by whufc » Thu Mar 31, 2011 1:01 pm
by whufc » Thu Mar 31, 2011 1:14 pm
by Grahaml » Thu Mar 31, 2011 1:23 pm
bothamsfearnley wrote:Browny25 wrote:Do other clubs think BL should still have a grade 1 side next year? - Being our C grade from this season (grade 4 would be)
This is what has been said from the PDCA, hopefully tongue in cheek.
I know we had a good year but seriously, Have a look at our C grade - Most of us were suprised we got dumped out of grade 4 for last season but its a mid table grade three side at the absolute most. Obviously it needs to be worked out fairly for everyone but unless we keep everyone and pickup four or five thats just nonsense talk.
If that has really come from someone in the executive as a serious comment - and I doubt it would have, they should consider how saying things like that could effect the decisions we make about next season.
by Wizard of Oz » Thu Mar 31, 2011 2:09 pm
Browny25 wrote:catchit wrote:Browny25 wrote:Lightning McQueen wrote:Congratulations to Jamie on the McKenzie Medal, thoroughly deserved winner.
Does anyone have any other placings etc.?
Sibbick 18
Jimmy 15
Justin Carmen 15
Dont know the rest.
Just think if jim played against oth and parafield in the last 2 games he would of been all over the medal...
Yep - Would have gone to Jimmy
Apparently BJ didnt get the votes when he made a ton
by Executive Member » Thu Mar 31, 2011 3:45 pm
Grahaml wrote:bothamsfearnley wrote:Browny25 wrote:Do other clubs think BL should still have a grade 1 side next year? - Being our C grade from this season (grade 4 would be)
This is what has been said from the PDCA, hopefully tongue in cheek.
I know we had a good year but seriously, Have a look at our C grade - Most of us were suprised we got dumped out of grade 4 for last season but its a mid table grade three side at the absolute most. Obviously it needs to be worked out fairly for everyone but unless we keep everyone and pickup four or five thats just nonsense talk.
If that has really come from someone in the executive as a serious comment - and I doubt it would have, they should consider how saying things like that could effect the decisions we make about next season.
It's up to Brahma Lodge to convince the PDCA not to put their teams in the grades they would have earned for next season anyway IMHO. Produce a list of 22 blokes that are leaving the comp and say they can't play in PDCA next season at all or something. But if I was on the exec, I'd be saying to Brahma that until they come up with a proposition
that will work and is fair on the rest of the competition they are likely to be graded in 1,2 and 4 for next season.
by Grahaml » Thu Mar 31, 2011 3:56 pm
by dark & stormy » Thu Mar 31, 2011 4:04 pm
by Phantom Gossiper » Thu Mar 31, 2011 4:06 pm
Grahaml wrote:How old should Peter Sleep be before he's allowed to play PDCA then?
It's Brahma that want to do all this, nobody forced you guys to move half your club to a different association. It's not up to the association to satisfy your club's whims as if that's the only thing that matters to the whole competition. If you seriously expected to be able to just say to the association your A and B grade sides were going and have the others left where they were and be given carte blanche to pick whomever you wanted in whatever association you decided each week, then your club must be very naive.
by whufc » Thu Mar 31, 2011 4:23 pm
Phantom Gossiper wrote:Grahaml wrote:How old should Peter Sleep be before he's allowed to play PDCA then?
It's Brahma that want to do all this, nobody forced you guys to move half your club to a different association. It's not up to the association to satisfy your club's whims as if that's the only thing that matters to the whole competition. If you seriously expected to be able to just say to the association your A and B grade sides were going and have the others left where they were and be given carte blanche to pick whomever you wanted in whatever association you decided each week, then your club must be very naive.
LIKE THIS POST
by sports follower » Thu Mar 31, 2011 4:50 pm
whufc wrote:Phantom Gossiper wrote:Grahaml wrote:How old should Peter Sleep be before he's allowed to play PDCA then?
It's Brahma that want to do all this, nobody forced you guys to move half your club to a different association. It's not up to the association to satisfy your club's whims as if that's the only thing that matters to the whole competition. If you seriously expected to be able to just say to the association your A and B grade sides were going and have the others left where they were and be given carte blanche to pick whomever you wanted in whatever association you decided each week, then your club must be very naive.
LIKE THIS POST
x2
by sports follower » Thu Mar 31, 2011 4:53 pm
Smasha wrote:how old does peter sleep need to be to play pdca ????????
who cares the man is a legend and can play where he wants to .IMO
Iwould love to play against the man , if he belts me all over the park then so be it , bowl better next time..
let the man play the game he loves , if at his age I am half as good I will be a happy man..............
by sports follower » Thu Mar 31, 2011 4:59 pm
Lightning McQueen wrote:whufc wrote:
Yeah they had pre counted all the 1 & 2 votes and the leader board up after those votes had been counted. Shane Rundle was infront at that point with 9 votes.
Then they procedded to read out all the 3 vote getters from each game round by round with an updated ladder at the end of each round. Was displayed on a power point presentation showing the ladder and 3 vote getter from the previous round.
Was well done.
Yeah West Ham and good memories arent usually used in the same sentence but that is one occasion i remember fondly.
Sh!t, that exceded what I thought he'd get, must've picked up a couple where the ump chose ball over bat.
I have a good idea for next season then if they are doing it that way. Our club does sensational sit-down meals now and are well priced, I'll be pushing to hold a count at Smithfield next season on the week leading up to the GF.
They could do the whole count as it wouldn't need to be compressed, everyone in attendance would be there to see who the winners will be.
Well done PDCA, getting with the times, I have a list of other things that would step up the comp for next season, roll on AGM.
by Grahaml » Thu Mar 31, 2011 5:11 pm
sports follower wrote:Lightning McQueen wrote:whufc wrote:
Yeah they had pre counted all the 1 & 2 votes and the leader board up after those votes had been counted. Shane Rundle was infront at that point with 9 votes.
Then they procedded to read out all the 3 vote getters from each game round by round with an updated ladder at the end of each round. Was displayed on a power point presentation showing the ladder and 3 vote getter from the previous round.
Was well done.
Yeah West Ham and good memories arent usually used in the same sentence but that is one occasion i remember fondly.
Sh!t, that exceded what I thought he'd get, must've picked up a couple where the ump chose ball over bat.
I have a good idea for next season then if they are doing it that way. Our club does sensational sit-down meals now and are well priced, I'll be pushing to hold a count at Smithfield next season on the week leading up to the GF.
They could do the whole count as it wouldn't need to be compressed, everyone in attendance would be there to see who the winners will be.
Well done PDCA, getting with the times, I have a list of other things that would step up the comp for next season, roll on AGM.
It was good and definately an improvement but still room for more improvement IMO.
Need some colour to the powerpoint presentation and showed on a proper screen and not a sheet but hey its a start.
Also had a few minor glitches with the microphone.
I know Elaine was disappointed with the lack of numbers overall and they catered for 160 I think and would of struggled to have 120 there. Most clubs were represented but I would of thought the premiership sides would of had greater numbers there, I know last season Modbury turned up in a mini bus.
by MadMax » Thu Mar 31, 2011 5:39 pm
sports follower wrote:It was good and definately an improvement but still room for more improvement IMO.
Need some colour to the powerpoint presentation and showed on a proper screen and not a sheet but hey its a start.
Also had a few minor glitches with the microphone.
I know Elaine was disappointed with the lack of numbers overall and they catered for 160 I think and would of struggled to have 120 there. Most clubs were represented but I would of thought the premiership sides would of had greater numbers there, I know last season Modbury turned up in a mini bus.
by sports follower » Thu Mar 31, 2011 5:41 pm
Browny25 wrote:Do other clubs think BL should still have a grade 1 side next year? - Being our C grade from this season (grade 4 would be)
This is what has been said from the PDCA, hopefully tongue in cheek.
by catchit » Thu Mar 31, 2011 8:57 pm
Browny25 wrote:catchit wrote:Browny25 wrote:Lightning McQueen wrote:Congratulations to Jamie on the McKenzie Medal, thoroughly deserved winner.
Does anyone have any other placings etc.?
Sibbick 18
Jimmy 15
Justin Carmen 15
Dont know the rest.
Just think if jim played against oth and parafield in the last 2 games he would of been all over the medal...
Yep - Would have gone to Jimmy
Apparently BJ didnt get the votes when he made a ton
by catchit » Thu Mar 31, 2011 9:08 pm
sports follower wrote:Browny25 wrote:Do other clubs think BL should still have a grade 1 side next year? - Being our C grade from this season (grade 4 would be)
This is what has been said from the PDCA, hopefully tongue in cheek.
I have also heard this from a PDCA committee member but not Elaine.
Was this comment from Elaine? Dont think she was overly impressed with Sibbs final remarks in his speech when he said " it was a good way to leave PDCA". By the look on her face I dont think she was impressed but I maybe wrong, I have been before.
by catchit » Thu Mar 31, 2011 9:15 pm
Grahaml wrote:How old should Peter Sleep be before he's allowed to play PDCA then?
It's Brahma that want to do all this, nobody forced you guys to move half your club to a different association. It's not up to the association to satisfy your club's whims as if that's the only thing that matters to the whole competition. If you seriously expected to be able to just say to the association your A and B grade sides were going and have the others left where they were and be given carte blanche to pick whomever you wanted in whatever association you decided each week, then your club must be very naive.
by Executive Member » Thu Mar 31, 2011 10:25 pm
catchit wrote:Grahaml wrote:How old should Peter Sleep be before he's allowed to play PDCA then?
It's Brahma that want to do all this, nobody forced you guys to move half your club to a different association. It's not up to the association to satisfy your club's whims as if that's the only thing that matters to the whole competition. If you seriously expected to be able to just say to the association your A and B grade sides were going and have the others left where they were and be given carte blanche to pick whomever you wanted in whatever association you decided each week, then your club must be very naive.
Very good... Piss off brahma...we are full...
by Phantom Gossiper » Thu Mar 31, 2011 10:45 pm
Executive Member wrote:By the the way forgot to ask if the minor premiers and premiership favorites don't win the gf is that a choke
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |