APPS

[Footy Smart]

It reads that in 2010 it was 1 point, but with the addoption of the Apendix 4 version it means all are 3 points and 2 points etc

Points will carry over!

[newbloke]

NG I think that is a bit rough saying u have to cop it sweet. What would happen if your club applies for a permit to have over 15 points and you go on and win the flag. I know I would be very dirty if I was the other team

[zedman]

It reads that in 2010 it was 1 point, but with the addoption of the Apendix 4 version it means all are 3 points and 2 points etc

Points will carry over!

http://saafl.asn.au/post/league_news/1s ... sletter-40

The clubs formally approved the adoption of the APPS system according to Appendix 4. Transfers within SAAFL during 2010 attracted 1 point. With the adoption of the APPS according to Appendix 4, transfers within SAAFL will attract 3 points (div 1 – 3) and 2 points (other grades). Would clubs please return the information as per memo on 12/10/10.

reads pretty clear to me..during 2010 they are worth 1 point..for 2011 its 3 and 2..

[Mr Beefy]

It reads that in 2010 it was 1 point, but with the addoption of the Apendix 4 version it means all are 3 points and 2 points etc

Points will carry over!

The clubs formally approved the adoption of the APPS system according to Appendix 4. Transfers within SAAFL during 2010 attracted 1 point. With the adoption of the APPS according to Appendix 4, transfers within SAAFL will attract 3 points (div 1 – 3) and 2 points (other grades).

I read it that 2010 transfers were 1 point, in the future that will 3 and 2

[zedman]

NG I think that is a bit rough saying u have to cop it sweet. What would happen if your club applies for a permit to have over 15 points and you go on and win the flag. I know I would be very dirty if I was the other team

some guys and clubs are sitting in ivory towers acting like their S*** dont stink..every dog has his day..they may find it funny now but trust me karma is a b****..

[nuggety goodness]

NG I think that is a bit rough saying u have to cop it sweet. What would happen if your club applies for a permit to have over 15 points and you go on and win the flag. I know I would be very dirty if I was the other team

not sure how it's gonna work in our situation considering we'll be playing in the C's... I can't see us pushing the 15 point limit, as I've said before we aren't recruiting A grade players from anywhere this year...

If there were two alternatives on any given situation would you plan with the worst case scenario in mind or just do what you want, hoping it works out in your favour? EVERY club is in the same boat...

So FE, who are the other clubs that have recruited with the 1pt transfers in mind?!?

[zedman]

It reads that in 2010 it was 1 point, but with the addoption of the Apendix 4 version it means all are 3 points and 2 points etc

Points will carry over!

in fact i am saying right now that you are wrong FS..and i will put money on it..wanna bet? 2010 intra league will be 1 point which drops to 0 for 2011..2011 will be 3 and 2

[Footy Chick]

Mr Hart, what a mess! Hopefully the following allieviates any confusion:

any player recruited into your club, for the 2011 season, from another SAAFL club will be allocated three (3) points for Div 1-3 players and two (2) points for Div 4-7 players. Any player recruited from North Pines, Ovingham or Wingfield Royals will be allocated two (2) points as this player has played “A” grade at that club.

As indicated earlier ALL EXISTING players registered at your club who currently have a “Player Point Rating” of one (1) or above will automatically drop one (1) point for the 2011 season. (ie. John Smith transferred from SAAFL club A to SAAFL club B in March 2010 and was allocated one point. If John Smith continues to play with SAAFL Club B during 2011 he will automatically drop to zero points)

[zedman]

"john smith"..mmm..seen that somewhere else as well

FS? anything to add?

[Footy Smart]

"john smith"..mmm..seen that somewhere else as well

FS? anything to add?

fair dues

(i was trying to find a little smiley that pulls his pants down and moons you )

Once again Policy isn’t always easy to read and takes time especially with amendments for all things to be made clear.
At least 4th Estate can stop stamping his feet like a naughty 2 year old who lost his dummy now

ps Zed where is your elegance? you don’t have a club listed? pure curiosity.....

[zedman]

<-- you mean that one?

its grey for all of us FS..we will get used to it but things need to be worked through..

clubs for me?.. well..Kenilworth, ALFC, ScotchOS, Goodwood, Lockleys..i wear many hats but i dont play any more

currently at CLGFC and did squeeze one game in for them so i guess they go on the resume to

so CLGFC is my club but i follow Goodwood as well..see them train every tuesday night and have mates out there and my lad plays juniors there..

[BFG]

:butthead: <-- you mean that one?

its grey for all of us FS..we will get used to it but things need to be worked through..

clubs for me?.. well..Kenilworth, ALFC, ScotchOS, Goodwood, Lockleys..i wear many hats but i dont play any more

currently at CLGFC and did squeeze one game in for them so i guess they go on the resume to

so CLGFC is my club but i follow Goodwood as well..see them train every tuesday night and have mates out there and my lad plays juniors there..

set a good example that game zed, calling for a handball in the pocket and kicking out on the full?

if i recall correctly that is

[zedman]

errr..thats when the mind knows what to do but the body says "your joking son" i think i got a behind not out on the full!

[OnSong]

Onsong mentioned above about playing 25 games for your club then going back after a stint in the SANFL. What about kids moving to Adelaide for school, playing Amateurs & now heading home. But they haven't played 25 games of senior footy?

The rule protects the junior club.
Take say, Peter Burgoyne, he would be zero points at Mallee Park.
Mark Ricciuto was zero points to Waikerie.

What about workers who are in a job that require constant moving (Police etc.)

Leagues have the power to bring in a bylaw to apply for a points exemption on such cases. It's not in the APPS core rules because it is an area that can be abused by some powerful clubs.

What about a father/son, family rule?

Again, another bylaw issue that could be introduced to leagues if they want to.

[FOURTH ESTATE]

One may suggest FS that you get your own house & President in order before you bag others.

[Footy Smart]

One may suggest FS that you get your own house & President in order before you bag others.

I dont remember bagging a club?

just found it amusing your ranting on here.... thats all!

Im not getting into a slanging match about clubs etc, this thread is to talk about the APPS.

play on

[Footy Smart]

:butthead: <-- you mean that one?

its grey for all of us FS..we will get used to it but things need to be worked through..

clubs for me?.. well..Kenilworth, ALFC, ScotchOS, Goodwood, Lockleys..i wear many hats but i dont play any more

currently at CLGFC and did squeeze one game in for them so i guess they go on the resume to

so CLGFC is my club but i follow Goodwood as well..see them train every tuesday night and have mates out there and my lad plays juniors there..

Damn thats the one i was after Zed

Few guernseys in the cupboard for you

To many people get worked up over things IMO and while things can always be handled better, not everyone is going to be happy with decisions made. Doesnt matter if its in the workforce or in this case amatuer footy. Some make more noise than others and some just get on with the job.

[zedman]

yeah..doesnt hurt to have discussions on points of conjecture but in the end we want whats good football..urggh cliche

[White Line Fever]

yeah..doesnt hurt to have discussions on points of conjecture but in the end we want whats good football..urggh cliche

Let's just take it one week at a time

[Blue Boy]

So does an ex SANFL player from your club attract points if they want to come straight back ???