lutz wrote:hotpies wrote:Cash 123 wrote:Yank Man wrote:[quote="Freo HeaveHo"]Yep sorry yank man but that's a rediculous statement. There are plenty of very good players but that's going a bit far.
Seen the results of the U23's lately. Anything is worth a try.

Started something aye? We have one that would.
U IDIOT. DIV 7 V DIV 1. DONT CARE HOW GOOD HE IS SHOULDN'T BE PICKED BASED ON THE FACT HE IS PLAYING DIVISION 7.
AAAAARRGGGGGGHHHH YANK THAT U GOOSE
There are some good players in Div7 mate. Mark Boothy captained Paralowie for years in Div 7 then Div 6. Went to Gepps Cross last season and played all Div 1 games last year and this year so far, starting at HBF. Get your head out of your arse!
Boothy was not U23, he was a seasoned campaigner, and I'd reckon did a pre-season with Gepps before playing in their A grade. The pressure of a D1 game is miles in front of that of a D7 game, so no matter how good someone looks in D7, I don't think they'd be as prepared as a similar player in D1.
As an example, Nic Meiers was U23 when he won the D7 association medal a few years back, he's a good player sure, but has never played in Henley's B grade, let alone the State U23's![/quote]
Is it that crazy to think a guy who is U23 playing Div 7 footy could be good enough for the state U23 side? Sumner from woody south in div 5 last year played in the state U23 side if my memory serves me correctly, and if he stayed at woody south this year he would be a Div 6 player.
Personally I hate it when people try to compare players from different Divs. it's just far to speculative and based purely on people's opinions (most times biased)