SA Footy

Its official. Kilburn have had their Premiership points and their score taken away from them for their wins over Mitcham, Seaton and Pooraka for playing these 3 games over the 15 point APPS threshold. And fined $1000.

The other 3 teams get the 2 Premiership points. Kilburn now 0-5.

Well rules are rules.

Could be a huge story tho should Kilburn make the 5 and go well be interesting how the club react to this? How many points were they over? Surly this must of been an oversight? A proud club like Kilburn would'nt let this happen.

I thought i was told last night that no decision had been made yet and would not be made for up to a week. I believe this is what was said at the Delegates meeting last night?
Ladder no different

I dont think the other teams should get the win.

carey wrote::shock:

Well rules are rules.

Could be a huge story tho should Kilburn make the 5 and go well be interesting how the club react to this? How many points were they over? Surly this must of been an oversight? A proud club like Kilburn would'nt let this happen.

SURELY THAT LAST COMMENT IS SARCASM THEY KNEW ALLRIGHT.

FOOTY TALK wrote:

carey wrote::shock:

Well rules are rules.

Could be a huge story tho should Kilburn make the 5 and go well be interesting how the club react to this? How many points were they over? Surly this must of been an oversight? A proud club like Kilburn would'nt let this happen.

SURELY THAT LAST COMMENT IS SARCASM THEY KNEW ALLRIGHT.

Oh come on, surely you wouldn't be going into a match knowingly that you are over the points.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

FOOTY TALK wrote:

carey wrote::shock:

Well rules are rules.

Could be a huge story tho should Kilburn make the 5 and go well be interesting how the club react to this? How many points were they over? Surly this must of been an oversight? A proud club like Kilburn would'nt let this happen.

SURELY THAT LAST COMMENT IS SARCASM THEY KNEW ALLRIGHT.

Oh come on, surely you wouldn't be going into a match knowingly that you are over the points.

I dont enter teams in system or anything like that but dont the points come up when entering them in. At least thats what i was told, could be wrong.

beef wrote:I dont enter teams in system or anything like that but dont the points come up when entering them in. At least thats what i was told, could be wrong.

Yeah, as far as I know they do. They appear on the printout that each team gives to each other aswell. I could only see it as a glitch, but then again, what would I know.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

FOOTY TALK wrote:

carey wrote::shock:

Well rules are rules.

Could be a huge story tho should Kilburn make the 5 and go well be interesting how the club react to this? How many points were they over? Surly this must of been an oversight? A proud club like Kilburn would'nt let this happen.

SURELY THAT LAST COMMENT IS SARCASM THEY KNEW ALLRIGHT.

Oh come on, surely you wouldn't be going into a match knowingly that you are over the points.

somebody knew,that i do know.

Kilburn will bounce back from this bigger and better!! They will recover and be there come business end of the season.

FOOTY TALK wrote:
confirmed all points lost and a fine. and i dont think points will be awarded to other clubs.apparently 6-7 other clubs being looked at aswell.

Who would they be? I heard Districts had an audit. Glenunga had 14 points against us so might be under consideration.

FOOTY TALK wrote:

somebody knew,that i do know.

Of course, strong ties between Encounter Bay & Kilburn.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

beef wrote:I dont enter teams in system or anything like that but dont the points come up when entering them in. At least thats what i was told, could be wrong.

Yeah, as far as I know they do. They appear on the printout that each team gives to each other aswell. I could only see it as a glitch, but then again, what would I know.

Pretty sure they show on the team sheets supplied by each club on game day.
Also pretty sure that the Kilburn players will be dirty on the findings and will fight hard to climb their way back up this year. It's not the players faults unfortunately... They'd just want to play footy...

Mr Beefy wrote:

FOOTY TALK wrote:
confirmed all points lost and a fine. and i dont think points will be awarded to other clubs.apparently 6-7 other clubs being looked at aswell.

Who would they be? I heard Districts had an audit. Glenunga had 14 points against us so might be under consideration.

I know Mawson Lakes are being looked in to.

I can't comment on the Kilburn saga as I am not involved but IMO (just an unbiased opinion) the amateur league must take some responsibiltiy. How did they allow this to happen for 4 games before errors were found. I can understand maybe 1 or 2 games but 4?? How did the oppostion clubs not pick this up in early rounds? Also I believe the league should make player ratings available online like the GSFL for example which is clear for everyone to see. If Kilburn have broken the rules they must be punsihed in some way but surely this could have been resolved after 1 or 2 rounds

http://www.sportingpulse.com/assoc_page ... sID=199681

With the change over to sporting pulse can you still see previous years players / round by round results etc like you could with the old SAAFL site??

Unlucky for Kashburn

[quote="FOURTH ESTATE"]Its official. Kilburn have had their Premiership points and their score taken away from them for their wins over Mitcham, Seaton and Pooraka for playing these 3 games over the 15 point APPS threshold. And fined $1000.

The other 3 teams get the 2 Premiership points. Kilburn now 0-5.[/quote]




So how how this been made official? My understanding from someone 'in the know' was it wouldn't be declared until next week sometime.

watchdog wrote:I can't comment on the Kilburn saga as I am not involved but IMO (just an unbiased opinion) the amateur league must take some responsibiltiy. How did they allow this to happen for 4 games before errors were found. I can understand maybe 1 or 2 games but 4?? How did the oppostion clubs not pick this up in early rounds? Also I believe the league should make player ratings available online like the GSFL for example which is clear for everyone to see. If Kilburn have broken the rules they must be punsihed in some way but surely this could have been resolved after 1 or 2 rounds

http://www.sportingpulse.com/assoc_page ... sID=199681

With the change over to sporting pulse can you still see previous years players / round by round results etc like you could with the old SAAFL site??

Very well said.

watchdog wrote:I can't comment on the Kilburn saga as I am not involved but IMO (just an unbiased opinion) the amateur league must take some responsibiltiy. How did they allow this to happen for 4 games before errors were found. I can understand maybe 1 or 2 games but 4?? How did the oppostion clubs not pick this up in early rounds? Also I believe the league should make player ratings available online like the GSFL for example which is clear for everyone to see. If Kilburn have broken the rules they must be punsihed in some way but surely this could have been resolved after 1 or 2 rounds

http://www.sportingpulse.com/assoc_page ... sID=199681

With the change over to sporting pulse can you still see previous years players / round by round results etc like you could with the old SAAFL site??

You speak to much sense watchdog get off this site!

carey wrote:

Mr Beefy wrote:

FOOTY TALK wrote:
confirmed all points lost and a fine. and i dont think points will be awarded to other clubs.apparently 6-7 other clubs being looked at aswell.

Who would they be? I heard Districts had an audit. Glenunga had 14 points against us so might be under consideration.

I know Mawson Lakes are being looked in to.

They're wasting their time here!