

JL Pattinson 9.0 / 1 / 29 / 1

[whufc]

Here we go ring field tight lines make the batsmen earn every run here we go

[whufc]

Great review

[The Ash Man]

Has to be out

[The Ash Man]

Bullshit. Bloody DRS

[Sky Pilot]

Bullshit. Bloody DRS

Tell me what happened - I'm in a meeting and pretending to be paying attention!

[Phantom Gossiper]

Bullshit. Bloody DRS

Tell me what happened - I'm in a meeting and pretending to be paying attention!

LBW shout given not out, went to DRS showed it was out, but pitched just outside the line and went to Umpires call which was of course not out.

[whufc]

Hey siddle how about u f**k off with your waist high length Peterson CAN pull a ball at that length

[MAY-Z]

Bullshit. Bloody DRS

Tell me what happened - I'm in a meeting and pretending to be paying attention!

LBW shout given not out, went to DRS showed it was out, but pitched just outside the line and went to Umpires call which was of course not out.

no drs didnt show it was out, drs showed it was close - in which case it stays with the onfield umpire

[whufc]

LYON gets Peterson

[whufc]

SAF 2/119

Peterson out caught Hussey bowled Lyon 64

[the milky bar kid]

Bullshit. Bloody DRS

Tell me what happened - I'm in a meeting and pretending to be paying attention!

LBW shout given not out, went to DRS showed it was out, but pitched just outside the line and went to Umpires call which was of course not out.

no drs didnt show it was out, drs showed it was close - in which case it stays with the onfield umpire

In this case, was the decision not because the umpire thought it didn't hit the boot?
Hence the not out call?
*Just going off what I read on cricinfo

[MAY-Z]

Bullshit. Bloody DRS

Tell me what happened - I'm in a meeting and pretending to be paying attention!

LBW shout given not out, went to DRS showed it was out, but pitched just outside the line and went to Umpires call which was of course not out.

no drs didnt show it was out, drs showed it was close - in which case it stays with the onfield umpire

In this case, was the decision not because the umpire thought it didn't hit the boot?
Hence the not out call?
*Just going off what I read on cricinfo[/quote]

that is actually a very interesting point, there have been cases where lbw's have been given not out by the umpire becuase they thought the ball was too high. but on drs the ball was shown to be hitting the stumps but was an umpires call of whether or not it was hit outside the line, so not out stood even though the part that the onfield ump was questioning was deemed out.

i wonder if the system could be improved more if the umpire gave his not out reasoning and that is the aspect checked most

[PPLions]

Lyon lucky there. Lazy lazy shot by Petersen

[CoverKing]

May z it wasn't given not out because where it was pitched, it was given not out because where it hit his foot. Two completely different things

[MAY-Z]

May z it wasn't given not out because where it was pitched, it was given not out because where it hit his foot. Two completely different things

i never mentioned where it pitched, i think the quotes have got embedded there

phantom gosspier mentioned where it pitched

[The Ash Man]

May z it wasn't given not out because where it was pitched, it was given not out because where it hit his foot. Two completely different things

And DRS has moved the "in line" area

[OnSong]

May z it wasn't given not out because where it was pitched, it was given not out because where it hit his foot. Two completely different things

Looked dead-set plumb, DRS showed it crashing into middle and off, it hit inline with the stumps, just not within the different strike zone this time around.
The zone has been shifted to be measured between the centre of the off and leg stump now. So last year, that was out.

[OnSong]

May z it wasn't given not out because where it was pitched, it was given not out because where it hit his foot. Two completely different things

And DRS has moved the "in line" area

Ah, beat me to it.