smac wrote:Pearcey, aren't you missing the whole point of football at that level by keeping scores, goalkickers etc? Also, why not have to evenly competitive teams instead of putting the better players in one team? How many years do you think the second team will keep coming back if the kids from the other team at the same club smash them if/when they play against each other?
Surely it is about teaching the skills and having some fun - not winning and losing.
Spot on smac, my son's year 6-7 school team has been travelling along quite nicely this year(lost 1 to a win at all costs team), and in a few games this year have turned up with a full side, and opposition sides have been short of players, our coach has lent the opposition enough players (rotating them 1 1/4 each) so that both teams have even numbers, this has been good for our kids as well, as they get to play a whole game instead of spendong time on the bench, and he hasn't just sent over the fringe players, 1st 1/4 last week, one of our better players kicked 4 goals for the opposition, before kicking 3 for us in the next 3 quarters.
This week (for the second time this season) he allowed the opposition to play all players (including the bench) on the ground in the last 1/4, we had 18, they had (i think) 3 extras, at 1/4 time we were 9-13 to 0-3, the opposition kicked 5-3 to 0-4 in the last 1/4, a lot of parents weren't happy, but it gave a side that has been getting flogged each week a chance to gain some dignity on the score board, while making our kids play under pressure, which can only benifit them for the future.
At no stage were our kids in danger of losing, and percentage doesn't count in primary school footy, just wins and loses.
To the kids credit this year, each time they have been asked to play for the opposition, they have gone about it as they would normally play for their own team.
Our year 4-5 team (coached by a SANFL umpire & managed by "giffo") have done simillar things regulary during the season 2with the same positive results.
Playing short, or for the opposition is not just giving other teams "a fair go" and giving our teams a better hit out, but it has been character building for our kids as well.