SAAFL Div 4 & 4R (2010)

[One Eyed]

Mate would love to have him but cant compete with the $$$ he will get offered. Probably less likely as Adam appears to be retirining ... Hope not but likely.

Brett would own div 4

[Choccies]

Yeah agree with you there on both points. Trying to compete with country clubs who can offer $600 a game is difficult...

[One Eyed]

mate . he is s really good bloke Brett and what ever he does will be ok by us .. trust me we will give him many phone calls ha ha

[turk186]

this has blown way out of control.
thats the reason i dont make comments are say this that and the other is becuse when u get flogged in a GF it comes back to bite you, and very hard.
i might a slight joke in reference to the knee and everyone has gone and got their leather g strings in a knot.
im over it all.. we lost they won.
bring on div 3 next year, might see u there the year after turk

Hope so Johno..but you guys might be in Div 2 by then

Hefty... absolutly correct it was all us.. I am not condoning it in any way shape or form and we have co-operated fully with SAAFL in bringing the offender to order .. but IMO there was some provocation, not from the Grovers but the umpiring standard over those 2 games at Harpers Field, stats dont lie.... and at no time have I had a crack at the GGFC over the issue...but I'm interested, did you see the incident or are you acting on 2nd hand info.

From my POV the respect that exists between our clubs thanks to blokes like Choccies is excellent and I will do everything I can to keep it that way.
Having said that my personnel view is that we were "umpired" out of those two games and that's based on the 7 point total margin, the stats on free's and standing there watching both those games in terrible conditions

Again well done to both Pooraka and Golden Grove on going to Div 3....again the stats/facts dont lie.

[Iron Fist]

this has blown way out of control.
thats the reason i dont make comments are say this that and the other is becuse when u get flogged in a GF it comes back to bite you, and very hard.
i might a slight joke in reference to the knee and everyone has gone and got their leather g strings in a knot.
im over it all.. we lost they won.
bring on div 3 next year, might see u there the year after turk

Hope so Johno..but you guys might be in Div 2 by then

Hefty... absolutly correct it was all us.. I am not condoning it in any way shape or form and we have co-operated fully with SAAFL in bringing the offender to order .. but IMO there was some provocation, not from the Grovers but the umpiring standard over those 2 games at Harpers Field, stats dont lie.... and at no time have I had a crack at the GGFC over the issue...but I'm interested, did you see the incident or are you acting on 2nd hand info.

From my POV the respect that exists between our clubs thanks to blokes like Choccies is excellent and I will do everything I can to keep it that way.
Having said that my personnel view is that we were "umpired" out of those two games and that's based on the 7 point total margin, the stats on free's and standing there watching both those games in terrible conditions

Again well done to both Pooraka and Golden Grove on going to Div 3....again the stats/facts dont lie.

to say that is pretty unfair Turk and sounds like you think you guys deserve to be in GG's position.
I have no involvement with either club and didnt see the game but im sure there would have been missed oportunitys on both sides. Points that should have been goals. High tackles on both sides that were probs missed. Sure the umpires make mistakes but I reckon they would make less then the players would during a game.

[turk186]

Fisty... again this is my view only and does not represent the views of Greenacres FC.
and you are asolutely correct without doubt there were missed opportunities on both sides... ask Geelong about umpire decisions in close games....
opinion and bumholes.....we all have one

[Johno6]

greenies kick straight they prob win both games??

i honestly think greenies will be in div 3 next year.
and the rivalry will begin again!

on a side note, u cant hold a whole club responsible for the posts of ppl on this forum.

u gotta blame the d1ckhead behind the alias...


that being said, enjoy the off season everybody....and enjoy the camel toes

[Choccies]

this has blown way out of control.
thats the reason i dont make comments are say this that and the other is becuse when u get flogged in a GF it comes back to bite you, and very hard.
i might a slight joke in reference to the knee and everyone has gone and got their leather g strings in a knot.
im over it all.. we lost they won.
bring on div 3 next year, might see u there the year after turk

Hope so Johno..but you guys might be in Div 2 by then

Hefty... absolutly correct it was all us.. I am not condoning it in any way shape or form and we have co-operated fully with SAAFL in bringing the offender to order .. but IMO there was some provocation, not from the Grovers but the umpiring standard over those 2 games at Harpers Field, stats dont lie.... and at no time have I had a crack at the GGFC over the issue...but I'm interested, did you see the incident or are you acting on 2nd hand info.

