SA Footy

OnSong wrote:There's a system in place to prescribe penalties for incidents.
Drainer broke Mitch Daniel's jaw a couple of years back, Daniel missed 6, Drainer missed 3.
Going on that precedent, two seems right, although both would be lenient in my opinion, although I did not see the Bruggemann incident, just going on what I've heard about Tyler's injuries.

OnSong wrote:So you're saying if there was video evidence of the above incident, the penalty would be worse?

OnSong wrote:There's a system in place to prescribe penalties for incidents.
Drainer broke Mitch Daniel's jaw a couple of years back, Daniel missed 6, Drainer missed 3.
Going on that precedent, two seems right, although both would be lenient in my opinion, although I did not see the Bruggemann incident, just going on what I've heard about Tyler's injuries.

mighty hounds wrote:

OnSong wrote:There's a system in place to prescribe penalties for incidents.
Drainer broke Mitch Daniel's jaw a couple of years back, Daniel missed 6, Drainer missed 3.
Going on that precedent, two seems right, although both would be lenient in my opinion, although I did not see the Bruggemann incident, just going on what I've heard about Tyler's injuries.

Before he delivered the hit he kicked him while he was on the ground, 2 does seem lenient.

mighty hounds wrote:

OnSong wrote:There's a system in place to prescribe penalties for incidents.
Drainer broke Mitch Daniel's jaw a couple of years back, Daniel missed 6, Drainer missed 3.
Going on that precedent, two seems right, although both would be lenient in my opinion, although I did not see the Bruggemann incident, just going on what I've heard about Tyler's injuries.

Before he delivered the hit he kicked him while he was on the ground, 2 does seem lenient.

OnSong wrote:Will update tipping table today!

Balak 80+
Mallala 1-39
Virginia 80+
United 80+

Mythical Creature wrote:

OnSong wrote:Will update tipping table today!

Balak 80+
Mallala 1-39
Virginia 80+
United 80+

x2

Lame Choice wrote:

OnSong wrote:There's a system in place to prescribe penalties for incidents.
Drainer broke Mitch Daniel's jaw a couple of years back, Daniel missed 6, Drainer missed 3.
Going on that precedent, two seems right, although both would be lenient in my opinion, although I did not see the Bruggemann incident, just going on what I've heard about Tyler's injuries.

The prescribed penalty system is a country football cop out to avoid proper and fair tribunal. Video cameras cost SFA and there should be one at each end of each game. $1k investment by the league tops (about a one week return for some players). Verbal evidence is worth squat as people lie through their teeth.
Footage would at least kerb the more moronic actions. I wouldn't put Gus in this class based on Saturday - but he would never have done this in the past two years. And if he did, he would have been handed plenty.

And while I'm on it, guess who are the worst perps of the country football antics ( albeit it is better than before ):
Not the players
Not the league/rules
Not the umpires ( for not being able to 'control' thugs )

Didnt United move Drainer on because of that incident? Mallala as a club wouldve hated what Gus did, maybe he will be playing elsewhere next year??
Yep, just the club left. They pay them, they support them, they defend them.

Sorry donk - I can't agree on this one.

Greggy Gregginson wrote:

Mythical Creature wrote:

OnSong wrote:Will update tipping table today!

Balak 80+
Mallala 1-39
Virginia 80+
United 80+

x2

x3