HFL Division 1 (Central)

[Zipper]

A few clubs were sitting pretty close to the points limit, will be interesting to see which ones are being investigated.

[The Pig Hunter]

silky skills where are you, missing your know it all. :

[Silky skills]

silky skills where are you, missing your know it all. :

what do u wanna no pig hunter??? ironbank is missing ur presence this yr in the under 17s,

[Jailbird]

A few clubs were sitting pretty close to the points limit, will be interesting to see which ones are being investigated.

The 3 that I was told were Uri's, Dorf's and the wood's. I don't know how second hand that is but another person told me today a similar story involving the same clubs. So maybe a bigger story than I thought?

[alice the camel]

A few clubs were sitting pretty close to the points limit, will be interesting to see which ones are being investigated.

The 3 that I was told were Uri's, Dorf's and the wood's. I don't know how second hand that is but another person told me today a similar story involving the same clubs. So maybe a bigger story than I thought?

Think this is unlikely as all point players are decided by the HFL before the player plays a game, only teams that fill in there team sheet incorrectly could be in trouble, this wouldnt take too much investigating.

[Slippery Pete]

A few clubs were sitting pretty close to the points limit, will be interesting to see which ones are being investigated.

The 3 that I was told were Uri's, Dorf's and the wood's. I don't know how second hand that is but another person told me today a similar story involving the same clubs. So maybe a bigger story than I thought?

Think this is unlikely as all point players are decided by the HFL before the player plays a game, only teams that fill in there team sheet incorrectly could be in trouble, this wouldnt take too much investigating.

A quick review on the HFL website shows that Blackwood and Uraidla would be just over the points limit, but only if all players with additional points played. For both clubs a number of guys attracting additional points are not playing consistently in the A's, with some not playing in the HFL this year at all i.e. Bowen for Woods. Wouldn't have thought either of these two clubs would make such a simple error given the transparency of the points system.
Hahndorf would be right on 35 points if all players attracting points played, so no issue for them in any case.
It appears good points management by these 3 clubs. If you've got the points and can afford the players then may as well use them.

[bobby davis]

hahndorf get away with it because so many of their recruits are past players/been at the club for quite some time. the only players who attract substantial points are bartemucci, lomas and to a lesser extent tim nicholas i think. i might be wrong though, i never paid much attention to how it all works

[The Muddy Roo]

A few clubs were sitting pretty close to the points limit, will be interesting to see which ones are being investigated.

The 3 that I was told were Uri's, Dorf's and the wood's. I don't know how second hand that is but another person told me today a similar story involving the same clubs. So maybe a bigger story than I thought?

Think this is unlikely as all point players are decided by the HFL before the player plays a game, only teams that fill in there team sheet incorrectly could be in trouble, this wouldnt take too much investigating.

I agree. Cant see teams making such a blunder. If it came to hand this was the case i also doubt that the HFL would take a serious stand this time of year. Interesting rumour though!

[No Respect]

A few clubs were sitting pretty close to the points limit, will be interesting to see which ones are being investigated.

The 3 that I was told were Uri's, Dorf's and the wood's. I don't know how second hand that is but another person told me today a similar story involving the same clubs. So maybe a bigger story than I thought?

Think this is unlikely as all point players are decided by the HFL before the player plays a game, only teams that fill in there team sheet incorrectly could be in trouble, this wouldnt take too much investigating.

I agree. Cant see teams making such a blunder. If it came to hand this was the case i also doubt that the HFL would take a serious stand this time of year. Interesting rumour though!

Have heard there is a hearing this Friday and it is over Blackwood players. Us and Hahndorf are close but don't exceed points.
Once again it is Ironbank stirring the pot, didn't they get a 17 from birdwood suspended and Lofty Bs lose final last year cos of them?

[Bat Pad]

Well you can hardly have a crack at Ironbank if the complaint is legitimate. I think we should wait until the results of the hearing before passing judgement on the matter.

[The Panther]

Kym Cobb is only 1 point and is in his sixth season since he left the mighty panthers ( ok not so mighty panthers ). 3 at edwardstown , 1 at robe and second season at blackwood i believe.

[Amateur Footy]

No Respect - share with us where you got you info on IB, because that is an absolute load of garbage. You honestly think IB folk have nothing better to do than try to calculate oppositon points. Just like Lofty incident, this will have been picked up by HFL and nothing to do with Ironbank. Get some facts before you post crap.

[Dashin]

No Respect - share with us where you got you info on IB, because that is an absolute load of garbage. You honestly think IB folk have nothing better to do than try to calculate oppositon points. Just like Lofty incident, this will have been picked up by HFL and nothing to do with Ironbank. Get some facts before you post crap.

Mate the hfl couldn't count the fingers on their hand...of course IB were the ones to highlight the discrepancies. You're kidding yourself if you think otherwise

[Banker]

C'mon Dashin, you cant be dirty at IB over last years B grade finals result?? You guys **** up. IB had no clue about unqualified players, but of course the HFL did...