From my POV the respect that exists between our clubs thanks to blokes like Choccies is excellent and I will do everything I can to keep it that way.
Having said that my personnel view is that we were "umpired" out of those two games and that's based on the 7 point total margin, the stats on free's and standing there watching both those games in terrible conditions

Again well done to both Pooraka and Golden Grove on going to Div 3....again the stats/facts dont lie.

to say that is pretty unfair Turk and sounds like you think you guys deserve to be in GG's position.
I have no involvement with either club and didnt see the game but im sure there would have been missed oportunitys on both sides. Points that should have been goals. High tackles on both sides that were probs missed. Sure the umpires make mistakes but I reckon they would make less then the players would during a game.

So you saying we were "umpired in" then turk ??? I honestly think that is an unfair representation of the effort our boys put in. Look, in the end no-one deserved to lose either of those games but someone had to. Who took these stats by the way ?

[Footy Follower]

you all telling me that if the opposition walked in the same pub your in after 24 hours of celebrating you would be all gracious about it and give them a hug, i would have broke out the club song straight away. As for the knee incident that only you seem to be going on about Jonno, get over it or go and play netball, it was a grand final mate, maybe your boys should have been as hard.

Kneeing someone in the head isn't being hard farmer.... maybe thats the way they did it back in the old days at Ingle Farm because they knew no better but the game doesn't need it and a team up by 10 goals doesn't need to do it.

agree the kneeing wasnt called for, but i wonder how the incident started. me thinks a GG player took flattened Kane Moore after he took a mark to line up for his 8th goal, that was a pathetic effort from that player. always the case of it takes two to tango.

anyway as a former player of the bulls, you done yourself and the club proud. should of won by 80pts , totally out classed GG in every way. ditts, nubbo and Frank Scott i take my hat off to you 3, you all have hung around in the hard times when anything could of happened to this great club without your hard work the club wouldnt of been able to achieve what they did. and wattsy gotta love you mate.

Lets get this right, I was going to be lining up for my 9th.

[turk186]

Choccies ..I am not getting into a he said she said especially with you....my gripe is not with you or your club or your posters

I feel much the same as anybody else that gets beaten in a close game ....ripped off

Stats are taken by the same bloke every week for the last couple of years ...why? do you want to try and get him to cross over?

[Lance's brother]

Luke Nathan won our Best and Fairest on Friday night by a small margin from Luke Radley and then Adam Ohara.

Mark Randell was a worthy winner in our B's.

Anyone else had their awards?

[Pag]

Salisbury:

A Grade
1st - Justin McPherson (70)
2nd - Scott McPherson (66)
3rd - Mark Robb (65)

B Grade - Pat Keenihan

C Grade - Josh Pratt

D Grade - Shaun Davies/Jason Rothwell

C7 - Shane Smith

[Hefty]

GG awards were Friday nite and results as follows

1st: J Kuhndt (3 in a row)
2nd: T Sheppard
3rd: J Boxer

Awesome effort by Jimmy who bolted in the B&F!

On a side note...what monkey put together the Div 4 Team of the Year in the budget?? How can T Shep not make the team?? He won the association medal!! It's like leaving Dane Swan out of the All-Australian team!

[Lance's brother]

GG awards were Friday nite and results as follows

1st: J Kuhndt (3 in a row)
2nd: T Sheppard
3rd: J Boxer

Awesome effort by Jimmy who bolted in the B&F!

On a side note...what monkey put together the Div 4 Team of the Year in the budget?? How can T Shep not make the team?? He won the association medal!! It's like leaving Dane Swan out of the All-Australian team!

Won the association medal but not your own??? Can easily happen because umpires see things differently, but I take your point.

Did you put up your crack at Team of the Year Hefty?

[Choccies]

Same happened last year too Lance. John Boxer won the Association Medal and was beaten by Jimmy K in teh club award. 3 in a row for Jimmy who goes 1 ahead of Hefty and 3 ahead of Choccies

[Lance's brother]

Same happened last year too Lance. John Boxer won the Association Medal and was beaten by Jimmy K in teh club award. 3 in a row for Jimmy who goes 1 ahead of Hefty and 3 ahead of Choccies

I can completely understand that Choccies. Jimmy was your best player in my opinion.

Sh!t, he's got 3 more than me too.

[Choccies]

Would have been teh first medal count that Warby wouldn't have featured highly in for a while ? What happend to him this year ??

[Lance's brother]

Would have been teh first medal count that Warby wouldn't have featured highly in for a while ? What happend to him this year ??

Damaged his knee early on, tried to rest it and then come back, but had to yield to surgery in the end. Missed 8 or 9 games all up and we really missed his impact. Should be pretty hungry to have a good season next year I would think.

[One Eyed]

We certainly missed is leg speed this year.

[zedman]

congrats on your re-appointment one_eyed