SA Footy

Posted: **Tue Sep 28, 2010 6:05 pm**

For those interested the Mitchell Park Team of the Decade was announced at our presentation night last Friday night.

Here is the team:

FF: Tony Olson - Damien Bates - Craig Rivett
HF: Joe Leck (c) - Luke McDonnell - Andrew Walsh
C: Nat McDonnell - Glen McPhail - Matt Emmerson
HB: Jeremy David - Phil Pike - Shaun Moyle
FB: Morgan Ellingham - Bernie Kusterman - Adam Hay
R: Stewie Griffen - Ben Weekley - Damien Gelven

I: Scott Weekley, Leigh Rowebottom, Lee Darrington, Chris Rogers

EDIT: And I should mention Trevor "Wal" Bennetts was named Coach of the Decade and Jeff Trinne Team Manager

Posted: **Tue Sep 28, 2010 6:11 pm**

morell wrote:For those interested the Mitchell Park Team of the Decade was announced at our presentation night last Friday night.

Here is the team:

FF: Tony Olson - Damien Bates - Craig Rivett
HF: Joe Leck (c) - Luke McDonnell - Andrew Walsh
C: Nat McDonnell - Glen McPhail - Matt Emmerson
HB: Jeremy David - Phil Pike - Shaun Moyle
FB: Morgan Ellingham - Bernie Kusterman - Adam Hay
R: Stewie Griffen - Ben Weekley - Damien Gelven

I: Scott Weekley, Leigh Rowebottom, Lee Darrington, Chris Rogers

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 12:38 am**

I'm going to apologise in advance to all at Mitchell Park and to anybody else who may take offence to it, and I hope you will understand. I appreciate everything the players, coaches, committee and volunteers have to go through with the clubs who may struggle, and my hat is off to them, BUT..........when I read the title of this thread (after a few sherbets) and I say it with absolutely no malice, nastiness, derision whatsoever - my very first thought was........

QUALIFICATIONS
1. MUST have won a game playing for Mitchell Park
2..................
3..................
4..................

Again sorry, but I p*ssed myself so hard I had to tell someone.

Please take it with a pinch of salt, it was just "THERE".

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 6:10 am**

i understand your comments are based on the hard times assosiated with the lions at the moments,like all clubs go through at some stage but a little known fact that in that decade the lions did win a flag,played in at least 4 finals series,produced players that won leading goal kicker in southern league,country league,assosiation medals and also had a number of players poached by bigger and richer clubs.the club has no juniors,doesnt pay players and like a number of other clubs is surrounded by at least 8 clubs within a 5km radius.they have not folded,they have not merged and they dont complain but keep fighting on.very successful in their own right and they fight on for survival.my hats off to them

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 9:51 am**

X Runna wrote:I'm going to apologise in advance to all at Mitchell Park and to anybody else who may take offence to it, and I hope you will understand. I appreciate everything the players, coaches, committee and volunteers have to go through with the clubs who may struggle, and my hat is off to them, BUT..........when I read the title of this thread (after a few sherbets) and I say it with absolutely no malice, nastiness, derision whatsoever - my very first thought was........

QUALIFICATIONS
1. MUST have won a game playing for Mitchell Park
2..................
3..................
4..................

Again sorry, but I p*ssed myself so hard I had to tell someone.

Please take it with a pinch of salt, it was just "THERE".

After doing a bit of a number crunch, based on your criteria, that would mean a team of well over 120 players. Not really what we were after but keep the suggestions coming.

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 1:45 pm**

I played U16's in 1990 and 1991...was I eligible? :lol:

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 2:14 pm**

MW wrote:I played U16's in 1990 and 1991...was I eligible?

Wrong decade matey.

Posted: **Wed Sep 29, 2010 4:35 pm**

why didnt darren aistrope make the team!! injustice!!

Posted: **Thu Sep 30, 2010 9:18 pm**

morell wrote:For those interested the Mitchell Park Team of the Decade was announced at our presentation night last Friday night.

