Adelaide Plains Football League

[Dogwatcher]

Both of those comps would be stronger than APFL wouldn't they?
The APFL person I spoke to today suggested that Robertstown was going to have to do a lot of work anyway if they were to lift to the standard of the APFL - he said they currently would be the equivalent of an APFL B grade side or even an under 18s team.

[The Big Shrek]

Barossa would be, NEFL probably about the same. However if you are a junior the A grade standard doesn't really matter much, you'll go to the closest league. Where do the Robby kids go to school.

[sparky]

I would say the kids go to Eudunda as it's only 20km down the road.

[Dogwatcher]

The antipathy between Robertstown and Eudunda footy clubs is pretty strong.

[sparky]

I know the feeling between the two, i was meaning that the kids go to school there at a guess.

[Dogwatcher]

Those kids are part of those footy clubs - I reckon their opinions would be the same as their parents in most cases.

[mighty hounds]

People involved in Mid Murray footy (and not involved with Robertstown) believe it very unlikely Robbie will be accepted in the APFL.
Apparently though, the netballers have got all excited about the change and have designed new uniforms.

If the women want to come to the APFL (and most of the lads out that way are married) I'm sure their decision is just about made .......... Bobtown for APFL.

PS: Congrats on your campaigning re the Mercy Rule Jumbo. From your first post to your most recent the mercy rule reversal has been your "BABY". I spose you can sleep better at night now mate, and the mental development of 15-17 year old Adelaide Plains kids can go on un-tarnished!

You will remain a blogger on here won't you? There will be other issues I'm sure!

hahahahaha, im sure he has lots to say but is keeping it to himself

[crazyfootball madman]

is wilmer the best old player getting around?maybe a premiship yr for him.did goodie return sat?fun and games at that club,hear he is returning to his old club

[jumbo]

Here is the mail kids Robertstown def in apfl next yaer

APFL voted last night to accept RT - now it has to go to SANFL for their Yay or Nay.

Jumbo....is that confirmed?

I believe at the league meeting Monday night the Board asked all clubs to vote on it - pushing the line that it needs to begin the process in order to meet SANFL deadlines. Clubs were not given the chance to take the question back to their members but had to vote then and there.

So yes - confirmed. My source is extremely reliable.

Now for an APFL league classic - to go to the "Only in the APFL Meetings" files. After a season of being told that no-one has anything good to say about the mercy rule - it was discussed ad-nauseam at every meeting and Mondays meeting as well - the APFL was not too concerned about having a vote on the subject - what the?! BUT they put to an urgent vote the Robertstown issue - I don't like to be precious but come on - that's no how you make porridge!!!

[jumbo]

People involved in Mid Murray footy (and not involved with Robertstown) believe it very unlikely Robbie will be accepted in the APFL.
Apparently though, the netballers have got all excited about the change and have designed new uniforms.

If the women want to come to the APFL (and most of the lads out that way are married) I'm sure their decision is just about made .......... Bobtown for APFL.

PS: Congrats on your campaigning re the Mercy Rule Jumbo. From your first post to your most recent the mercy rule reversal has been your "BABY". I spose you can sleep better at night now mate, and the mental development of 15-17 year old Adelaide Plains kids can go on un-tarnished!

You will remain a blogger on here won't you? There will be other issues I'm sure!

hahahahaha, im sure he has lots to say but is keeping it to himself

Thanks KB - not sure if anyone was listening but it was good to get it off my chest. In the end common sense won out and it got the flick. I often wonder what other football people think when they heard about the APFL innovation!

Don't worry - MH is right - I will have my say at times.

[jumbo]

is wilmer the best old player getting around?maybe a premiship yr for him.did goodie return sat?fun and games at that club,hear he is returning to his old club

What Wilmer from Balaklava? You should be doing stand up CFM .......

[jumbo]

Can always kick them out again!

Adds a bit of interest to the league. My worry is that Robby players especially juniors may leave for clubs which travel less. Auburn was a part of HWE but everyone left for Min Man. I'm not sure but wouldn't the NEFL or Barossa involve less travel for Robby people than the APFL?

Reckon the Robertstown Bus company would be rubbing their hands together. Plenty of jobs coming up in 2009.

Might start one up in Adelaide Plains as well

[jumbo]

Probably too early - I believe RT wears Green and Gold which will clash with Balak - will they have another guernsey when playing Balak or change colours completely? One of the issues - one of many I'm sure.

[callop]

I'm interested as to why Robertstown are keen to join the AP?. Surely if the NEFL is closer and of a similar standard to that of the APFL you would go to the closer league?? I agree with DW, they would seriously have a lot of work to do if they are keen to join either of those leagues. Will be interesting.

[The Big Shrek]

Geez, just had a look at the map. Every team except Blyth/Snowtown and BSR are closer to Robertstown than any APFL side.

Maybe they should take Robby and we'll take RSMU or Blyth/Snowtown.

[jumbo]

Geez, just had a look at the map. Every team except Blyth/Snowtown and BSR are closer to Robertstown than any APFL side.

Maybe they should take Robby and we'll take RSMU or Blyth/Snowtown.

Now thats a good idea - maybe thats the sort of feedback that could come from the SANFL.

[Mythical Creature]

And the best news I have heard for a long long time out of the APFL - clubs VOTE OUT the U17s mercy rule for season 2009.

Finally some common sense - the 3 clubs that still think its a good idea really need to have a look at what this ridiculous rule is currently doing for junior development. The U17 coaches don't want it but still are having it pushed down their throats by ill informed committee and delegates.

At least it is now gone - hopefully for ever.

Good news Jumbo! Who are the 3 clubs that still think its a good idea? Hang on, Let me guess, Hummocks, Hamley and Mallala!

I heard the U/14's was voted in to stay the same as it is this year.

[TimmiesChin]

I'm interested as to why Robertstown are keen to join the AP?. Surely if the NEFL is closer and of a similar standard to that of the APFL you would go to the closer league?? I agree with DW, they would seriously have a lot of work to do if they are keen to join either of those leagues. Will be interesting.

They would be joining because the MMFL is in some trouble and down to 4 sides I guess.

Will be interesting as their current lineup wouldnt get anywhere near a APFL A grade side.
I cant see how their population can support a side in that league ... as it is they are regularly forfeiting B grade games due to lack of numbers, and have players playing 2 games each week.
With Eudunda just down the road - and the stronger of the two clubs. even if their scores dont suggest it - Eudunda would flog Robertstown (if their money hasnt run out), they dont have the population to support a side in a higer quality league.
So basically I think they are going to a place they wont be able to recover from, and have a fear that it could be the start of their downfall, and perhaps the Eudunda/Robertstown football club. (Even though they hate each other they have a merged cricket team... and common sense will need to prevail)

[Mythical Creature]

Personally I can see this Robertstown thing as a big positive for the league! RT are reportedly a financial club but have no paid players. Moving to our league will help them with that cause as town players don't really have to travel too far to play. Yes there will be a few teething issues in the first 2 years and yes they might not be up in the top 3 sides next year, but in ten years time all of these issues will be resolved and the league will be better off for it. It is very hard to try and encourage clubs to change leagues and when one comes knocking on the door you would be very silly to knock them back. Besides if worse comes to worse and they fold in 3 years time what have we lost?

RT have lost a few players lately but when you look at the conditions they play in I would leave too. They play in a five team comp with one of those teams having only an A grade and nothing else. That means their B Grade and kids are only playing 3 in every 5 weeks. No wonder they all want to leave. I applaud RT for jumping the gun and getting off the sinking ship of the MMFL whilst they still can!

RT has a Primary School with about 60 kids so juniors shouldn't be a problem. Apparently their team colours are Green & Gold with their logo being the Kangaroos. I'm sure they could just change their colours to blue & white, still keep their nickname and not clash with any other sides.

All in all I see this as a positive move by the league as gaining clubs is always a better position than losing them!

PS: If you don't like the idea of RT coming in then speak to your delegates because EVERY club voted in favour of accepting them.

(Sh!t my fingers are sore from typing now)

[jumbo]

And the best news I have heard for a long long time out of the APFL - clubs VOTE OUT the U17s mercy rule for season 2009.

Finally some common sense - the 3 clubs that still think its a good idea really need to have a look at what this ridiculous rule is currently doing for junior development. The U17 coaches don't want it but still are having it pushed down their throats by ill informed committee and delegates.

At least it is now gone - hopefully for ever.

Good news Jumbo! Who are the 3 clubs that still think its a good idea? Hang on, Let me guess, Hummocks, Hamley and Mallala!

I heard the U/14's was voted in to stay the same as it is this year.

Yes - great news MC - and I think you are spot on with your guess. I know Hamley coaches don't want it but committee seem to think it is good - go figure! Mallala confuse me - their coach is not a fan (I think) - maybe they feel some form of embarrassment being solid supporters from the start and find themselves in a difficult position. Hummocks also confuse me - there is a real example of why it is not needed - they have been getting pumped for a number of years - this season fielding a very competitive team - didn't seem to hurt their kids - probably made them hungrier.

And again yes - I understand the U14s is still in place.