SAAFL Div 5 & 5R (2010)

[Demon Juke]

yeah i have to agree, if they allowed it for one person. it opens the flood gates for every one to use the old injury excuse to allow players to play lower... unfortunite as it is, i think it's a fair call... all club have injuries... i personally think people wood take advantage of the rule if it came in...

Yon only have to look at the "a" grade team sheet to see Lee Duggan missed the last 4 games so a player has to go up to cover for him. That's the idea of putting a permit in, if all cases went by rules stated then there is no need to put in any permits in. All permits should be canned because if you follow the letter of the law, nobody permit should be approved. It just not a good look for the league to have somebody approving / not approving permits who has vested interest, not saying that would sway them but just should not be done.

[EddieV]

You make it seem like there is 1 individual who makes the decisions. If as your suggesting Shaun Ryan didnt allow the permits based on a self interest why didnt the other members on the permit committee simply over rule him? What about the AL players who were approved? If we are to progress to a final we will have to play them also so why wouldnt he have pulled those magic strings the same way?

Im just looking forward to playing tomorrow, last week was a good game and i just hope we can get the result to turn the other way by 9 points or more.

[The Bartman]

You make it seem like there is 1 individual who makes the decisions. If as your suggesting Shaun Ryan didnt allow the permits based on a self interest why didnt the other members on the permit committee simply over rule him? What about the AL players who were approved? If we are to progress to a final we will have to play them also so why wouldnt he have pulled those magic strings the same way?

Im just looking forward to playing tomorrow, last week was a good game and i just hope we can get the result to turn the other way by 9 points or more.

Noone is suggesting Shaun did anything untoward, just looked like a conflict of interest from an outsiders view. We put in for permits, didnt get them, we move on.

Should be another good game at the Lodge today. Go you Magoos!!

[S Demon]

Up early Bartman? Thought you'd already be at Brahma Lodge by now!!! Good luck today mate

[The Bartman]

Up early Bartman? Thought you'd already be at Brahma Lodge by now!!! Good luck today mate

Cheers mate. Up at 5.30. Didnt think that was too bad being a final!

[The Bartman]

Up early Bartman? Thought you'd already be at Brahma Lodge by now!!! Good luck today mate

Probably not too safe before sun up down that way!

[catchisthecry]

Good luck D5 teams..
Both should be cracker games.
Can't split rosies v plympton... I'll go Plympton just with VanderH to kick a bag.
BL best team I think and should account for Liz out there.

HV and a good Lutho outfit in the magoos to get up.

[hawkseye]

Good luck Bartman

[old farmer]

yeah i have to agree, if they allowed it for one person. it opens the flood gates for every one to use the old injury excuse to allow players to play lower... unfortunite as it is, i think it's a fair call... all club have injuries... i personally think people wood take advantage of the rule if it came in...

But if your A grade finished top and has the week off then anyone from your A grade can go down and play B's, makes sense. Know 1 club that has picked possibly their A grade B&F in the B's because he will be overseas and possibly won't play till GF.

[Jabber]

if the rain stays away, plympton, if it rains, rosewater with a leg in the air unfortunately.

BL in the other.

[Booney]

Rosewater win by about 3 goals.

[S Demon]

Div 5
EF Rosewater 13.16 94 v 11.06 72 Plympton
QF Brahma Lodge 22.11 143 v 11.13 79 Elizabeth

Div 5R
EF Brahma Lodge 11.16 82 v 05.05 35 Hope Valley
QF Plympton 07.12 54 v 05.06 36 Adelaide Lutheran

[The Dark Knight]

Div 5
EF Rosewater 13.16 94 v 11.06 72 Plympton
QF Brahma Lodge 22.11 143 v 11.13 79 Elizabeth

Div 5R
EF Brahma Lodge 11.16 82 v 05.05 35 Hope Valley
QF Plympton 07.12 54 v 05.06 36 Adelaide Lutheran

Good wins by both Brahma Lodge and Rosewater today, well done on their peformances. I'm spewing I couldn't go and watch the game at Rossies, bloody phonebooks!

[The Dark Knight]

Dark Knight is matty eags affiliated with a SANFL club?

He was/still is (?) on the Magpies reserves list and has played U/19s there. He was asked to go out and train with them and possibly play a game earlier in the year, but doesn't want anything to do with them anymore. He also played Eagles juniors before switching to Port.

Too good a footballer imo to be playing D5.....Bit like duggy for us really.....but not going to complain if they play for your club!

Yeah agreed Valleys, he's too good for div 5. He really should be playing for the Magpies. He did play all his juniors at Seaton where he won a Metro West Association medal in the U/16s back in 2006. He made a few mistakes on and off the field and fell out of favour at the Magpies and at Seaton and ended up with us. We're so lucky we have him that's for sure.

[NO-MERCY]

Yes young Matty Eags needed to change his ways quickly.
A bloke thats very young, has been suspended a few times & he would know once he hits the 12 game suspension mark its bye bye.

[The Dark Knight]

NHFC 2010 Best and Fairest Medal Count

A Grade
1st-Trent Kolbig
2nd-Matthew Eagles
3rd-Matthew Davidson and Craig Todd

B Grade
1st-Jason Kouba
2nd-Shaun Costigan
3rd-Nathan Corry

C Grade
1st-Francisco Meijas
2nd-Nathan Ruskin
3rd-Kalien Butler

Well done to all the winners and all the runners up.

[The Dark Knight]

Yes young Matty Eags needed to change his ways quickly.
A bloke thats very young, has been suspended a few times & he would know once he hits the 12 game suspension mark its bye bye.

Hello NM! Yeah, he was a lose cannon in juniors and has certainly changed his behavior for the better which is good to see.

[bazza1]

NHFC 2010 Best and Fairest Medal Count

A Grade
1st-Trent Kolbig
2nd-Matthew Eagles
3rd-Matthew Davidson and Craig Todd

B Grade
1st-Jason Kouba
2nd-Shaun Costigan
3rd-Nathan Corry

C Grade
1st-Francisco Meijas
2nd-Nathan Ruskin
3rd-Kalien Butler

Well done to all the winners and all the runners up.

Nice work DK on your placing mate. Weed a deserving winner, quality footballer and bloke.

[The Dark Knight]

NHFC 2010 Best and Fairest Medal Count

A Grade
1st-Trent Kolbig
2nd-Matthew Eagles
3rd-Matthew Davidson and Craig Todd

B Grade
1st-Jason Kouba
2nd-Shaun Costigan
3rd-Nathan Corry

C Grade
1st-Francisco Meijas
2nd-Nathan Ruskin
3rd-Kalien Butler

Well done to all the winners and all the runners up.

Nice work DK on your placing mate. Weed a deserving winner, quality footballer and bloke.

Thanks mate. That's back to back A Grade B and F wins for Weed now, good on him.

[custardarm]

just to let everyone know that the forum will be quiet from here on for a while as a safooty gag has been issued to brahma lodge posters , the rest of us will just have to lift our games