SA Footy

early season form considered.............. medal contenders? nicholls another 3 u say?? puts him on 9

crowzanddogz wrote:early season form considered.............. medal contenders? nicholls another 3 u say?? puts him on 9

he'd be fighting for votes with Sumner and Woodcock from Saturday

Robb_Stark wrote:number 14 slices and dices

Quality user of the ball by foot, surprises me that he has gone largely unnoticed so far..

Zartan wrote:

Robb_Stark wrote:number 14 slices and dices

Quality user of the ball by foot, surprises me that he has gone largely unnoticed so far..

got a free ride on the wing and linked up well

Q. wrote:

crowzanddogz wrote:early season form considered.............. medal contenders? nicholls another 3 u say?? puts him on 9

he'd be fighting for votes with Sumner and Woodcock from Saturday

Woodcock would have to be right up there.

From other clubs:
Mitchell Park - Walczak
Brahma - Steele
Houghton - Cam Schutz always polls well, or Vandermoer
Mawson Lakes - Kennett / King
Ingle Farm - Hancock
Fitzroy - Avery
Woody South - Clark
TOS - Hooker / Spurr
Lutheran - Koenig

steele got the 3 when they played us

65 kicks gets my attention

who else guys? steele obvious

but what bout other teams? walzak? clarke ?

the umpires are very random id put money on F.C getting votes in a few games

crowzanddogz wrote:65 kicks gets my attention

who else guys? steele obvious

but what bout other teams? walzak? clarke ?

Walczak might have a few 1 votes but no 3's. You need to be winning to get them. Steele is the best player I've seen so far, but haven't seen West Croydon. The danger for both the Hawks and Brahma is they would have quite a few taking votes of each other.

Robb_Stark wrote:the umpires are very random id put money on F.C getting votes in a few games

Must've been umps full moon, I don't normally notice umps one way or the other but ours were particularly bad on the weekend.

By no means the reason we lost (being 8 goals down at half time will have something to do with that)

Example: One of our guys went up for a mark, got full on tunnelled - play on was the call.

Few interesting calls in the last quarter in the Mawson Lakes v Ingle Farm game
1. Ingle Farm player takes a contested mark against 3x Mawson Lakes players - free kick against him for "lifting his knee into the back of the player in front"
2. Ingle Farm defender takes mark in defence, as he pushes back to take the kick, another defender goes to move on, is held back by his opponent - kick is reversed, umpire citing Ingle Farm player "holding".
3. Ingle Farm player takes a bounce, takes a few more steps, is done for running too far - umpire says "I didn't see you bounce the ball"

Very ordinary performance over the 4 qtrs. by the umpires.. so bad it was almost comical..

Zartan wrote:Few interesting calls in the last quarter in the Mawson Lakes v Ingle Farm game
1. Ingle Farm player takes a contested mark against 3x Mawson Lakes players - free kick against him for "lifting his knee into the back of the player in front"
2. Ingle Farm defender takes mark in defence, as he pushes back to take the kick, another defender goes to move on, is held back by his opponent - kick is reversed, umpire citing Ingle Farm player "holding".
3. Ingle Farm player takes a bounce, takes a few more steps, is done for running too far - umpire says "I didn't see you bounce the ball"

Very ordinary performance over the 4 qtrs. by the umpires.. so bad it was almost comical..

The umpire paid a free kick to Hawthorn in our game!

cossi11 wrote:

Zartan wrote:Few interesting calls in the last quarter in the Mawson Lakes v Ingle Farm game
1. Ingle Farm player takes a contested mark against 3x Mawson Lakes players - free kick against him for "lifting his knee into the back of the player in front"
2. Ingle Farm defender takes mark in defence, as he pushes back to take the kick, another defender goes to move on, is held back by his opponent - kick is reversed, umpire citing Ingle Farm player "holding".
3. Ingle Farm player takes a bounce, takes a few more steps, is done for running too far - umpire says "I didn't see you bounce the ball"

Very ordinary performance over the 4 qtrs. by the umpires.. so bad it was almost comical..

