SA Footy

I can assure you he was hit twice in the mouth by the two mentioned.

Pag wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

jackpot jim wrote:

Pag wrote:Just saw the Alleway one, cannot fathom how he gets off that.

Easy when theres no report to start with. Whilst an incident may be easily identifiable from watching video footage, during live play things happen in a split second and umpires i think can be excused for missing things like this from time to time as they need to be very sure just what happened to be reporting and sending players off etc.
I guess clubs have the right to make their own reports and use video evidence? Im not sure what the process is?
Also im guessing clubs at times dont want to be seen as dobbers and unless a serious injury resulted from a dog act clubs im guessing would just rather move on and concentrate on next week.
Incidentally Sellar for the Creeks suffered a severe concussion from a rucking contest against Alleway earlier in the season and was forced to miss the following match. Not making any aspersions as to what actually happened there as didnt see it, just the result. Who knows, may have been an accident?
Anyway after the AFL seemingly endorsed Gary Ablett earlier in the season with his wayward elbows who knows whats acceptable these days?

With the clear and damning evidence that we just viewed I think the league should intervene and be proactive.

Yes, it probably would've been missed by the umpires as they are generally fixed on watching where the ball is.

Not blaming the umpire, can't call it if he doesn't see it, but surely the league have seen it now and can call it.

Couldn't care if he's ex-SANFL, it was a deadset snipe after the ball had gone and deserves weeks. If it ends his career, so be it.

My mail is that an official report has been lodged in recent days and though he will be free to play this week end he will face the tribunal next week.

If he is suspended this puts him over the 16 game mark. Meaning Life suspension. De-registered by the SACFL. Would this mean his coaching days are also done?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

After watching the footage he’s gonna need the bloke that got OJ off. As mentioned previously if that happened in the C9AFL you’d be looking at many weeks and probably have your name in the Advertiser for 1-2 days. Terrible looking act and whilst the other incident you could argue was a football incident (if isolated) when you combine both it leaves nothing to the imagination.

LaughingKookaburra wrote:After watching the footage he’s gonna need the bloke that got OJ off. As mentioned previously if that happened in the C9AFL you’d be looking at many weeks and probably have your name in the Advertiser for 1-2 days. Terrible looking act and whilst the other incident you could argue was a football incident (if isolated) when you combine both it leaves nothing to the imagination.

Ask any opposing clubs in the league and this is a reasonably common occurrence from this player in question in what is generally a very clean League.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Anyone watching the live-stream of the count on Youtube?

Seem to be having bad connection issues meaning the stream is choppy as anything...

Winner of Mail Medal 2019 - Daniel Bass (Willunga) 26 votes

Followed by:
Ellis (Mc) 24
Sellar (LH) 24
Vitkunas (MC) 22

Tonkin has been running the league for years yet still can't pronounce Langhorne Creek properly. There is no S in Langhorne Gordon.

Down the Hill wrote:Followed by:
Ellis (Mc) 24
Sellar (LH) 24
Vitkunas (MC) 22

Tonkin has been running the league for years yet still can't pronounce Langhorne Creek properly. There is no S in Langhorne Gordon.

1. It’s not Gordon
2. Gordon isn’t president any more
3. Gordon is from LC and isn’t that naive


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[img]https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20190828/5bfb3244771101029da0f59af6fa3641.jpg[/img]

[emoji57] Didn’t go near each other?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Deleted double post

footy1992 wrote:Anyone watching the live-stream of the count on Youtube?

Seem to be having bad connection issues meaning the stream is choppy as anything...

Yeah it was pretty awful.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Apologies to Gordon, didn't realise Terry Cameron was the new boss or is that Terry Camerons.

Down the Hill wrote:Apologies to Gordon, didn't realise Terry Cameron was the new boss or is that Terry Camerons.

You’re getting there DTH. It’s Terry Corcoran(s).


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Heck, that wasn’t my finest hour on SA Footy. Anyway, congratulations to Daniel Bass.

Down the Hill wrote:Heck, that wasn’t my finest hour on SA Footy. Anyway, congratulations to Daniel Bass.

Don't worry about it Down the Hills.