Here is the team:

FF: Tony Olson - Damien Bates - Craig Rivett
HF: Joe Leck (c) - Luke McDonnell - Andrew Walsh
C: Nat McDonnell - Glen McPhail - Matt Emmerson
HB: Jeremy David - Phil Pike - Shaun Moyle
FB: Morgan Ellingham - Bernie Kusterman - Adam Hay
R: Stewie Griffen - Ben Weekley - Damien Gelven

I: Scott Weekley, Leigh Rowebottom, Lee Darrington, Chris Rogers

EDIT: And I should mention Trevor "Wal" Bennetts was named Coach of the Decade and Jeff Trinne Team Manager

glad you didnt make one of the twins captain

Posted: **Thu Sep 30, 2010 9:25 pm**

unknown source wrote:
morell wrote:For those interested the Mitchell Park Team of the Decade was announced at our presentation night last Friday night.

Here is the team:

FF: Tony Olson - Damien Bates - Craig Rivett
HF: Joe Leck (c) - Luke McDonnell - Andrew Walsh
C: Nat McDonnell - Glen McPhail - Matt Emmerson
HB: Jeremy David - Phil Pike - Shaun Moyle
FB: Morgan Ellingham - Bernie Kusterman - Adam Hay
R: Stewie Griffen - Ben Weekley - Damien Gelven

I: Scott Weekley, Leigh Rowebottom, Lee Darrington, Chris Rogers

EDIT: And I should mention Trevor "Wal" Bennetts was named Coach of the Decade and Jeff Trinne Team Manager

glad you didnt make one of the twins captain

i have been around footy and football clubs my whole life and nat mcdonnell has been and is in the top three captains i have been assosiated with.he did a wonderful job for me when at the club and hold him in the highest esteem.as for luke,he has had a short fuse which teams used for their advantage and i hold him in the same level as his brother.not many people i respect as much as the boys for everything they do for the club family and friends

Posted: **Fri Oct 01, 2010 10:03 am**

unknown source wrote:
morell wrote:For those interested the Mitchell Park Team of the Decade was announced at our presentation night last Friday night.

Here is the team:

FF: Tony Olson - Damien Bates - Craig Rivett
HF: Joe Leck (c) - Luke McDonnell - Andrew Walsh
C: Nat McDonnell - Glen McPhail - Matt Emmerson
HB: Jeremy David - Phil Pike - Shaun Moyle
FB: Morgan Ellingham - Bernie Kusterman - Adam Hay
R: Stewie Griffen - Ben Weekley - Damien Gelven

I: Scott Weekley, Leigh Rowebottom, Lee Darrington, Chris Rogers

EDIT: And I should mention Trevor "Wal" Bennetts was named Coach of the Decade and Jeff Trinne Team Manager

glad you didnt make one of the twins captain

That would be a high honour indeed, but we reserved the biggest honour of the night for Nat McDonnell who became a life member of the Mitchell Park Football Club. Nat deserves every accolade that comes his way. He is a wonderful footballer and an even better person.

Furthermore, the McDonnell twins are two of the most genuine people I have ever met through football. Neither are perfect, both have made mistakes on and off the field. Neither would give a fat rats clacker what anyone outside of their family and friends thinks of them. Indeed, the truest testament of their character is how quickly and vehemently the people that know them come to their defense.

Rather than reading sites like this and taking it as gospel, or believing horror stories from the mouths of exaggerated footballers, come down to MPFC next Wednesday the 13th and look Nat and Luke in the eye, shake their hand, have a chat and then you might be able to base your opinions on something resembling fact.

Posted: **Fri Oct 01, 2010 10:36 am**

Unfortunately Morell, most people can only gain their opinion of someone on how they act on the footy field... Yes this probably isn't fair but for some of us it's all we can go by...