Bit of an unwarranted attack here.

[BANG]

tips for this week
uraidla vs lofty.... uraidla by a mile, heard mt lofty are in injury trouble once again, but in my opinion there full side wouldnt be good enough anyway
bridgey vs pies..... maggies by a mile, bridgey are just sinking to lower depths, must be a real blow when you recruit like crazy and still fail.
mt barker vs onkas... think onkas are hitting great form and seem to bury some of the lower sides better than the top sides do
ironbank vs lobey... can ironbank win away from the fortress, think they will but not by as much as expected
blackwood vs birdwood... the woodies will make up for last times defeat and give birdwood a pasting

[Dashin]

C'mon Dashin, you cant be dirty at IB over last years B grade finals result?? You guys **** up. IB had no clue about unqualified players, but of course the HFL did...

Bit of an unwarranted attack here.

I don't remember the specifics for the disqualification of the devs b-grade, spearhead should be able to help out....

I remember it being a touch unfair though, pretty sure B Dawes had played atleast the last 5 or 6 games in the sweet b's before somone alerted the hfl to the fact that young Bruce had played slightly more games in the a's for the year than the b's.

[magpiemaster]

tips for this week
uraidla vs lofty.... uraidla by a mile, heard mt lofty are in injury trouble once again, but in my opinion there full side wouldnt be good enough anyway
bridgey vs pies..... maggies by a mile, bridgey are just sinking to lower depths, must be a real blow when you recruit like crazy and still fail.
mt barker vs onkas... think onkas are hitting great form and seem to bury some of the lower sides better than the top sides do
ironbank vs lobey... can ironbank win away from the fortress, think they will but not by as much as expected
blackwood vs birdwood... the woodies will make up for last times defeat and give birdwood a pasting

uraidla vs mt lofty- i heard that lofty are nearly at full strength while uri are missing a few so i think mt lofty will get up. still a class outfit and tough to beat, uraidla arent as good as people have made them out to be. and i think with a fine day lofty will run them off their legs. lofty by 5 goal

bridgy vs handorf- handorf back in town last week against a really good side. shows were still the best team when were on song. we will win by 17 goal. barta could kick 10 i think.

mt barker vs onkas- it will be close i think, onkas but only by 3 goal. barker showing some good signs of late.

ironbank vs lobey- 15 goals to ironbank. the cheif will b best on by a mile.....awesome player and along with williams and co they will carve the once powerful lobey

blackwood v birdwood- the woods will bounce back by plenty. dangerous forwards who birdwood wont b able to stop. gigney will kick 8 roach with 6

[Mop Up]

Think it was cleared up last year when this all happened that it wasn't IB that dobbed anyone Dashin! They had no idea about any of it... first they heard was on Tues well after the decision was made

Not sure of anyone who knows about this incident at IB and I'm pretty sure the only reason finger is pointed is because a forum poster said they think it was IB... pretty solid evidence... why would IB care considering not in finals contention

In the end it comes down to... Rules are Rules too so if you break em, even if by a little I don't think you have a leg to stand on... can't go bending em for some when others follow them

[Amateur Footy]

No Respect - share with us where you got you info on IB, because that is an absolute load of garbage. You honestly think IB folk have nothing better to do than try to calculate oppositon points. Just like Lofty incident, this will have been picked up by HFL and nothing to do with Ironbank. Get some facts before you post crap.

Mate the hfl couldn't count the fingers on their hand...of course IB were the ones to highlight the discrepancies. You're kidding yourself if you think otherwise

Kidding myself eh? Well arn't you a bright one, just like your mates who screwed up the selection of Bruce Dawes. Since what we said before still hasn't sunk in, I'll once again say that the HFL notified IB that Lofty was suspended last year. Secretary of HFL called our Pres. Now tell me again how that was our fault?

[Dashin]

No Respect - share with us where you got you info on IB, because that is an absolute load of garbage. You honestly think IB folk have nothing better to do than try to calculate oppositon points. Just like Lofty incident, this will have been picked up by HFL and nothing to do with Ironbank. Get some facts before you post crap.

Mate the hfl couldn't count the fingers on their hand...of course IB were the ones to highlight the discrepancies. You're kidding yourself if you think otherwise

Kidding myself eh? Well arn't you a bright one, just like your mates who screwed up the selection of Bruce Dawes. Since what we said before still hasn't sunk in, I'll once again say that the HFL notified IB that Lofty was suspended last year. Secretary of HFL called our Pres. Now tell me again how that was our fault?

Well if that's what you are saying i don't suppose i can argue too much. I just find it hard to believe that the volunteers that run the hfl would sit down and calculate how many games every single player has played to check whether or not they are eligible to play.

It's certainly unfortunate for your club that these sorts of things have ocurred when IB has been involved, because you can understand people associating your team with such occurrences now that it has happened on more than one occasion.