APPS

[wangas#4]

I hear this was formally adopted last night and SAAFL internal transfers are now worth 3 points for Div 1-3 and 2 points for the other divs instead of the proposed 1 point for all internal transfers.

That will sort a few clubs and players out

[Footy Smart]

I hear this was formally adopted last night and SAAFL internal transfers are now worth 3 points for Div 1-3 and 2 points for the other divs instead of the proposed 1 point for all internal transfers.

That will sort a few clubs and players out

Few clubs may have to tap a few recruits on the shoulder PLAY ON

[nuggety goodness]

I hear this was formally adopted last night and SAAFL internal transfers are now worth 3 points for Div 1-3 and 2 points for the other divs instead of the proposed 1 point for all internal transfers.

That will sort a few clubs and players out

Few clubs may have to tap a few recruits on the shoulder PLAY ON

So how does a B grade player work?

Some of those we will be receiving never played A's at their current club, other's registered but didn't play... what's the ruling on them?

[The Riddler]

So how does a B grade player work?

Some of those we will be receiving never played A's at their current club, other's registered but didn't play... what's the ruling on them?

As far as I know if they played B grade or majority there of the year before they are 0 points but may need that confirmed be someone.

[Footy Smart]

I hear this was formally adopted last night and SAAFL internal transfers are now worth 3 points for Div 1-3 and 2 points for the other divs instead of the proposed 1 point for all internal transfers.

That will sort a few clubs and players out

Few clubs may have to tap a few recruits on the shoulder PLAY ON

So how does a B grade player work?

Some of those we will be receiving never played A's at their current club, other's registered but didn't play... what's the ruling on them?

Doesnt effect B grade, only your highest team.

Doesnt matter what grade they played for another club, if they didnt play they would have some playing history which would determine their allocation

[nuggety goodness]

[

Ok so example...

Player X played at Div 6 club in the Magoos in 2009, worth 2 points still?
Player Y registered at country club in Hills league and never played, 2 points still?

[Boosh]

[

Ok so example...

Player X played at Div 6 club in the Magoos in 2009, worth 2 points still?
Player Y registered at country club in Hills league and never played, 2 points still?

Going by what ive read on here and what footy smart has just said both would be worth zero as they didn't play the majority of games for the the senior side of the club they came from.

Unless the bloke from the country did the year before, which might mean he is worth 1 point

[Mr Beefy]

So how does a B grade player work?

Some of those we will be receiving never played A's at their current club, other's registered but didn't play... what's the ruling on them?

As far as I know if they played B grade or majority there of the year before they are 0 points but may need that confirmed be someone.

Yes that's correct, must have played the majority of the previous season's games in the seniors, if they played mostly in the reserves then they are worth 0 points with the exception of SANFL/VFL/WAFL reserves players who are worth 3 points.

[nuggety goodness]

So how does a B grade player work?

Some of those we will be receiving never played A's at their current club, other's registered but didn't play... what's the ruling on them?

As far as I know if they played B grade or majority there of the year before they are 0 points but may need that confirmed be someone.

Yes that's correct, must have played the majority of the previous season's games in the seniors, if they played mostly in the reserves then they are worth 0 points with the exception of SANFL/VFL/WAFL reserves players who are worth 3 points.

Ok, so if we were to go out and recruit a Div 1R player, who played a handful of games in the A's but majority in the Magoos he's worth 0 but a div 7 A grade player is gonna cost us 2 points?!?

[Pag]

So how does a B grade player work?

Some of those we will be receiving never played A's at their current club, other's registered but didn't play... what's the ruling on them?

As far as I know if they played B grade or majority there of the year before they are 0 points but may need that confirmed be someone.

Yes that's correct, must have played the majority of the previous season's games in the seniors, if they played mostly in the reserves then they are worth 0 points with the exception of SANFL/VFL/WAFL reserves players who are worth 3 points.

Ok, so if we were to go out and recruit a Div 1R player, who played a handful of games in the A's but majority in the Magoos he's worth 0 but a div 7 A grade player is gonna cost us 2 points?!?

Correct. Those D1R players will not become very worthwhile for lower-divison clubs.

[nuggety goodness]

Ok, so if we were to go out and recruit a Div 1R player, who played a handful of games in the A's but majority in the Magoos he's worth 0 but a div 7 A grade player is gonna cost us 2 points?!?

Correct. Those D1R players will not become very worthwhile for lower-divison clubs.

I assume you mean 'now'...?

[BFG]

So how does a B grade player work?

Some of those we will be receiving never played A's at their current club, other's registered but didn't play... what's the ruling on them?

As far as I know if they played B grade or majority there of the year before they are 0 points but may need that confirmed be someone.

Yes that's correct, must have played the majority of the previous season's games in the seniors, if they played mostly in the reserves then they are worth 0 points with the exception of SANFL/VFL/WAFL reserves players who are worth 3 points.

Ok, so if we were to go out and recruit a Div 1R player, who played a handful of games in the A's but majority in the Magoos he's worth 0 but a div 7 A grade player is gonna cost us 2 points?!?

when it first came out that was the thing that struck me that many clubs may use as a loophole of sorts, still very much within the rules but definately something lower grade clubs will look at in regards to recruiting.

[Pag]

Ok, so if we were to go out and recruit a Div 1R player, who played a handful of games in the A's but majority in the Magoos he's worth 0 but a div 7 A grade player is gonna cost us 2 points?!?

Correct. Those D1R players will not become very worthwhile for lower-divison clubs.

I assume you mean 'now'...?

You would be correct again

[White Line Fever]

What would a SFL B grader be worth to a SAAFL A grade side??

[Pag]

What would a SFL B grader be worth to a SAAFL A grade side??

All 'B Graders' across the state are worth 0.

[nuggety goodness]

AFL = 5
State leagues ie SANFL = 4
State leagues Reserves/SAAFL D1-3 = 3
SAAFL D4-7 = 2
? = 1
ANY B grader/Former player = 0
Junior's from your own club = -1

this is my understanding. Just not sure where they have put the country comps...

can someone fill this out properly to clarify it all?!?

[bandar]

-1 for juniors only counts while they are under 18.

[piccachu]

AFL = 5
State leagues ie SANFL = 4
State leagues Reserves/SAAFL D1-3 = 3
SAAFL D4-7 = 2
? = 1
ANY B grader/Former player = 0
Junior's from your own club = -1

this is my understanding. Just not sure where they have put the country comps...

can someone fill this out properly to clarify it all?!?

Just my oppinion but 3 points seems a bit rich for a Div 1-3 considering a bloke who played 8 league games and 9 reserves games for a league club would be worth the same amount of points. i reckon 2 points for div 1-3 and 1 point for lower divs would be more resonable, if this is the case with 3 points for div 1-3 and 2 points for div 4 and down players, a few clubs are going to be really close to exceeding the points allocated

[nuggety goodness]

AFL = 5
State leagues ie SANFL = 4
State leagues Reserves/SAAFL D1-3 = 3
SAAFL D4-7 = 2
? = 1
ANY B grader/Former player = 0
Junior's from your own club = -1

this is my understanding. Just not sure where they have put the country comps...

can someone fill this out properly to clarify it all?!?

Just my oppinion but 3 points seems a bit rich for a Div 1-3 considering a bloke who played 8 league games and 9 reserves games for a league club would be worth the same amount of points. i reckon 2 points for div 1-3 and 1 point for lower divs would be more resonable, if this is the case with 3 points for div 1-3 and 2 points for div 4 and down players, a few clubs are going to be really close to exceeding the points allocated

Was any alternative put forward? like e.g
Div 1-2 = 3
Div 3-5 = 2
Div 6-7 = 1

How much difference is there between SANFL Reserves and Div 1 or 2?

Also from the original post, does anybody know which country leagues will be worth what?!?

[Footy Smart]

AFL = 5
State leagues ie SANFL = 4
State leagues Reserves/SAAFL D1-3 = 3
SAAFL D4-7 = 2
? = 1
ANY B grader/Former player = 0
Junior's from your own club = -1

this is my understanding. Just not sure where they have put the country comps...

can someone fill this out properly to clarify it all?!?

Just my oppinion but 3 points seems a bit rich for a Div 1-3 considering a bloke who played 8 league games and 9 reserves games for a league club would be worth the same amount of points. i reckon 2 points for div 1-3 and 1 point for lower divs would be more resonable, if this is the case with 3 points for div 1-3 and 2 points for div 4 and down players, a few clubs are going to be really close to exceeding the points allocated

Was any alternative put forward? like e.g
Div 1-2 = 3
Div 3-5 = 2
Div 6-7 = 1

How much difference is there between SANFL Reserves and Div 1 or 2?

Also from the original post, does anybody know which country leagues will be worth what?!?

You can see the full document online just google it.

All amatuer/country leagues are divided into 2. One set is worth 3 points (including SAAFL Div1-3) and one set is worth 2 points (including SAAFL div 4-7)