Posted: **Fri Oct 01, 2010 11:36 am**

Choccies wrote:Unfortunately Morell, most people can only gain their opinion of someone on how they act on the footy field... Yes this probably isn't fair but for some of us it's all we can go by...

I can understand that, and for Luke, he has done something incredibly stupid things on the field, no doubt about that.

As for Nat, I really do not understand the criticism.

Here are all of Mitchell Parks player offences, as taken from iScore. Lets play "Spot the Nat":

Offences Penalised
ID Date Name Reported For Tribunal Proceedings Suspended Action
12620 16/06/2007 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person 3 games View Offence Appeal
13257 04/08/2007 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person non appearance of player View Offence Appeal
29483 08/08/2009 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person Striking - 4 games View Offence Appeal
5858 19/08/2006 HAY, ADAM Striking another person 1 game View Offence Appeal
21176 28/06/2008 KUHAR, JAY Category B Offence 3 in season - automatic penalty View Offence Appeal
21347 19/07/2008 KUHAR, JAY Striking another person player was found guilty of striking and was suspended for 4 games. View Offence Appeal
191 30/07/2005 LECK, JOSEPH Striking another person 6 games - investigation View Offence Appeal
28868 13/06/2009 LINDHOLM, SHAUN Striking another person Guilty - 3 games (Striking - 2 games Rough Play - 1 game Failing to leave the ground - dismissed) View Offence Appeal
29436 01/08/2009 MCDONNELL, LUKE Striking another person Guilty - 3 games View Offence Appeal
5870 26/08/2006 MCDONNELL, LUKE Striking another person 1 game View Offence Appeal
27082 18/04/2009 MCDONNELL, LUKE Prescribed offence - Attempting to kick another player Automatic Penalty Applied View Offence Appeal
18744 12/04/2008 NEWTON, LUKAS Striking another person guilty 2 games suspension View Offence Appeal

Posted: **Fri Oct 01, 2010 12:02 pm**

morell wrote:
Choccies wrote:Unfortunately Morell, most people can only gain their opinion of someone on how they act on the footy field... Yes this probably isn't fair but for some of us it's all we can go by...
I can understand that, and for Luke, he has done something incredibly stupid things on the field, no doubt about that.

As for Nat, I really do not understand the criticism.

Here are all of Mitchell Parks player offences, as taken from iScore. Lets play "Spot the Nat":

Offences Penalised
ID Date Name Reported For Tribunal Proceedings Suspended Action
12620 16/06/2007 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person 3 games View Offence Appeal
13257 04/08/2007 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person non appearance of player View Offence Appeal
29483 08/08/2009 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person Striking - 4 games View Offence Appeal
5858 19/08/2006 HAY, ADAM Striking another person 1 game View Offence Appeal
21176 28/06/2008 KUHAR, JAY Category B Offence 3 in season - automatic penalty View Offence Appeal
21347 19/07/2008 KUHAR, JAY Striking another person player was found guilty of striking and was suspended for 4 games. View Offence Appeal
191 30/07/2005 LECK, JOSEPH Striking another person 6 games - investigation View Offence Appeal
28868 13/06/2009 LINDHOLM, SHAUN Striking another person Guilty - 3 games (Striking - 2 games Rough Play - 1 game Failing to leave the ground - dismissed) View Offence Appeal
29436 01/08/2009 MCDONNELL, LUKE Striking another person Guilty - 3 games View Offence Appeal
5870 26/08/2006 MCDONNELL, LUKE Striking another person 1 game View Offence Appeal
27082 18/04/2009 MCDONNELL, LUKE Prescribed offence - Attempting to kick another player Automatic Penalty Applied View Offence Appeal
18744 12/04/2008 NEWTON, LUKAS Striking another person guilty 2 games suspension View Offence Appeal

just curious to what the automatic penalty is for an offence like that??
I dont know these blokes at all but as choccies said, alot of us only get to know a bloke by how they act on the field.
I remember some of the blokes I played against when I was younger I hated with a passion, a few years later played with them and they were some of the best blokes Ive ever met!

