Footy Warrior wrote:BOMBERS wrote:Footy Warrior wrote:footys the winner wrote:
stribling and dowdell will both be in the top 5 players in the comp.
solly
pym
monty rounding it out IMO
obviously have no idea about the APFL. The best players who have been in this league are the one's who have grown up in it. I could name a few who are still around before you mention those imports, who might i add haven't even suited up for an APFL game yet. Lee Allmond, Jason Earl, matt Young, Heath Pym already mentioned.
I'm interested how you have come up with your top 5 considering you as quoted 'have no idea of the APFL' and most likely no idea of the quality of players running around in this league? Obviously you're very Salisbury North/United biased with your selections but there is some quality players from each of the 7 sides.
I didn't name any Salisbury north players? What are you on about. Played in this league for many years up to 2011. Top players running around this league Allmond, Earl, Young, Pym, Seccafien, Whiskey Walker. Joel Mont has been the best import to come into this league and stay. Like Swamp said there has been many that have come with hype and not delivered. It's up to them to show the people who have been running around the league for years how good they are. What's your top five?
Apologies Footy Warrior I misread the quotes and I got mixed up between you and footy is the winner.
I agree with you that the top 5 are guys that have performed in this league and not at AFL,SANFL and other country and amateur comps.
Until they play a few games and prove themselves in this league they shouldn't be in anyone's top 5.
Current top 5.
Montgomerie
Seccafien
Feast
Cicollella
Niklaus
Could easily chuck in Pym, Allmond, Howell, Earl, Zanandrea, Robertson, Thach, King, Etteridge, Storic or guys that have left like Taylor, Faulkner, Lachy Michael or Whiskey and most probably wouldn't disagree too much.