SA Footy

little bayman wants me to put up the scores so firstly last week clg played phos at home & lost 7.5.47 to nil, the endeavour of both teams in that game was great but phos was a lot more polished in their skill level

today 27/4/08

goodwood 1.1.7 4.2.26 5.2.32 5.2.32

colonel l.g. 1.1.7 1.1.7 2.1.13 4.4.28

what an enthrawlling game this was, it was just a great contest & as you can see by the scores it was close, i personally was bemused by the different rules to the week before as last week there was full on tackling & this week you were allowed for 3 seconds to grab the jumper but not wrap the arms around your opponent, surely it is one or the other oh by the way little bayman had a shot to put clg in front from about 25 metres & it dropped a couple of metres short, romeo snapped a goal after crumbing but the siren beat him, it was a very entertaining game

well done little BAYMAN
now i wonder if this year we'll get goal kickers and best players probably

It's interesting that you have scores and tackling. In the MWJFL there is no tackling & bumping until U/11's. There is also no "official" scores either.

bayman, just letting you know that you cant place the scores on this website for the U/8's, 9's and 10's, your club was warned last year. If the AFL or the SANFL search this site which they do and see the scores are posted, the league can get fined whihc will be passed onto the club. On the rules, there is no tackling allowed, it is grab and release, all clubs were advised about this and was voted on at the AGM in November. What we are seeing here though is that the club delegates arent passing on the information to the respective coaches for those grades and also some umpires need some extra training. All clubs have been sent an email outlining the rules so hopefully it is all right by this weekend. Please grab them off you club Thursday night.

kookas wrote:bayman, just letting you know that you cant place the scores on this website for the U/8's, 9's and 10's, your club was warned last year. If the AFL or the SANFL search this site which they do and see the scores are posted, the league can get fined whihc will be passed onto the club. On the rules, there is no tackling allowed, it is grab and release, all clubs were advised about this and was voted on at the AGM in November. What we are seeing here though is that the club delegates arent passing on the information to the respective coaches for those grades and also some umpires need some extra training. All clubs have been sent an email outlining the rules so hopefully it is all right by this weekend. Please grab them off you club Thursday night.

i cant, yes i can it is a free country & how do kids LEARN how to win & how to lose ? just like life in general, they lost by about 6 goals last week against plympton & this week they didn't play but just for you kookas i wont do them

Just wondering if anyone could enlighten me on the following- i have a nephew who plays for payneham in the u/9's comp, i think its the NEJMFL?? I went to watch his game the other Friday night at Modbury and was very disheartened by some of the rules which have/haven't been implemented.
Why is there tackling in U/9's?! Why are there not zones set up so there isnt 20 players around the ball at all times?? These would be my main two issues.
Shouldnt junior footy be about kids developing their skills?? How can this happen when as soon as they get the ball there is 20 other kids within 2 metres of them? It just seems farcical. Some kids at this level are still learning how to kick FFS!
I remember when i played jnr footy their was no tackling up until U/11's and you had to bump the kid twice to get holding the ball. And there was 3 seperate zones on the oval- Forward /Centre/Back and the kids playing in each of these zones were restricted to these playing areas. Much better concept in my opinion. Gave all the kids a chance, and gave them time to dispose of the ball.
The way it is setup currently is a joke and whoever heads this association needs to reassess the rules because the development of these kids is at jeapordy.

bayman, just letting you know that you cant place the scores on this website for the U/8's, 9's and 10's, your club was warned last year. If the AFL or the SANFL search this site which they do and see the scores are posted, the league can get fined whihc will be passed onto the club.

Well WE do!

See:

http://geppscross.homestead.com/Resultsmenu.html

or:

http://geppscrossjuniors.blogspot.com/

When will the kiddy footy police come knocking!

Pearcey wrote:

bayman, just letting you know that you cant place the scores on this website for the U/8's, 9's and 10's, your club was warned last year. If the AFL or the SANFL search this site which they do and see the scores are posted, the league can get fined whihc will be passed onto the club.

Well WE do!

See:

http://geppscross.homestead.com/Resultsmenu.html

or:

http://geppscrossjuniors.blogspot.com/

When will the kiddy footy police come knocking!

thankyou, i'll do it then because little bayman like the scores going up & it gives him a 'thrill' seeing his team up on the screen a few days later etc

bayman wrote:

Pearcey wrote:

bayman, just letting you know that you cant place the scores on this website for the U/8's, 9's and 10's, your club was warned last year. If the AFL or the SANFL search this site which they do and see the scores are posted, the league can get fined whihc will be passed onto the club.

Well WE do!

See:

http://geppscross.homestead.com/Resultsmenu.html

or:

http://geppscrossjuniors.blogspot.com/

When will the kiddy footy police come knocking!

thankyou, i'll do it then because little bayman like the scores going up & it gives him a 'thrill' seeing his team up on the screen a few days later etc

You can go ahead bayman and do it, the club will get a nice fine then.

keeping scores in u/8s and u/9s..what tools..its meant to be no scores kept..its for..wait for it...FUN..ok..get over yourselves and grow up and stop using kids as pawns in your club v club mentality..disgraceful

My son plays at Flinders Pk u11s. They dont keep scores either and havent done since u8s, but the kids all know if they have won or lost when they come off anyway. Quite often he comes off after the game and tells me the scores or how much they won/loss by. No big deal i dont reckon.

kookas wrote:

bayman wrote:

Pearcey wrote:

bayman, just letting you know that you cant place the scores on this website for the U/8's, 9's and 10's, your club was warned last year. If the AFL or the SANFL search this site which they do and see the scores are posted, the league can get fined whihc will be passed onto the club.

