SA Footy

Johno6 wrote:ahhhhh finals...

that time of year where I forget how to play football.

You're not the only one at your club that has that problem

****, kick a man while hes down.


and a big booooo-urns to FC

Sorry, it was there...

A great one-liner Lutz, well done!

lutz wrote:

Johno6 wrote:ahhhhh finals...

that time of year where I forget how to play football.

You're not the only one at your club that has that problem

reowwr...

The dreaded bye is rearing its bastard head

wristwatcher wrote:The dreaded bye is rearing its bastard head

easy fix for div 8 is to chuck adelaide uni e & f grade back in, bye bye bye?

or throw one of the div 8 teams up into div 7 and fix both...

the other thing is that the bye gives people a chance to recuperate, and given that the average age in div 8 and c grades is older, this is welcome.

finn wrote:or throw one of the div 8 teams up into div 7 and fix both...

the other thing is that the bye gives people a chance to recuperate, and given that the average age in div 8 and c grades is older, this is welcome.

This is not the AFL. It's an 18 week season not 23. In the lower levels if you need a week off you take one and probably most importantly teams get 2 weeks off with long weekends already.

Byes are a coaching nightmare in lower divs. in 2010 our run went bye, long weekend, Ovingham folded. So I had to try and get a team together after a month off. You would much rather play every week and have long weekends off.

I do like your first idea. Throw TTG who should have been in Div 6 last year into Div 7. They do have the largest junior program in the State. No byes problem solvered. OK so it doesn't have to be TTG but how about aSMOSH who seem to play in lower grade GFs every year.

yeah looking at div 8 teams now, smosh kinda seem a calibre ahead of the rest?

bout time they give the next level a crack?

i no understand wristy, ur say just remove a div 8 side to make it 8 teams only in div 8?

marbles wrote:yeah looking at div 8 teams now, smosh kinda seem a calibre ahead of the rest?

bout time they give the next level a crack?

i no understand wristy, ur say just remove a div 8 side to make it 8 teams only in div 8?

Yeah that would work. It would mean that you would play 4 teams 3 times but at least no byes.

I think your spot on Mr Marbles. SMOSH C and D's have been ripping it up for years and should be in 7.

The least ideal scenario is to have 8 teams and thus a biased fixture.

I'll admit that adding the Easter weekend on top of the other byes is one too many. It's a shame that easter is so late this year.

Which club pulled out? Or was there only 9 clubs with C & D Grade?

surely there a c grade only club out there right now thats got more numbers on the track than the seaford trainline, that they could easily field a dgrade? ingles? goodwood?

then chuck in uni e & f & smosh up to 7 & its a 10 team football heaven

Not that it really affects me, but I'd rather the bye and have a weekend to go and watch some mates play in other leagues, get across to Melbourne to watch Richmond, or just have a week off footy altogether, not to mention giving the body another break, than have a compromised fixture, which could be the difference between a side making the finals or not.

Pag wrote:Not that it really affects me, but I'd rather the bye and have a weekend to go and watch some mates play in other leagues, get across to Melbourne to watch Richmond, or just have a week off footy altogether, not to mention giving the body another break, than have a compromised fixture, which could be the difference between a side making the finals or not.

Sorry Pag you lost all credibility when you said go and watch Richmond I understand you would want at least a 9 team league so Richmond have their spot they have made their own. OK I'm done now, sorry mate. I am in the same boat doesn't directly effect me but my point of view was as a coaching one.

Incidentally I am heading over late this year to watch your beloved Tigers take on the worlds greatest football team ever ever Port. Have been invited into a corporate box at Etihad. Div 8 probably won't be at the front of my mind then

wristwatcher wrote:

Pag wrote:Not that it really affects me, but I'd rather the bye and have a weekend to go and watch some mates play in other leagues, get across to Melbourne to watch Richmond, or just have a week off footy altogether, not to mention giving the body another break, than have a compromised fixture, which could be the difference between a side making the finals or not.

Sorry Pag you lost all credibility when you said go and watch Richmond I understand you would want at least a 9 team league so Richmond have their spot they have made their own. OK I'm done now, sorry mate. I am in the same boat doesn't directly effect me but my point of view was as a coaching one.

Incidentally I am heading over late this year to watch your beloved Tigers take on the worlds greatest football team ever ever Port. Have been invited into a corporate box at Etihad. Div 8 probably won't be at the front of my mind then

I'll be there that day too, flying over on the Sunday morning. No corporate box but I'll be sure to wave up at you while you look down at us commoners.

S Demon wrote:Which club pulled out? Or was there only 9 clubs with C & D Grade?

SHOC are now listed in Div 7. I don't mind the bye either - as we know C/D graders are predominatly made of blokes aged 30+ and gives a chance to rest the old legs.

I just fit into that category now.

so how many byes will the c and d grade have each year now?

Johno6 wrote:I just fit into that category now.

so how many byes will the c and d grade have each year now?

Possibly 4

I know a lot of people don't agree with that but in theory, that'd be almost perfect for a comp dominated by players over 30.