The umpire paid a free kick to Hawthorn in our game!

You're so behind the times Cos

It's Bulldogs now

Heard West Croydon Players fighting each other Saturday Night back at the club ????

Robb_Stark wrote:Heard West Croydon Players fighting each other Saturday Night back at the club ????

Taking their competitive efforts off field now?

Yank Man wrote:

crowzanddogz wrote:65 kicks gets my attention

who else guys? steele obvious

but what bout other teams? walzak? clarke ?

Walczak might have a few 1 votes but no 3's. You need to be winning to get them. Steele is the best player I've seen so far, but haven't seen West Croydon. The danger for both the Hawks and Brahma is they would have quite a few taking votes of each other.

Was very surprised to see Walczak was name 2nd best for you on the weekend. I thought he might of had max 15 touches (with most in the first half) and then was shut down pretty well by Hayes in the 2nd.

Steele is a gun, has just got better each week after having a very off opening game against West Croydon and is always recognised by the umps because he is at pretty much every stoppage. Thought Brooks played his best game for the club on weekend and he too will just keep getting better I reckon.

Wait til you see Sumner then YM, the kid is a freak... is very fit and is just so clean and skilful both inside and outside of the contest... he would be catching the umpires eyes for sure and imo would be leading the count at the moment given they have won all their games, probably stating the obvious there. Long way to go in the season though..

Footy Chick wrote:

cossi11 wrote:

Zartan wrote:Few interesting calls in the last quarter in the Mawson Lakes v Ingle Farm game
1. Ingle Farm player takes a contested mark against 3x Mawson Lakes players - free kick against him for "lifting his knee into the back of the player in front"
2. Ingle Farm defender takes mark in defence, as he pushes back to take the kick, another defender goes to move on, is held back by his opponent - kick is reversed, umpire citing Ingle Farm player "holding".
3. Ingle Farm player takes a bounce, takes a few more steps, is done for running too far - umpire says "I didn't see you bounce the ball"

Very ordinary performance over the 4 qtrs. by the umpires.. so bad it was almost comical..

The umpire paid a free kick to Hawthorn in our game!

You're so behind the times Cos

It's Bulldogs now

Of course... changes weekly depending on who Adelaide is playing

Sumner was one of the players yellow carded on the weekend lost his cool very easy in the 4th quarter but if Q is correct not recorded

I would say the umpiring in our B grade game was better than the A grade game on the weekend. I rate our B grade umpire higher than most A grade umpires anyway, even though I enjoy ribbing him as much as any other person I know, he does a consistent job every week.

Another tough day for TOS Saturday in all 3 grades. A grade showed some ticker to be 3 goals up at 3 qtr time but ran out of legs in the last and Woody South got over the line. In the B grade, a well drilled WS were just too good for our lads, 3 in a row now, need to respond against Lutheran this week in both grades..

A grade 1-5, biggest loss is 24 points, but haven't played West Croydon yet, so that is likely to change. Need to win the close games on the way home and we can still figure in finals, only 1 game from 5th as it stands now. B grade need to be ahead of the ledger at the midway mark, and im confident we can respond in the second half of the season and still figure strongly at the business end..

human_torpedo wrote:I would say the umpiring in our B grade game was better than the A grade game on the weekend. I rate our B grade umpire higher than most A grade umpires anyway, even though I enjoy ribbing him as much as any other person I know, he does a consistent job every week.

Another tough day for TOS Saturday in all 3 grades. A grade showed some ticker to be 3 goals up at 3 qtr time but ran out of legs in the last and Woody South got over the line. In the B grade, a well drilled WS were just too good for our lads, 3 in a row now, need to respond against Lutheran this week in both grades..

A grade 1-5, biggest loss is 24 points, but haven't played West Croydon yet, so that is likely to change. Need to win the close games on the way home and we can still figure in finals, only 1 game from 5th as it stands now. B grade need to be ahead of the ledger at the midway mark, and im confident we can respond in the second half of the season and still figure strongly at the business end..

fair to say last year your A grade won all the close ones..this year not winning the close ones so far and the ladder position shows this..