SA v VIC Sheffield Shield 13-16/2 @ MCG

[Footy Smart]

Siddle gone caught behind off Mennie

[RustyCage]

On the cricket Australia website they have the Sheridan wicket as being a stumping, wouldn't have thought that's right...

[locky801]

On the cricket Australia website they have the Sheridan wicket as being a stumping, wouldn't have thought that's right...

He wasn't taking a run, he was standing outside of his crease after letting the ball go and the keeper through the wicket down so it is the correct call that being stumped

[RustyCage]

I was of the understanding that if the keeper throws the stumps down while standing back to a fast bowler it was a run out regardless of whether a run was attempted or not. Learn something new everyday!

[Brodlach]

Vics have lost 8/48...they were 0/56

[scoob]

Only 2 wickets to go before the dreaded 8th wicket

Here we go!

This time please

2nd highest partnership of the innings..... 18

[the joker]

The odds would almost have to have SA as slight favourate now wouldn't they

[Dogwatcher]

I was of the understanding that if the keeper throws the stumps down while standing back to a fast bowler it was a run out regardless of whether a run was attempted or not. Learn something new everyday!

I also thought the same.
I did that a couple of times as a keeper - I was gipped of some dismissals!

[heater31]

I was of the understanding that if the keeper throws the stumps down while standing back to a fast bowler it was a run out regardless of whether a run was attempted or not. Learn something new everyday!

Website commentary had it originally a run out though..... must have corrected it later on.

[bulldogproud2]

I was of the understanding that if the keeper throws the stumps down while standing back to a fast bowler it was a run out regardless of whether a run was attempted or not. Learn something new everyday!

Stumping is definitely the correct dismissal if the batsman is not attempting a run. There is an anomoly to this though. If the batsman is not attempting to run but it is a slip fielder who throws down the stumps it is a runout. I saw Hookesy do this once or twice in grade cricket.
Cheers

[Dogwatcher]

The odds would almost have to have SA as slight favourate now wouldn't they

Why? They've still scored more than our first innings.

It's the fourth day, the wicket's deteriorating.
Oh crap, it's only the second!

[the joker]

The odds would almost have to have SA as slight favourate now wouldn't they

Why? They've still scored more than our first innings.

It's the fourth day, the wicket's deteriorating.
Oh crap, it's only the second!

that's why Sa would be favourate. The wicket will be flat now.

[Brodlach]

Over 40.4: Mennie to Herrick, no run, OUT, but out the very next ball, good length, just outside off, that line has proved fruitful all day, finds the edge, Crosthwaite with another catch

9/104

[MatteeG]

Over 40.4: Mennie to Herrick, no run, OUT, but out the very next ball, good length, just outside off, that line has proved fruitful all day, finds the edge, Crosthwaite with another catch

9/104

Amazing!

[36 flags]

Commonwealth Bank Bushrangers 9/111 (42.1) lead by 231 runs

[locky801]

Commonwealth Bank Bushrangers 9/111 (42.1) lead by 231 runs

They should declare, they have enough to win by around 130 runs

[Coach Bombay]

The choke begins

[scoob]

Jon Holland swinging Hay-makers

[locky801]

Vic 9/156

RGL Carters
31 (75)

JM Holland
34 (20

[Coach Bombay]

i hope chuck gives the bowlers a roasting, all the good work is undone