SA Footy

What in your opinion is the SANFL's most infamous on-field incident, and why?

Here's a few to get you started, feel free to add your own:

1982 Prelim - Granger v Cornes.

1991 GF - Sims v Simpson.

1985 Richmond Oval - Riley v Luders.

1977 GF - Phillis v Evans in the goal square.

1967(?) at the Parade - Kerley v Nygaard.

1988 at the Parade - Centrals v Norwood pre-game scuffle at the same end.

1975 - Norm Dare jumping in the crowd to hide during the head count.

For mine, the Granger incident probably ranks as the most infamous. Would like to know more about the 1977 GF incident, all I know is that they were both wandering around dazed in the second quarter and apparently no-one who reported on the game saw what happened.

Theres also
*Evans/Balme 84 GF
*Salisbury/Anderson 86
*Aish/Ryan circa 88
*Dilena/Johnston 88
*Wynne/Opposition coaches box 78 GF

Robbie Muir v the crowd at Thebarton

'84 - Evans v Balme in my mind.

'91 - Sims v Anyone within reach

'86 - Salisbury v Anderson - was right in front of me, I was on the fence about 12m from the incident. Remember it like it was yesterday, not 30 years ago.

No mention of Port's failed AFL bid? It has proven to be the biggest upheaval in the competitions history.

At the risk of inflaming an already volatile subject matter, would the 6-2 vote to accept Port and Adelaide's entry be up there?

I know I'm taking things off field, but they are both very significant moments in the timeline of the SANFL.

Booney wrote:No mention of Port's failed AFL bid? It has proven to be the biggest upheaval in the competitions history.

At the risk of inflaming an already volatile subject matter, would the 6-2 vote to accept Port and Adelaide's entry be up there?

I know I'm taking things off field, but they are both very significant moments in the timeline of the SANFL.

Fair call Booney - definitely controversial and competition changing events, although I did have on-field stuff in mind when posting. But it's a Friday, so I'll let it slide.

Magellan wrote:

Booney wrote:No mention of Port's failed AFL bid? It has proven to be the biggest upheaval in the competitions history.

At the risk of inflaming an already volatile subject matter, would the 6-2 vote to accept Port and Adelaide's entry be up there?

I know I'm taking things off field, but they are both very significant moments in the timeline of the SANFL.

Fair call Booney - definitely controversial and competition changing events, although I did have on-field stuff in mind when posting. But it's a Friday, so I'll let it slide.

I think for the purposes of this discussion we stay on field, considering the subject matter I've raised and where my allegiance lies.

GWW wrote:Theres also
*Evans/Balme 84 GF
*Salisbury/Anderson 86
*Aish/Ryan circa 88
*Dilena/Johnston 88
*Wynne/Opposition coaches box 78 GF

Thanks GWW, these are good additions. I recall going to Footy Park for the second half of that double header (Port v Sturt followed by Centrals v North - a then record crowd for a minor round game?) and hearing on the radio the incident and aftermath. Certainly a lot of discussion about at at the time.

Salisbury v Anderson in the 1986 qualifying final was big news too - I recall the Sunday mail the next day with the massive headline "Anderson KO'd").

James Gowans sniper shot on Shane Schubert?

1997 prelim final - McIntosh whacking a kid and missing the GF the following week. Which was followed by him receiving a premiership medal.
Just another example of an NFC disgrace being offset by the SANFL's favouritism.

Dogwatcher wrote:1997 prelim final - McIntosh whacking a kid and missing the GF the following week. Which was followed by him receiving a premiership medal.
Just another example of an NFC disgrace being offset by the SANFL's favouritism.

Who did he hit?

Port picking Max James in 84 GF

Macca hit Dew,

Magellan wrote:

Dogwatcher wrote:1997 prelim final - McIntosh whacking a kid and missing the GF the following week. Which was followed by him receiving a premiership medal.
Just another example of an NFC disgrace being offset by the SANFL's favouritism.

Who did he hit?

Stewart Dew.

Booney wrote:James Gowans sniper shot on Shane Schubert?

never

From memory there was a Salisbury/Champion incident, anyone confirm/provide further info?

GWW wrote:From memory there was a Salisbury/Champion incident, anyone confirm/provide further info?

1990 Foundation Cup Grand Final.

2:44 mark.

I'll get some dates but:
McIntosh v Greg Williams
Greg Turbill v Bob Tardiff

The two snipers came off 2nd best against the Norwood players
Tardiff was very funny. Played the big tough man against a kid and got belted into the next quarter

Booney wrote:2:44 mark.

Viscious headbutt to poor Scooters arm (he was just trying to protect himself)

You thug, Champion....

Scooter....what a rubbish nickname. Should have been Sniper.