"Grasshopper" My mail is that an official report has been lodged in recent days and though he will be free to play this week end he will face the tribunal next week.

If he is suspended this puts him over the 16 game mark. Meaning Life suspension. De-registered by the SACFL. Would this mean his coaching days are also done?

If this is actually correct Grasshopper what you say about him being free to play this week but sitting next week then it’s totally crap from the SFL. I’m pretty sure the constitution says that a player who is reported cannot play until they have sat at the tribunal.

I feel for the opposition players, if he knows next week he is likely to get life ban then what’s to stop him this week going out all guns blazing especially with the reputation he has. Not a good look at all or New President Terry Corcoran and the GSFL


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk[/quote]

If the GSFL rules are the same as the SFL rules then if a player is reported by a club official or by the league deciding to conduct its own investigation then a tribunal/investigation committee is not convened to hear the matter until the following week and the player is free to play until then. I don't have a problem with that because it's still a better outcome than not having any power to look into a matter if it was missed by the umpires on the day.

Medal votes by club

26 Daniel Bass
18 Sean Beath
11 Bradley Haskett
7 Tyson Hoffmann
4 Billy Cook
4 Sam Alexopoulos
3 Braden Altus
2 Brett Miegel
2 Timothy Boyd
2 Cameron Hutchens
2 Jake Standfield
81 Willunga

22 Ziggy Vitkunas
18 Steven Copestick
10 Tom Pinyon
8 Peter Hoban
5 Michael Corbett
4 Braden Ritter
3 Shane Heatley
3 Adam Hunter
2 Tomas Vitkunas
75 Compass

12 Benjamin Yeomans
11 Clint Alleway
11 Sam Basham
9 Michael Ross
7 Leslie Weetra
4 Jack McKAY
3 Luke Davey
3 Ryan Fletcher
3 Brok Schubert
2 Ben Basham
2 Billy Wade
1 Eljay Connors
68 Victor

24 James Sellar
10 Angus Lally
7 Caleb Howell
5 Matthew Dominish
5 Jarrod Kellock
4 Coby Helyar
3 Ben Arbon
3 Thomas Derham
3 Curtis Perrey
2 Lachlan Mcgregor
1 Troy Blackwell
67 Creek

24 Brett Ellis
8 James Mathews
6 Codey Ellison
4 Heath Lambert
4 Brendan Gill
4 Jess Watchman
4 Lachlan Mathews
3 Joel Vandeleur
3 William Gregory
2 Max Wakefield
1 Evan Williams
63 McLaren

14 Marc Elliott
12 Ben Simounds
8 Mark Tucker
7 Todd Price
6 Richard O'Grady
2 Brad James
2 Ethan Bell
2 Tom McNamara
1 Cooper Machin
1 Sam Elliott
55 Strathalbyn

13 Callum Tonkin
10 Tyson Neale
5 Tyler Baldock
5 Thomas Bonnes
6 Tarik Illingworth
4 Patrick Barrett
3 Jack Crispin
2 Nicholas Marshall
1 Kenn Campbell
49 Bays

10 Xavier Gotch
6 Joshua Wilson
5 Jacob Laba
6 Jono Lee
3 Zac Edwards
3 Trent Kelly
3 Benjamin McConnell
2 Adam Braendler
2 John Hinge
1 Jesse Fitzgerald
1 Ryan Fisher
1 Campbell Bellaney
43 Yankalilla

6 Daniel Fry
6 Brock Godwin-Knott
4 Todd Marsh
4 James Fry
3 Ethan Cinc
3 Ryan Griffen
2 Scott Paul
1 Thomas Neville
29 GPE

4 Josh Donohue
2 Bradley Clarke
2 Jake Spinks
1 Damien Hill
1 Brady O'Hanlon
10 Pongy

Mail medal votes per club and club votes per win
Willunga ........81.......5.59
Compass.......75.......5.56
Victor.............68.......5.67
Cree.k............67.......5.15
McLaren........63.......5.25
Strathalbyn...55.......5.50
Bays...............49.......7.00
Yankalilla.......43.......8.60
GPE................29......14.50
Pongy............10......10.00
540

Did Simon Phillips play much at Pongy?