EP Sport - back with a vengeance

[untapped ability]

I hope they play on each other in the prelim and you will see who is better SS

[silicone skyline]

It's like you've banged your head against a brick wall for an extended period.

I just said, I'm not concerned who is better, it's like comparing Nick Riewoldt to Garry Ablett at AFL level.

You could go on about the pros and cons for ages, at the end of the day, they're both match winners.

I just can't believe you guys don't rate Keatley. That's all I'm saying. FFS.

[BJ Ernest]

There is no way Matt Keatley is not a very good footballer. Ive played with and against him and he finds the footy, uses it well and is able to have a big influence on a game.

You're kidding yourself if you think hes not a super player!

[untapped ability]

over-rated

[silicone skyline]

There is no way Matt Keatley is not a very good footballer. Ive played with and against him and he finds the footy, uses it well and is able to have a big influence on a game.

You're kidding yourself if you think hes not a super player!

[silicone skyline]

over-rated

You CLEARLY have NFI

[lincolnsdirtysecrets]

Why do so many people argee that Carl is a much better player then?

[acockfromwayback]

There is no way Matt Keatley is not a very good footballer. Ive played with and against him and he finds the footy, uses it well and is able to have a big influence on a game.

You're kidding yourself if you think hes not a super player!

Are you the same guy that told us earlier that Wayne Langford is a gun??? Someone on here said he was over-rated. and hell he proved it. Too big too slow too old.

On the subject of Semmler and Keatley, SS is on the money. Different type of players both are awesome. And about your dickie argument of teams tagging Semmler and not Keatley, When you are playing Waybacks where do you stop tagging? You've got Goodwin, Keatley, Kelsh, Hunt all needing a decent tag and if you miss one he'll be the one to destroy you, like we did in the last round, we were up in the final stages and Keatley finished us. We had tags on, but quality will rise at important moments...

MP, ruck is not the most important possie in my opinion. I reckon centre or centre half back would be my choices for most important. No matter how good a ruckman you have, you'll always find quality midfielders to read the tap and get the clearance. Watch how Mallees midfield work without a decent ruckman, same as waybacks earlier in the year

[BJ Ernest]

There is no way Matt Keatley is not a very good footballer. Ive played with and against him and he finds the footy, uses it well and is able to have a big influence on a game.

You're kidding yourself if you think hes not a super player!

Are you the same guy that told us earlier that Wayne Langford is a gun??? Someone on here said he was over-rated. and hell he proved it. Too big too slow too old.

On the subject of Semmler and Keatley, SS is on the money. Different type of players both are awesome. And about your dickie argument of teams tagging Semmler and not Keatley, When you are playing Waybacks where do you stop tagging? You've got Goodwin, Keatley, Kelsh, Hunt all needing a decent tag and if you miss one he'll be the one to destroy you, like we did in the last round, we were up in the final stages and Keatley finished us. We had tags on, but quality will rise at important moments...

MP, ruck is not the most important possie in my opinion. I reckon centre or centre half back would be my choices for most important. No matter how good a ruckman you have, you'll always find quality midfielders to read the tap and get the clearance. Watch how Mallees midfield work without a decent ruckman, same as waybacks earlier in the year

In Mooses defence hes played about half the season and works a priority for him but his own admission is hes had an average year. However hopefully he can step up in the finals and provide a solid option for Waybacks!

However Keatley has played state footy, plenty of zone footy in which i believe he was your zones best player in their game against the central zone on the Sunday. I think that proves the guy can play!

[bluestheboy]

LDS is once again absolutely spot on. Keatley is over rated and under no circumstances should clubs waste a tag on him.....

As for moose, my spies tell me his recent footy has been solid and he is expected to play a reasonable part in finals glory...

Whats the weather report for the weekend??

[coyote ugly]

LDS is once again absolutely spot on. Keatley is over rated and under no circumstances should clubs waste a tag on him.....

As for moose, my spies tell me his recent footy has been solid and he is expected to play a reasonable part in finals glory...

Whats the weather report for the weekend??

You need to get some new spies bluestheboy.

weather will be wind and rain

[acockfromwayback]

Whats the weather report for the weekend??

weather will be wind and rain

What a stupid question!

What else was it going to be? fine and sunny. i think not

[fev_99]

i have never seen keatley play club footy but i watched him at mortlock shield and he is a gun footballer without a doubt. I reckon in lincoln this weekend mallees will get up by about 5 goals and in GF ramblers will get up by about 7 goals

[Media Park]

I'm tipping Waybacks. Two goals

Bostons in the two's. Less than 2 goals.

No junior footy.

[pecker power]

we have an awesome side picked

[lincolnsdirtysecrets]

Ok there is only 1 way to settle this. I will tally the votes at 8 am Monday morning

VOTE

Who is a better footballer Semmelr of Keatley?

My vote: Semmler

[Media Park]

Keats

[coyote ugly]

C Semler

[Bum Crack]

Keatley

[untapped ability]

Semmler