Well WE do!

See:

http://geppscross.homestead.com/Resultsmenu.html

or:

http://geppscrossjuniors.blogspot.com/

When will the kiddy footy police come knocking!

thankyou, i'll do it then because little bayman like the scores going up & it gives him a 'thrill' seeing his team up on the screen a few days later etc

You can go ahead bayman and do it, the club will get a nice fine then.

HOW COULD THE CLUB THAT I AM NOT A MEMBER OF GET FINED FOR SOMETHING THEY HAVE NO POWER IN CONTROLLING ?

zedman wrote:keeping scores in u/8s and u/9s..what tools..its meant to be no scores kept..its for..wait for it...FUN..ok..get over yourselves and grow up and stop using kids as pawns in your club v club mentality..disgraceful

SURELY KIDS HAVE TO LEARN TO TAKE THE GOOD WITH THE BAD, HOW TO WIN & LOSE GRACIOUSLY & AS SOMEONE ELSE SAID THE KIDS KNOW IT ANYWAY & I THINK ZEDMAN IS ANOTHER DOO BLOODY GOODER , IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH CLUB MENTALITY AT ALL I COULDN'T CARE LESS IF THEY WON OR LOST BUT THE KIDS DO, I REMEMBER WHEN I PLAYED AT THIS AGE WE KEPT SCORES ETC IT TAUGHT US LESSONS FOR LIFE

i learnt my 6 times table from playing footy in the backyard wen i was 6. if i didnt take scores, i still wouldnt know my 6 times tables

Teach your kids life skills another way, don't expect football to do it for you before the kid turns 11.

Teach them how to kick, mark, handball, bump, spoil, run... By 11 they may be competent at some or all of these - then teach them how to tackle, win and lose. Little steps for little kids guys.

I've seen first hand the effect that a big loss has on these kids and it isn't pretty. They learnt nothing. I doubt the kids who won learnt much more. They aren't life skills, that's just punishment for the undeserving.

Whats stopping you from just telling us how the game went without printing the scores?? Just a thought......

Your son plays football for them?????? The club has to always control their players and supporters.

kookas wrote:Your son plays football for them?????? The club has to always control their players and supporters.

I think it also comes to attention that the league has clearly set rules. Rules are meant to be set in place to keep people in line. I understand all parties arguments but the bottom line is.... The league has clear set rules that are in place, surely we would all be setting the best example by abiding by them. I always read baymans articles on the juniors as there is nothing better than watching the youngsters kicking their first goal or take a great mark, but rather than printing the scores i'd rather hear of a young fellas run down the wing and hitting the bustling full forward on the chest and slotting it for a 6 pointer. I mean cmon they are just having fun....

LaughingKookaburra wrote:

kookas wrote:Your son plays football for them?????? The club has to always control their players and supporters.

I think it also comes to attention that the league has clearly set rules. Rules are meant to be set in place to keep people in line. I understand all parties arguments but the bottom line is.... The league has clear set rules that are in place, surely we would all be setting the best example by abiding by them. I always read baymans articles on the juniors as there is nothing better than watching the youngsters kicking their first goal or take a great mark, but rather than printing the scores i'd rather hear of a young fellas run down the wing and hitting the bustling full forward on the chest and slotting it for a 6 pointer. I mean cmon they are just having fun....

I know they are having fun, I helped to set up a junior club and am happy to see the kids still running around 10 years later playing for the club. The rules are set down by the SANFL who dont really help out much latetly with the juniors. I would like to say to bayman to go ahead and put the scores in but just letting him know about somethings.

mypaddock wrote:Just wondering if anyone could enlighten me on the following- i have a nephew who plays for payneham in the u/9's comp, i think its the NEJMFL?? I went to watch his game the other Friday night at Modbury and was very disheartened by some of the rules which have/haven't been implemented.
Why is there tackling in U/9's?! Why are there not zones set up so there isnt 20 players around the ball at all times?? These would be my main two issues.
Shouldnt junior footy be about kids developing their skills?? How can this happen when as soon as they get the ball there is 20 other kids within 2 metres of them? It just seems farcical. Some kids at this level are still learning how to kick FFS!
I remember when i played jnr footy their was no tackling up until U/11's and you had to bump the kid twice to get holding the ball. And there was 3 seperate zones on the oval- Forward /Centre/Back and the kids playing in each of these zones were restricted to these playing areas. Much better concept in my opinion. Gave all the kids a chance, and gave them time to dispose of the ball.
The way it is setup currently is a joke and whoever heads this association needs to reassess the rules because the development of these kids is at jeapordy.

It is ridiculous paddock.
They go from 15 to 18 on the ground & tackling is allowed for the 1st time, but, they still play on the half ground that they played on as under 8's.
I don't mind the tackling coming in at that age, otherwise the kids that stand out just run around the player on the mark every time & get a false security. Personally I'd stay with the 15 to keep the game open, the zoning is interesting though.