by carey18 » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:33 pm
by Phantom Gossiper » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:45 pm
by Ecky » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:48 pm
carey18 wrote:lol back then i would of been a bit fired up. Now i just have a laugh. have we heard how Fitzroy went tonight at the meeting?
John Olsen, June 2012 wrote:"Reserves teams in the SANFL for the two AFL clubs is not negotiable.
We will not compromise the SANFL competition (with AFL reserves teams)."
by bloodybouncer » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:49 pm
by Phantom Gossiper » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:50 pm
Ecky wrote:carey18 wrote:lol back then i would of been a bit fired up. Now i just have a laugh. have we heard how Fitzroy went tonight at the meeting?
Fitzroy put forward a very good argument why they should not have been deducted the points, so the motion of whether the 3 points should be reinstated or not was put to the club delegates. There were 8 votes for and 8 votes against, with a number of clubs (including the other Div 1 clubs) abstaining. So the motion missed out by one vote of being accepted, so the 3 point penalty stands and Fitzroy As will not be playing in the finals.
It was good to see that all the discussion was carried out in good spirits and the debate never became heated, and the Fitzroy delegates were willing to accept the decision.
by Phantom Gossiper » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:51 pm
bloodybouncer wrote:NEWS JUST IN.....
Fitzroys deducted points to stand....paralowie to play finals.
In what can only be described as an epic hearing, it went to member votes, with equal ballots for and against. Call it an indecision to decide i guess??
Glenys was quite fiery from what i hear too.....
Intersting to note that all the votes to reverse the decision where non-church teams....all the votes to keep the point dedcuted where church originals, with the div1 teams present abstaining from the votes (which i can sort of understand).
anyway, thats done for us. lets see what happens with our c-grade, and then next year...in or out of this league.
by bloodybouncer » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:52 pm
Ecky wrote:carey18 wrote:lol back then i would of been a bit fired up. Now i just have a laugh. have we heard how Fitzroy went tonight at the meeting?
Fitzroy put forward a very good argument why they should not have been deducted the points, so the motion of whether the 3 points should be reinstated or not was put to the club delegates. There were 8 votes for and 8 votes against, with a number of clubs (including the other Div 1 clubs) abstaining. So the motion missed out by one vote of being accepted, so the 3 point penalty stands and Fitzroy As will not be playing in the finals.
It was good to see that all the discussion was carried out in good spirits and the debate never became heated, and the Fitzroy delegates were willing to accept the decision.
by carey18 » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:54 pm
by Phantom Gossiper » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:56 pm
bloodybouncer wrote:Ecky wrote:carey18 wrote:lol back then i would of been a bit fired up. Now i just have a laugh. have we heard how Fitzroy went tonight at the meeting?
Fitzroy put forward a very good argument why they should not have been deducted the points, so the motion of whether the 3 points should be reinstated or not was put to the club delegates. There were 8 votes for and 8 votes against, with a number of clubs (including the other Div 1 clubs) abstaining. So the motion missed out by one vote of being accepted, so the 3 point penalty stands and Fitzroy As will not be playing in the finals.
It was good to see that all the discussion was carried out in good spirits and the debate never became heated, and the Fitzroy delegates were willing to accept the decision.
....is accepting an indecsion acceptable??? i guess we exhausted all avenues to convince enough people to reverse. i cant think of a way to get around this just now!! anyway, its done and dusted for us....let hope lessons will be learnt by all
by Phantom Gossiper » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:57 pm
carey18 wrote:Phantom were you playing next season?
by bloodybouncer » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:59 pm
Phantom Gossiper wrote:bloodybouncer wrote:Ecky wrote:carey18 wrote:lol back then i would of been a bit fired up. Now i just have a laugh. have we heard how Fitzroy went tonight at the meeting?
Fitzroy put forward a very good argument why they should not have been deducted the points, so the motion of whether the 3 points should be reinstated or not was put to the club delegates. There were 8 votes for and 8 votes against, with a number of clubs (including the other Div 1 clubs) abstaining. So the motion missed out by one vote of being accepted, so the 3 point penalty stands and Fitzroy As will not be playing in the finals.
It was good to see that all the discussion was carried out in good spirits and the debate never became heated, and the Fitzroy delegates were willing to accept the decision.
....is accepting an indecsion acceptable??? i guess we exhausted all avenues to convince enough people to reverse. i cant think of a way to get around this just now!! anyway, its done and dusted for us....let hope lessons will be learnt by all
Its a tough one, personally i think the issue needed to be sorted BEFORE the last round ahd finished, i mean seriously this is an issue from before the new year isnt it?
Whether they are trying to make an example out of your side i dont know, 3 points is harsh i agree, unfortunately i really think leaving it so long like i said is worse.
Imagine if it were over turned? Paralowie think they are in, then they are out, you guys go in etc. Going into the last round every club should have known where it stood. Sorry if it doesnt make sense, very tired at the moment
I really hope you stick around next season...
by carey18 » Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:59 pm
by Magpies96 » Mon Feb 23, 2009 11:00 pm
by Phantom Gossiper » Mon Feb 23, 2009 11:02 pm
Magpies96 wrote:Should of been sorted out weeks ago, not left to the meeting before finals.
Don't think I want to comment any further.
Good luck to Paralowie and the rest of the teams playing finals.
by Phantom Gossiper » Mon Feb 23, 2009 11:04 pm
by carey » Mon Feb 23, 2009 11:19 pm
Ruffhead wrote:Hmm clearly brain cells are a rare aspect of your family my friend! How can you call it a weak performance, look at the facts.
Fact 1.. You lost
Fact 2.. you were bowled out on the first day for less runs than a primary school side.
Fact 3.. you conceded almost 100 runs per hour, quality bowling!
Fact 4.. Chance to win outright guess what, yep refer fact 1!
by carey » Mon Feb 23, 2009 11:23 pm
Ruffhead wrote:carey18 wrote:You are a dick just showing your real talent with posts like that. And you sooked because one of your players got called a homo!!!. grab a Kleenex champ
See not talking about that dick! Talking about you guys bragging your hot s***t. As usual quick to sling not so quick to take.
by carey » Mon Feb 23, 2009 11:34 pm
carey18 wrote:If it had of got reversed we would of accepted it.I for one dont agree with leaving it so late. Really hope Fitzroy stay around as i have always respected the people out there and the club
by carey » Mon Feb 23, 2009 11:41 pm
Phantom Gossiper wrote:Ecky wrote:carey18 wrote:lol back then i would of been a bit fired up. Now i just have a laugh. have we heard how Fitzroy went tonight at the meeting?
Fitzroy put forward a very good argument why they should not have been deducted the points, so the motion of whether the 3 points should be reinstated or not was put to the club delegates. There were 8 votes for and 8 votes against, with a number of clubs (including the other Div 1 clubs) abstaining. So the motion missed out by one vote of being accepted, so the 3 point penalty stands and Fitzroy As will not be playing in the finals.
It was good to see that all the discussion was carried out in good spirits and the debate never became heated, and the Fitzroy delegates were willing to accept the decision.
This is good to hear. BB fire 'em up and come out roaring next season! I highly anticipate our clash! Oh and i've decided young pidge, 3rd ball i will put you over your head and into the next suburb, you can take that tip to the bank!
by carey » Tue Feb 24, 2009 12:41 am
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |