SAAFL Div 5 & 5R (2010)

[One Eyed]

Hollywood so 5 flags at roxby was it.??? Or some at Lobethal too.??

[Jabber]

Hollywood u have serious head issues.

My support for the club does not begin and end with this forum.

The boys have my full support but i'm not the type of person to sugar coat and pretend things are fine when they are not.

My A Grade tally stands at about 10 for the record, and i'm under no illusions as to my place in the pecking order at Plympton.

I guesss what people need to know is that the 'relationship' between jabber & hollywood is frosty at best, which is why hollywood feels he has to chuck a few personal barbs in, but thats up to him.

All players at plympton have my support, as long as they support the club. Thats my stance, nothing malicious in that i would have thought. And i think most people that have spent a fair chunk of thier life at a footy club would have the same stance.

I love plympton, and put my hand up to help in any way possible and always have. I might challenge the status quo on occasion, but that is only to promote debate, and to get the club continually evolving and moving forward.

Now once again, bugger off to the div 3 forum please

Gee, we're all nasty little beans in here tonight.

Now shake hands and go and play nicely please

If some galah from another div jumped on here and started throwing barbs at your club would you shake hands with them FC?

Hollywood on the rampage! some big comments directed at PFC I would have to say things arent as rosy on and off the field at the kennel as a few on here would have u think. As with alot of footy clubs there are alot of people with different agendas and when the team is losing these seem to come to the surface alot more. I too have been present when a couple of new players have been givin a mouthful from long time club people while they were sitting at the bar hardly what you want to happen if the club wants these guys to stick around(this has happened twice)but a win this weekend and all of a sudden the supporters are back on your side, thats the fickle nature of supporters

Thats the thing as it has always been with plympton and the bar flies that have been there for years including jabber they would rather bag the players than actually support them. Funny thing is how many A grade games has he played 1 i think and it was the funniest thing ive ever seen.And Jabber is a hypocrite bags the team then when someone speaks up he has a has a dig at them for telling it how it is. Classic classic classic

[sprinttospace]

Was just playing - I like the idea of non club umpires thats the reason we are doing it with our C Grade - it takes away the perception of cheating

the reality is our b grade ump wouldn't travel to a neutral ground. he wants to umpire our games and does it fairly. why fix something that isn't broken, there's only a few that err on the side of their own club, but i think div 5 is pretty good at B grade level.

saw one of the umps we had against plympton doing junior footy at smosh on sunday and he is an extremely competent umpire, shame there is not more like him doing the late games. maybe performance based pay would help.

[sprinttospace]

Plympton vs Smithfield
Hope Valley vs Elizabeth
Blackfriars vs Rosewater
Hectorville vs North Haven
Brahma Lodge vs Adelaide Lutheran

[Mr Beefy]

Was just playing - I like the idea of non club umpires thats the reason we are doing it with our C Grade - it takes away the perception of cheating

the reality is our b grade ump wouldn't travel to a neutral ground. he wants to umpire our games and does it fairly. why fix something that isn't broken, there's only a few that err on the side of their own club, but i think div 5 is pretty good at B grade level.

saw one of the umps we had against plympton doing junior footy at smosh on sunday and he is an extremely competent umpire, shame there is not more like him doing the late games. maybe performance based pay would help.

At present we pay $100 for a bad umpire, should we pay more for a good ump or less for what we're getting?

[Drop Bear]

I guesss what people need to know is that the 'relationship' between jabber & hollywood is frosty at best, which is why hollywood feels he has to chuck a few personal barbs in, but thats up to him.

Yep, I think we picked up on that vibe mate!

[zedman]

I guesss what people need to know is that the 'relationship' between jabber & hollywood is frosty at best, which is why hollywood feels he has to chuck a few personal barbs in, but thats up to him.

Yep, I think we picked up on that vibe mate!

on a side note jabber..could you inform your bbq people to trim the rind off the bacon please..i nearly choked on it sunday afternoon watching the kids play

[Jabber]

I guesss what people need to know is that the 'relationship' between jabber & hollywood is frosty at best, which is why hollywood feels he has to chuck a few personal barbs in, but thats up to him.

Yep, I think we picked up on that vibe mate!

on a side note jabber..could you inform your bbq people to trim the rind off the bacon please..i nearly choked on it sunday afternoon watching the kids play

Will forward that on...

[Jabber]

I guesss what people need to know is that the 'relationship' between jabber & hollywood is frosty at best, which is why hollywood feels he has to chuck a few personal barbs in, but thats up to him.

Yep, I think we picked up on that vibe mate!

Subtle as a sledge hammer hey!

[sprinttospace]

Was just playing - I like the idea of non club umpires thats the reason we are doing it with our C Grade - it takes away the perception of cheating

the reality is our b grade ump wouldn't travel to a neutral ground. he wants to umpire our games and does it fairly. why fix something that isn't broken, there's only a few that err on the side of their own club, but i think div 5 is pretty good at B grade level.

saw one of the umps we had against plympton doing junior footy at smosh on sunday and he is an extremely competent umpire, shame there is not more like him doing the late games. maybe performance based pay would help.

At present we pay $100 for a bad umpire, should we pay more for a good ump or less for what we're getting?

good point. $100 maximum and we'll assess down from there.

[Lightning McQueen]

Was just playing - I like the idea of non club umpires thats the reason we are doing it with our C Grade - it takes away the perception of cheating

the reality is our b grade ump wouldn't travel to a neutral ground. he wants to umpire our games and does it fairly. why fix something that isn't broken, there's only a few that err on the side of their own club, but i think div 5 is pretty good at B grade level.

saw one of the umps we had against plympton doing junior footy at smosh on sunday and he is an extremely competent umpire, shame there is not more like him doing the late games. maybe performance based pay would help.

Fair enough, I think teams should still lodge umpire reports in the B's so the SAAFL & the club umpires can get a gist of their performance. You don't get much feedback generally on where you are going right or wrong once the game has finished, I know I get disappointed with myself if I feel as though I've umpired poorly or missed things.

[Old Dog 13]

Plympton vs Smithfield
Hope Valley vs Elizabeth
Blackfriars vs Rosewater
Hectorville vs North Haven
Brahma Lodge vs Adelaide Lutheran

[Jabber]

Absolutely spot on, B Grade ump reports should be compulsory.

That way if there is a trend where an umpire is seen to be cheating, or whatever, an umpires observer can be sent out to have a look. If the observer has a problem with the ump then a letter can be sent to the club advising of this, and that a different ump should be found, or a league appointed one will be used at the clubs expense.

Or the ump can be follwed up later in the year if need be

Was just playing - I like the idea of non club umpires thats the reason we are doing it with our C Grade - it takes away the perception of cheating

the reality is our b grade ump wouldn't travel to a neutral ground. he wants to umpire our games and does it fairly. why fix something that isn't broken, there's only a few that err on the side of their own club, but i think div 5 is pretty good at B grade level.

saw one of the umps we had against plympton doing junior footy at smosh on sunday and he is an extremely competent umpire, shame there is not more like him doing the late games. maybe performance based pay would help.

Fair enough, I think teams should still lodge umpire reports in the B's so the SAAFL & the club umpires can get a gist of their performance. You don't get much feedback generally on where you are going right or wrong once the game has finished, I know I get disappointed with myself if I feel as though I've umpired poorly or missed things.

[manbitesdog]

was good to c the fat little bald bloke back in the lodge a grade yesterday. one d.coombs been out 4 a while. got about 20 free kicks for too high

Thats not very nice mandog! Its a pity that our full forward couldnt mark other wise could of kicked a lazy 6-7. $100 on it with GEESKIP that Scott mac kicks 100 goals this year!! This bloke is an absolute gun!! Its a pity you never see him at training but!!

from what i hear u haven't seen the track for a while urself. exept the trainers room. he definately wont get the 100, will probably fall off the edge soon and break down like the other forwards in the comp

[woodublieve12]

Absolutely spot on, B Grade ump reports should be compulsory.

That way if there is a trend where an umpire is seen to be cheating, or whatever, an umpires observer can be sent out to have a look. If the observer has a problem with the ump then a letter can be sent to the club advising of this, and that a different ump should be found, or a league appointed one will be used at the clubs expense.

Or the ump can be follwed up later in the year if need be

Was just playing - I like the idea of non club umpires thats the reason we are doing it with our C Grade - it takes away the perception of cheating

the reality is our b grade ump wouldn't travel to a neutral ground. he wants to umpire our games and does it fairly. why fix something that isn't broken, there's only a few that err on the side of their own club, but i think div 5 is pretty good at B grade level.

saw one of the umps we had against plympton doing junior footy at smosh on sunday and he is an extremely competent umpire, shame there is not more like him doing the late games. maybe performance based pay would help.

Fair enough, I think teams should still lodge umpire reports in the B's so the SAAFL & the club umpires can get a gist of their performance. You don't get much feedback generally on where you are going right or wrong once the game has finished, I know I get disappointed with myself if I feel as though I've umpired poorly or missed things.

totally agree... i think coaches should be able to write a report, as they do in the A grade... Cuold of come in handy couple of times this year...

[Browny25]

BRAHMA LODGE SPORTS CLUB
PAST PLAYERS DAY
Saturday 26th of June
@ Brahma Lodge Oval
Brahma Lodge Vs Adelaide Lutheran

*Triple Header*

C Grade 10:15
B Grade 12:15
A Grade 2:15

All Past Players and Officials Welcome

[Browny25]

Congratulations to Beau Paterson who plays his 100th game for Brahma Lodge this week...

Part of the leadership group, and a very consistent contributor.

Well done mate

[cossi11]

Plympton vs Smithfield
Hope Valley vs Elizabeth
Blackfriars vs Rosewater
Hectorville vs North Haven
Brahma Lodge vs Adelaide Lutheran

[Demon Juke]

Was just playing - I like the idea of non club umpires thats the reason we are doing it with our C Grade - it takes away the perception of cheating

the reality is our b grade ump wouldn't travel to a neutral ground. he wants to umpire our games and does it fairly. why fix something that isn't broken, there's only a few that err on the side of their own club, but i think div 5 is pretty good at B grade level.

saw one of the umps we had against plympton doing junior footy at smosh on sunday and he is an extremely competent umpire, shame there is not more like him doing the late games. maybe performance based pay would help.

Fair enough, I think teams should still lodge umpire reports in the B's so the SAAFL & the club umpires can get a gist of their performance. You don't get much feedback generally on where you are going right or wrong once the game has finished, I know I get disappointed with myself if I feel as though I've umpired poorly or missed things.

[/quote]

totally agree... i think coaches should be able to write a report, as they do in the A grade... Cuold of come in handy couple of times this year...[/quote]

I don,t think the "a" grade umpires even have a report written on them anymore!

[Demon Juke]

Congratulations to Beau Paterson who plays his 100th game for Brahma Lodge this week...

Part of the leadership group, and a very consistent contributor.

Well done mate

Well done to Beau on 100 games and maybe he will give himself a good write up in the budget!