I think you'll find that 'young' 'inexperienced' sides do play inconsistent footy ... guys to state a player and questioning why he's in the side is a little harsh i think (or maybe i've miss interpreted that statement)! i would guarantee that other than the top 2 maybe 3 sides in the GSFL the rest would have players that are fringe a graders in their side ... never the less they still put their hand up to play when asked by the a grade selection committee ... i say well done to them!! It's much better than players that are more than capable a graders who refuse to play a's cause it's "too hard" "just wanna play with me mates" or some other piss weak excuses (other than I'm too old for a's!

) etc!
I personally would pat the back of the likes of "j. smith's" for presenting themselves for the late game on a saturday![/quote]
If you're old then so am I!
I think it's fantastic that Justo stepped up into the 1's and kicked a couple. gives other backmen hope![/quote]
I'm too old also. What joy does anyone get from knocking a bloke that gets an opportunity in the A grade. Smith got a chance to play a higher grade, he took it, did what he was required by the coach on the day. End of story. Well done. If he plays A grade again, good on him, if he doesn't then go back to the B grade and bust your ass for that team. That's footy.....
PS- Hi Stan. Still don't know if I've been registered yet. I'm cleared to the League but in limbo at the moment..........[/quote]
i think the whole a grade, b grade and which to play is an issue at every club...they're not always pathetic excuses either - i know at goolwa that those 'fringe' players that dont wanna play a's may be because players are playing footy just for the fitness and sure the 'excuses' of being able to play with best mates, drink a few brews after the game and still been able to get behind your club in the a's are definately a bonus

also goolwa's bench in the a grade is basically not used unless a player wants to come off or is injured - why play 1 or 2 quarters in the a's if you can have a full game in the b's if your playing for the fitness...i know a lot of the fringe players (some are quality a grade players as well) would be more then happy to stick their hand up and play a's...
i know everyone has their own opinion and they all differ so i think clubs just need to sit down with players and discuss what the club wants out of the players and also what the players want to get out of footy from playing footy for their local club...