Warney's top 50 cricketers

[jackpot jim]

MAL, why are May, Hughes and Macgill strange selections?
Apart from the chucker, whose been a better offie in world cricket in the last 20 years than T.B.A. MAY?

[Stumps]

saqlain by a mile

[mal]

MAL, why are May, Hughes and Macgill strange selections?
Apart from the chucker, whose been a better offie in world cricket in the last 20 years than T.B.A. MAY?

Strange as not many scribes would pick these 3 guys in a top 50

[Hondo]

Having said all that MAY/HUGHES/MACGILL are strange listings

There's a strong vibe of looking after his mates in that list I reckon. Tim May in a top 50

That's why I personally don't find it as compelling as some.

[Pup]

Having said all that MAY/HUGHES/MACGILL are strange listings

There's a strong vibe of looking after his mates in that list I reckon. Tim May in a top 50

That's why I personally don't find it as compelling as some.

I have exactly the same opinion..

Just having a quick look at it and there are many problems with the list IMO

Surely Stuart MacGill is not a better cricketer than Younis, Langer and Kapil Dev

He had Tim May and Robin Smith before all these players- Younis, Langer, Dev, Jayasuriya, A.Flower, Vaughan, Donald.

As much as i like Lehmann he is not in the same league as Steve Waugh and is not better than Anwar, Yousuf, Kallis, Pollock or McDermott and Arguably KP.

I Know we all have different opinions and Warney is entitled to his, but surely the reasons for some of these players being where they are isnt purely based on Cricket.

[the joker]

No Jason Gillespie in his 50 as well??? him and mcgrath are australias best ever opening partnership

[Drop Bear]

McGrath would make it based purely on his batting ability.

[Booney]

21-David Boon