Posted: **Fri Oct 01, 2010 12:11 pm**

unknown source wrote:glad you didnt make one of the twins captain

If hope your selection criteria for a Brahama Lodge Team of the Decade is just as strict as you are purporting ours should have been. Brahma Lodge are a great footy club and have had a couple of good years results wise on the field, but if you're going to have a crack at MPFC for our supposed thuggish rep you had best get your facts straight:

Every single year BL have had more reports than the MPFC, but don't let facts get in the way of a good story.

Posted: **Fri Oct 01, 2010 12:15 pm**

Iron Fist wrote:
morell wrote:
Choccies wrote:Unfortunately Morell, most people can only gain their opinion of someone on how they act on the footy field... Yes this probably isn't fair but for some of us it's all we can go by...
I can understand that, and for Luke, he has done something incredibly stupid things on the field, no doubt about that.

As for Nat, I really do not understand the criticism.

Here are all of Mitchell Parks player offences, as taken from iScore. Lets play "Spot the Nat":

Offences Penalised
ID Date Name Reported For Tribunal Proceedings Suspended Action
12620 16/06/2007 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person 3 games View Offence Appeal
13257 04/08/2007 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person non appearance of player View Offence Appeal
29483 08/08/2009 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person Striking - 4 games View Offence Appeal
5858 19/08/2006 HAY, ADAM Striking another person 1 game View Offence Appeal
21176 28/06/2008 KUHAR, JAY Category B Offence 3 in season - automatic penalty View Offence Appeal
21347 19/07/2008 KUHAR, JAY Striking another person player was found guilty of striking and was suspended for 4 games. View Offence Appeal
191 30/07/2005 LECK, JOSEPH Striking another person 6 games - investigation View Offence Appeal
28868 13/06/2009 LINDHOLM, SHAUN Striking another person Guilty - 3 games (Striking - 2 games Rough Play - 1 game Failing to leave the ground - dismissed) View Offence Appeal
29436 01/08/2009 MCDONNELL, LUKE Striking another person Guilty - 3 games View Offence Appeal
5870 26/08/2006 MCDONNELL, LUKE Striking another person 1 game View Offence Appeal
27082 18/04/2009 MCDONNELL, LUKE Prescribed offence - Attempting to kick another player Automatic Penalty Applied View Offence Appeal
18744 12/04/2008 NEWTON, LUKAS Striking another person guilty 2 games suspension View Offence Appeal

just curious to what the automatic penalty is for an offence like that??
I dont know these blokes at all but as choccies said, alot of us only get to know a bloke by how they act on the field.
I remember some of the blokes I played against when I was younger I hated with a passion, a few years later played with them and they were some of the best blokes Ive ever met!

He didn't make contact with him and it was more of a glancing kick, but you're right, I thought he was lucky to only get 2 matches for what was a pretty ordinary thing to do. I think Luke has improved this year, we struggled and struggled and were obviously very frustrated. Luke played nearly every game, including some B Grade games and was a complete saint.

Posted: **Fri Oct 01, 2010 1:29 pm**

morell wrote:
Iron Fist wrote:
morell wrote:
Choccies wrote:Unfortunately Morell, most people can only gain their opinion of someone on how they act on the footy field... Yes this probably isn't fair but for some of us it's all we can go by...
I can understand that, and for Luke, he has done something incredibly stupid things on the field, no doubt about that.

As for Nat, I really do not understand the criticism.

