bagster wrote:good changes PG

....i could see it that way too.. but id still would prefer a w/k separate from opening the bat, tough for the lad to do both at senior rep level........ Brookes /Feltus swap , ok you see them every week, you would know......but does Willi bat at 6 ???, never against us...but he does however bowl left arm around.......do you use a batsman that can bowl a few tweekers ? or a spinner that plays as a spinner regardless if he can bat ?... he might sqeeze out the full time left arm spinner because he can bat ......slightly better

.... bit like the w/k batsman or the batting w/k selection.. and agreed Carmen would slot in wherever it suited ahead of Leo.....

Sorry mate, that wasn't in batting order, that was just the squad. IMO Willi opens and Trav goes down the middle as primarily a keeper who is more than capable with the bat.
Norman was good with the gloves last week, but anyone who gets out to my I dont rate
As for the spinner it's simple, either you go with a specialist spinner or not one at all... you can afford not to go with a spinner since you have Davies, Carmen, McInnes, Jenner & Scott, but having a 12 man squad and playing an extra batter then you are not losing anything and infact gaining an option by playing a spinner...
My line up is as follows: