SAAFL Division 4 2013

[Jimmy_041]

I actually found the scoreboard guys quite amusing

[Executive Member]

I actually found the scoreboard guys quite amusing

They must have been drinking Coopers then

[Gatt_Weasel]

unless you talking about them assholes on the scoreboard sorry my mistake 90 percent of them are ok then you got them they could be down by 20 goals and them 5-10 guys still give a mouth full cbc dont have a big following so dont expect much $$$ in the til if you playing at home but still nice people (most)


thanks for reminding me old farmer

Pooraka have never got close to beating CBCOC by 20 goals at CBC so I am not certain what you are talking about Weasel. By the way if you don't like the banter from the scoreboard bad luck - perhaps you and the other 3 Pooraka supporters who come to our ground and fill our till with your riches could pop over to the scoreboard and voice your concerns (p.s. I am one of those "assholes" you referred to )

i watched you guys run your mouth in the B grade game when you lost by 20 goals some of the talk was pretty bad and then in the A grade it got better id suggest this year you watch a few of the remarks you make towards to players i heard some things that could land you in trouble with the saafl (racist remarks)

[Wild Thing]

Ohhh the B Grade. 20 goals...wow, perhaps you should swap your A and B Grades around.

Also, thanks for the advice - I will be sure to ignore it. Seeing as we are giving advice how about you concentrate on getting a kick instead of watching the spectators at the scoreboard? I suppose next thing you are going to tell me that no one at Pooraka has anything to say when opposition teams come to visit?

Lastly, don't make crap up - yes we are vocal but not racist

[Grahaml]

any news on who got the salisbury b grade coaches gig

Steve couzner. Salisbury are in div 3, don't know why you asked in the div 4 forum.

sorry mate
was chasing salisbury west b grade
led to believe that their was interviews during the week

Nathan Sidwell is B grade coach.

[lovetotalkfooty]

any news on who got the salisbury b grade coaches gig

Steve couzner. Salisbury are in div 3, don't know why you asked in the div 4 forum.

sorry mate
was chasing salisbury west b grade
led to believe that their was interviews during the week

Nathan Sidwell is B grade coach.

What happened to Daniel Schell???

[Footy Follower]

CBC oval is sometimes good and sometimes weird the grass can be so spongey and other times perfect... great BBQ and very nice set up and friendly[/quote]

I would disagree with you here GW (on the friendly part that is). I played there a few years back the year when they played PAC in the GF. When we played them there (and lost) and the supporters there on the upper level near the stairs were very vocal all day, mostly very abusive. Now normally I would say all is fair during the game, however the supporters continued to sledge as we were walking past them off the ground. Very nearly created a scuffle between players and spectators. No I would consider CBC to be quite unfriendly, and I know a few of the lads that play there.

[Gatt_Weasel]

CBC oval is sometimes good and sometimes weird the grass can be so spongey and other times perfect... great BBQ and very nice set up and friendly

I would disagree with you here GW (on the friendly part that is). I played there a few years back the year when they played PAC in the GF. When we played them there (and lost) and the supporters there on the upper level near the stairs were very vocal all day, mostly very abusive. Now normally I would say all is fair during the game, however the supporters continued to sledge as we were walking past them off the ground. Very nearly created a scuffle between players and spectators. No I would consider CBC to be quite unfriendly, and I know a few of the lads that play there.[/quote]


i guess different people and clubs have different views......and to the cbc guy who claims to be part of the scoreboard hicks yes racial taunts were yelled out to one of our players i heard it clear as day i have no need to lie sad truth is you probably not the sharpest tools in the shed you get that scoreboard wrong a lot

[The Ash Man]

how many other players have not played against some of the teams in div 4 personally i got a few

1. Plympton (never played on the oval or know where it is)
2. Hectorville (never played against probably get lost looking for this ground)
3. Hope Valley
4. Brahma Lodge

Plympton runs east weast so good luck with that, but you want to hope you get them on their ladies day as it makes travelling there all worth while

Hectorville is a bigger than average ground so someone like you GW who likes the easy ball will love it, you will enjoy the banter from the two old blokes sitting on the balcony

Hope Valley is a small ground and can get very muddy but held together very well last year - change rooms are great and if you get on the right side of FC, she will even strap you - also stay away from Magoos corner

Brahma Lodge is slightly bigger than Hope Valley and generally holds together ok except down the clubroom end where the soccer club trains, gets chewed up pretty bad - dont make a mistake in the backline at the club room end as you will be biatch for the rest of the day

[Grahaml]

What happened to Daniel Schell???

He didn't apply for the job. I don't know whether he's looking at trying his hand coaching another club or anything, but at least to my understanding there was no ill will.

[Q.]

What happened to Daniel Schell???

He didn't apply for the job. I don't know whether he's looking at trying his hand coaching another club or anything, but at least to my understanding there was no ill will.

Thought I read elsewhere he applied for the Smithfield job.

[Wild Thing]

CBC oval is sometimes good and sometimes weird the grass can be so spongey and other times perfect... great BBQ and very nice set up and friendly

I would disagree with you here GW (on the friendly part that is). I played there a few years back the year when they played PAC in the GF. When we played them there (and lost) and the supporters there on the upper level near the stairs were very vocal all day, mostly very abusive. Now normally I would say all is fair during the game, however the supporters continued to sledge as we were walking past them off the ground. Very nearly created a scuffle between players and spectators. No I would consider CBC to be quite unfriendly, and I know a few of the lads that play there.

i guess different people and clubs have different views......and to the cbc guy who claims to be part of the scoreboard hicks yes racial taunts were yelled out to one of our players i heard it clear as day i have no need to lie sad truth is you probably not the sharpest tools in the shed you get that scoreboard wrong a lot[/quote]

I won't argue that some of the boys are vocal and can get carried away sometimes but sounds to me like you need your hearing checked - once again vocal yes, racist no. I've heard it all over the years and been on the end of plenty of abuse - so what? I couldn't care less what you call me, no skin off my nose - blokes are far too precious these days. Tell me did you run home and tell mummy that those bad boys called you names at the football?

[dee man]

What happened to Daniel Schell???

He didn't apply for the job. I don't know whether he's looking at trying his hand coaching another club or anything, but at least to my understanding there was no ill will.

sorry mate,but you better think again

[dee man]

What happened to Daniel Schell???

He didn't apply for the job. I don't know whether he's looking at trying his hand coaching another club or anything, but at least to my understanding there was no ill will.

Thought I read elsewhere he applied for the Smithfield job.

did have a chat with them but the job was gone before anyone had even spoken to them
another case of advertising because of constitution but was a great learning experience for him

[Lightning McQueen]

did have a chat with them but the job was gone before anyone had even spoken to them
another case of advertising because of constitution but was a great learning experience for him

That's bullshit, it is constitutional for one reason, to elect the best possible coach available at the current time. Andy was no walk up start for the job, he would've got it because he must've given the best presentation and had players staying or coming back.
Whether you like his style or you don't, Andy has always been good at gaining respect from his player's and they always seem to stick by him.
I personally don't know who I would've chosen, it would've come down to what they could bring to the Smithfield Football Club, I wasn't in the meeting's so I have no opinion. All 3 applicant's had merit on paper, even you dee man, they asked my opinion and they were holding off for as long as possible for you to get back to them after you showed initial interest.
The last coaches they have had.
Andy Stewart: Units for a year or two, Smithfield juniors for a long time prior.
Joss denengelse: Former Salisbury North player.
Paul Oldacre: Burnside/Kensington amongst other clubs.
Bill Schutt: Woody South.

No rules stating a coach comes from inhouse mate.

[The Rooster]

CBC oval is sometimes good and sometimes weird the grass can be so spongey and other times perfect... great BBQ and very nice set up and friendly

I would disagree with you here GW (on the friendly part that is). I played there a few years back the year when they played PAC in the GF. When we played them there (and lost) and the supporters there on the upper level near the stairs were very vocal all day, mostly very abusive. Now normally I would say all is fair during the game, however the supporters continued to sledge as we were walking past them off the ground. Very nearly created a scuffle between players and spectators. No I would consider CBC to be quite unfriendly, and I know a few of the lads that play there.

i guess different people and clubs have different views......and to the cbc guy who claims to be part of the scoreboard hicks yes racial taunts were yelled out to one of our players i heard it clear as day i have no need to lie sad truth is you probably not the sharpest tools in the shed you get that scoreboard wrong a lot

I won't argue that some of the boys are vocal and can get carried away sometimes but sounds to me like you need your hearing checked - once again vocal yes, racist no. I've heard it all over the years and been on the end of plenty of abuse - so what? I couldn't care less what you call me, no skin off my nose - blokes are far too precious these days. Tell me did you run home and tell mummy that those bad boys called you names at the football?[/quote]

So why do you sit on the opposite side of the ground to everyone else again??

