SA Footy

Something to do off season :
Who is the best player you have seen by club ..... pick one only !

Norwood : Garry McIntosh
West : Robert Day
Centrals : John Platten
North : Barrie Robran
Eagles : Lindsay Head
Woodville : Malcolm Blight
Port : John Cahill
South : Peter Darley
Sturt : Paul Bagshaw
Glenelg : Stephen Kernahan

Norwood : Michael Taylor
West : Keith Kuhlman
Centrals : Gilbert McAdam
North : Darren Jarman - never really saw Robran, certainly not in his prime (a regret)
Eagles : Neville Roberts
Woodville : Malcolm Blight
Port : Russell Ebert
South : ohn Schneebichler
Sturt : Paul Bagshaw
Glenelg : Graham Cornes

Norwood- Marty McKinnon
West- Nick Prokepec
North- Scott Stevens
South- James Boyd
Port- Jacob Surjan
Sturt- Steven Trigg
Eagles- Craig Gogoll
Glenelg- Nathan Grima's brother
Central- John Platten

Good Post.

Norwood : Alfred Waldron
West : Bruce McGregor
Centrals : Rudi Mandermaker
North : Barrie Robran
Eagles : Lindsay Head
Woodville : Malcolm Blight
Port : Russel Ebert
South : Peter Darley
Sturt : Rick Davies
Glenelg : Peter Carey

Port - Russell Ebert
Glenelg - Chris McDermott
Norwood - Michael Aish
South - Mark Naley
Central District - John Platten
North - Darren Jarman
Torrens - Bruce Lindsay
Sturt - John Paynter
Woodville - John Klug
West - Grantley Fielke

We would all like to know the official Club's Best Player.

SDK.

Please Advise.

Homework needed here...

I doubt there's an actual official best player for each club, its mainly opinion, although some are relatively obvious (eg Robran).

If I was to guess who is universally considered best at each club, I would say:

Port - Ebert
North - Robran
Centrals - Platten
Glenelg - Carey (or Kernahan)
Sturt - Bagshaw (or Davies)..EDIT - I forgot Fitzgerald
Torrens - Bob Hank (or Head)
Woodville - Blight
West - Eustice??
Norwood - McIntosh
South - Darley (or Moriarty)

Central Derek Kickett
Norwood Mackintosh
North Robran
Torrens Lindsey Head
Glenelg Carey
South Kantilla
Port Ebert
Sturt Davies
Woodville Sewer
West Luders

Central - Wilbur Wilson
Glenelg - Stephen Kernahan
North - Barrie Robran
Norwood - Michael Taylor
Port - Brian Cunningham
Sturt - Paul Bagshaw
South - Mark Naley
West Adelaide - Peter Meuret
West Torrens - Bruce Lindsay
Woodville - Malcolm Blight

Have chosen these on who I saw play in the flesh..

Norwood. Gary McIntosh
Sturt.........Paul Bagshaw
West........Peter Meuret
Centrals...John Platten
North........Barry Robran
W Torrens.Lindsay Head
Woodville..Malcolm Blight
Glenelg....Graham Cornes
Port .......Russell Ebert
South .....Peter Darley

The best I've seen from each club:

Port: Scott Hodges
Central: Rick Macgowan
Sturt: Damian Squire
West: Grant Fielke
Norwood: Gary McIntosh
Glenelg: Nick Chigwidden
South: Mark Naley
Eagles: Gavin Colville
North: James Allan

Port: John Cahill
Norwood : Ben Warren
West : Luke Norman
Centrals : James Boyd
North : Michael Handby
Eagles : Craig Parry
Woodville : Paul Harridene
South : Greg Klenjens
Sturt : Eddie Fry
Glenelg : John Schneebichler

daysofourlives wrote:Glenelg- Nathan Grima's brother

LMAO

Norwood....Michael Taylor
Sturt.........Paul Bagshaw
West.........Neil Kerley
Centrals.....Gary Window
North.........Barry Robran
W Torrens...Lindsay Head
Woodville....Ralph Sewer
Glenelg.......Peter Marker
Port ..........Geoff Motley
South ........Peter Darley

JK wrote:

daysofourlives wrote:Glenelg- Nathan Grima's brother

LMAO

Alex?

North-Robran
Port-Ebert
West-Ricciuto
Norwood-Carmen
Centrals-Platten
Woodville-Blight
South-Naley
Torrens-Roberts
Eagles-Pavlich
Sturt-Davies

no-one worthy from the Bays?

Dog_ger wrote:Good Post.

Norwood : Alfred Waldron
West : Bruce McGregor
Centrals : Rudi Mandermaker
North : Barrie Robran
Eagles : Lindsay Head
Woodville : Malcolm Blight
Port : Russel Ebert
South : Peter Darley
Sturt : Rick Davies
Glenelg : Peter Carey

If you saw all of those players, how come you haven't got Bob Hank as your Torrens player. As great as Lindsay Head was I have never met a footy supporter who saw them both who thought he was better than Bob Hank. And I certainly knew a lot of people who saw them both.

robranisgod wrote:

Dog_ger wrote:Good Post.

Norwood : Alfred Waldron
West : Bruce McGregor
Centrals : Rudi Mandermaker
North : Barrie Robran
Eagles : Lindsay Head
Woodville : Malcolm Blight
Port : Russel Ebert
South : Peter Darley
Sturt : Rick Davies
Glenelg : Peter Carey

If you saw all of those players, how come you haven't got Bob Hank as your Torrens player. As great as Lindsay Head was I have never met a footy supporter who saw them both who thought he was better than Bob Hank. And I certainly knew a lot of people who saw them both.

OTR to thread, OTR to thread!!!