Here are all of Mitchell Parks player offences, as taken from iScore. Lets play "Spot the Nat":

Offences Penalised
ID Date Name Reported For Tribunal Proceedings Suspended Action
12620 16/06/2007 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person 3 games View Offence Appeal
13257 04/08/2007 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person non appearance of player View Offence Appeal
29483 08/08/2009 HARRISON, MARK Striking another person Striking - 4 games View Offence Appeal
5858 19/08/2006 HAY, ADAM Striking another person 1 game View Offence Appeal
21176 28/06/2008 KUHAR, JAY Category B Offence 3 in season - automatic penalty View Offence Appeal
21347 19/07/2008 KUHAR, JAY Striking another person player was found guilty of striking and was suspended for 4 games. View Offence Appeal
191 30/07/2005 LECK, JOSEPH Striking another person 6 games - investigation View Offence Appeal
28868 13/06/2009 LINDHOLM, SHAUN Striking another person Guilty - 3 games (Striking - 2 games Rough Play - 1 game Failing to leave the ground - dismissed) View Offence Appeal
29436 01/08/2009 MCDONNELL, LUKE Striking another person Guilty - 3 games View Offence Appeal
5870 26/08/2006 MCDONNELL, LUKE Striking another person 1 game View Offence Appeal
27082 18/04/2009 MCDONNELL, LUKE Prescribed offence - Attempting to kick another player Automatic Penalty Applied View Offence Appeal
18744 12/04/2008 NEWTON, LUKAS Striking another person guilty 2 games suspension View Offence Appeal

just curious to what the automatic penalty is for an offence like that??
I dont know these blokes at all but as choccies said, alot of us only get to know a bloke by how they act on the field.
I remember some of the blokes I played against when I was younger I hated with a passion, a few years later played with them and they were some of the best blokes Ive ever met!
He didn't make contact with him and it was more of a glancing kick, but you're right, I thought he was lucky to only get 2 matches for what was a pretty ordinary thing to do. I think Luke has improved this year, we struggled and struggled and were obviously very frustrated. Luke played nearly every game, including some B Grade games and was a complete saint.

Mate if that was the game agaisnt Paralowie a few seasons ago at your ground it was nothing like that. I was there watching some mates play and it happend right in front of us.
Shane Hailes tackles Luke who hets caught holding the ball. Shane falls to the ground in the tackle and when Luke got up, Shane was still on the ground. Luke took a full blooded kick at Shane who was lucky enought to roll out of the way.
Lucky Shane didnt belt him.
That is the truth.

Posted: **Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:36 pm**

newbloke wrote:
morell wrote:He didn't make contact with him and it was more of a glancing kick, but you're right, I thought he was lucky to only get 2 matches for what was a pretty ordinary thing to do. I think Luke has improved this year, we struggled and struggled and were obviously very frustrated. Luke played nearly every game, including some B Grade games and was a complete saint.

Mate if that was the game agaisnt Paralowie a few seasons ago at your ground it was nothing like that. I was there watching some mates play and it happend right in front of us.
Shane Hailes tackles Luke who hets caught holding the ball. Shane falls to the ground in the tackle and when Luke got up, Shane was still on the ground. Luke took a full blooded kick at Shane who was lucky enought to roll out of the way.
Lucky Shane didnt belt him.
That is the truth.

Yeah I was playing and would have been 15m from it. The Paralowie player tackled Luke who got pinged for HTB, Luke got up quicker and the Paralowie player then grabbed at Luke's lower leg. Luke swiped/kicked at him with his leg and missed. It wasn't full blooded boot but it wasn't exactly a flick either.

It was one of the stupidest things I have seen someone do. Definitely deserved a few weeks on the sidelines but it wasn't like he took a run up and punted his head like a football, which is what I think a few people think might have happened.

The Paralowie bloke did get up and try and belt him, and rightly so.

Whatever. Its done and dusted.

Still don't get what this has to do with Nat or our team of the decade....

Posted: **Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:46 pm**

Troy Rynne thinks you've got it wrong with him not in there.... :lol:

Posted: **Fri Oct 01, 2010 3:27 pm**

Jeff Trinne Team Manager

sponsored by GO shelving of course

SA Footy

Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade

Re: Mitchell Park Team of the Decade