[Grahaml]

What happened to Daniel Schell???

He didn't apply for the job. I don't know whether he's looking at trying his hand coaching another club or anything, but at least to my understanding there was no ill will.

sorry mate,but you better think again

If you wish to add more information feel free, but vague comments just make you look like a stirrer.

[dee man]

did have a chat with them but the job was gone before anyone had even spoken to them
another case of advertising because of constitution but was a great learning experience for him

That's bullshit, it is constitutional for one reason, to elect the best possible coach available at the current time. Andy was no walk up start for the job, he would've got it because he must've given the best presentation and had players staying or coming back.
Whether you like his style or you don't, Andy has always been good at gaining respect from his player's and they always seem to stick by him.
I personally don't know who I would've chosen, it would've come down to what they could bring to the Smithfield Football Club, I wasn't in the meeting's so I have no opinion. All 3 applicant's had merit on paper, even you dee man, they asked my opinion and they were holding off for as long as possible for you to get back to them after you showed initial interest.
The last coaches they have had.
Andy Stewart: Units for a year or two, Smithfield juniors for a long time prior.
Joss denengelse: Former Salisbury North player.
Paul Oldacre: Burnside/Kensington amongst other clubs.
Bill Schutt: Woody South.

No rules stating a coach comes from inhouse mate.

have no problems with Andy getting the job,i think he did a wonderful job last season and was a shoe in for the position
players from smithfield had already told me that he was coaching their again next season whether anyone wants to admit it or not
i never went for the job or considered it but initially made enquireies on behalf of someone who wanted to go for the position

he did get an interview but my name was not mentioned due to the fact that he wanted to interview on behalf of himself and show his talents and what he could bring to the club
in the end smithfield have selected a coach and a good coach at that ,and i do believe he deserved a second go to finish what he had started

[Lightning McQueen]

did have a chat w
have no problems with Andy getting the job,i think he did a wonderful job last season and was a shoe in for the position
players from smithfield had already told me that he was coaching their again next season whether anyone wants to admit it or not
i never went for the job or considered it but initially made enquireies on behalf of someone who wanted to go for the position

he did get an interview but my name was not mentioned due to the fact that he wanted to interview on behalf of himself and show his talents and what he could bring to the club
in the end smithfield have selected a coach and a good coach at that ,and i do believe he deserved a second go to finish what he had started

Andy was no shoe-in mate and the committee select's the coach, not the players. Andy had one thing going in his favour and that was he coached the group in 2012.
At no stage until after the interviews were conducted did the committee make their choice, the interviews we're spread out over a week aswell IIRC.

[dee man]

What happened to Daniel Schell???

He didn't apply for the job. I don't know whether he's looking at trying his hand coaching another club or anything, but at least to my understanding there was no ill will.

sorry mate,but you better think again

If you wish to add more information feel free, but vague comments just make you look like a stirrer.

not stirring at all mate
know for a fact that he was told he wasnt going to get the job
he came to see me about what he should do due to the fact that when he was told the presentation night was coming up
and did not know whether to go or not
i not only work and assosiate with him but also ex presidents of the clubs and several players and fathers and they all say the same thing
i agree its the clubs right to pick who they want and i have no problem with that but for me and the little i know to loose someone of his standing as a young family man,a person who has high ethical and moralistic views which he proves with his actions and willingness to help out has me bemused and confused
personally i would think that a club could not afford to loose someone like that
and the fact that players have also showed their absolute faith in him and ackowledged that by their approaches to him and his future plans shows that
and to think he was offered a great chance to learn at a good club under a great coach but knocked that back in the belief that he was wanted has made him well aware that you can never assume anything especially when they are only words