jb wrote:CoverKing wrote:jb wrote:so if the association played this week?
S.McCrae
S.Basso
R.Curyer
D.Sampson
H.Mackay
P.Devine
R.Hopkins
D.Rowe
B.McCormack
J.Calderbank
M.O'malley
So far, i would without looking too much into results, i would say McCrae and Basso are definites for opening. Curyer to bat at 3 (best bat bats at 3) well he shouldnt be there, and neither should sambo IMO. Devine, im not sure, one score is it?? Mackay is a definite, im not sure on facts but is he the only person to score 2 centurys in the first 5 games since Richie Press around 3 years ago? And if ya ask Ramblers, Ben McCormack wont be keeping!!! But as bowlers, i think its obvious Hoppy, Rowe, O Malley pick themselves! Tonkes unlucky to miss out IMO
Also young J. Quirk and his leggies seem to be coming along quite nicely. Looks like he has improved a lot since last year! (not saying he is in the association side)
3 and 4 the worry in that side. Without looking at statistics have they made 100 between them? Plus Sambo doesnt really bat at 4 i dont think! Not sure what Scott Luders needs to do to get in that side JB!!

But im happy to pay that i was wrong RE: Heath, altho he still has not made runs against a good bowling side

so ck what does sambo have to do to get a game after he was our best player in every single game last year, if bmac wont keep then naismith or patching will play, devine and hartlett have made more runs than luders? and also rusty made runs in 2 of the 3 games last year and captain the last game, u cant just turf him after that
Yes obviously Sambos performances last year would come into it! To be honest Rowe, where would he play? yes he probably the best player in the comp, however he would not make himself available! ANd from what i hear, Sambos opening spell against a star studded turf line up, he does deserve to be picked for a long based on that. His batting i think, tho as a number 4 bat, i personally could not justify!
Im not sure where Hartlett came from in this discussion, but trusting what you have said, he has made more runs then Luders as has Devine, however im sure Luders average would be either 2nd or 3rd in the comp would it not?
And Bazza would be able to shed more light, but surely if someone was going to be picked at 6 in an association side, then they would want to be able to score at a quick rate which luders is extremely capable of doing! IIRC Devine, is one that likes to bat long periods and be extremely patient, such is his runs in the 2 day format!