Lightning McQueen wrote:Rolls Royce wrote:Lightning McQueen wrote:Hey Rolls, how do you gain access to who got what votes in each game, I didn't know that it was displayed anywhere.
What's the general consensus on "fielding votes", who else thinks it is the biggest crock going around, what makes it worse is when the PDCA send out a leaderboard with a couple of rounds to go, I seen someone gain ten points in the last two rounds, the funny thing is, we played them in the last round and he got none from us, he barely touched the ball.
There is no possible way to find a fair system, maybe "most catches or dismissals" otherwise it is a nothing award. We had a kid win our B grade one, he bowled well for the year, he took a few catches, there were some weeks where he got votes just for being young.
Mr Gary Venn had all the votes round by round on a piece of paper on presentation night. A club delegate had a quick look at it and almost fell over after what he saw. Get this....the same player who scored 192no only recieved 2 votes for that particular game.
But you are correct, they are not public common knowledge.
Fielding votes....meh. I believe it should be a wicketkeepers award like they do in turf. You are spot on again....a pretty ordinary award if you ask me.
That's sort of fair, just a bit of a concern that the guy with slick hands in the slips or an outstanding outfielder can't get rewarded, there is no proper way of judging. I always wait for the other captain to do theirs to see if they take it serious as it annoys the crap out of me when they don't, I've had to hide players in the field coz they are having a shocking day and they seem to get votes against some teams in particular.
192 not out and only two votes, along with Adam's debacle, a little bit of common sense doesn't hurt once in a while.
That was Adam also....maybe they have it in for him ?