SA Footy

Club Rankings in ALL components since 1991 inclusive

OUTSTANDING
Centrals (rags to riches)

ACCEPTABLE
Eagles (new kids ((X2 clubs)) on the block)
Port (perennial competitors)
North (always entertaining even in the Hart era)
Sturt (good recovery after poor start)
Norwood (just)

EMBARASSING
Glenelg (under achievers)
West (too many imports)
South (lucky to make this level)

Port's won more Premierships in that time than even Central.

Not judged just on premierships though

If you are going to span 1991-2007 you have to put Port as 'outstanding'

Premiers 92,94,95,96,98,99 runners up 97

If you spanned 2000-2007 then just 'acceptable'

Plus Eagles with 2 premierships in 93 and 06 + runners up in 94, 00, 01, 04, 05 thats 7 GF appearances - better than 'acceptable' IMO

It needs more than 3 groups unless you are just trying to plug the Doggies (well deserved 'outstanding' rating)

Who is 'winning' the wooden spoon awards over this time.

We have zero

Col D
Personal Post Only

cd wrote:Who is 'winning' the wooden spoon awards over this time.

We have zero

Col D
Personal Post Only

Port and Central also hasn't finished last in this time as well.

Premiers since 1991:
Port - 6
Central - 5
Eagles - 2
North - 1
Norwood - 1
Sturt - 1

Grand Finals since 1991:
Central - 9
Port - 7
Eagles - 7
Norwood - 3
Sturt - 2
West - 2
North - 1
Glenelg - 1

Years in finals since 1991 - including this year:
Central - 14
Eagles - 14
Port - 13
Norwood - 10
West - 8
North - 8
Sturt - 8
Glenelg - 5
South - 3

Wooden spoons since 1991 - including this year:
Sturt - 6
Glenelg - 4
West - 3
North - 2
South - 1
Norwood - 1

hondo71 wrote:If you are going to span 1991-2007 you have to put Port as 'outstanding'

Premiers 92,94,95,96,98,99 runners up 97

If you spanned 2000-2007 then just 'acceptable'

Plus Eagles with 2 premierships in 93 and 06 + runners up in 94, 00, 01, 04, 05 thats 7 GF appearances - better than 'acceptable' IMO

It needs more than 3 groups unless you are just trying to plug the Doggies (well deserved 'outstanding' rating)

Agreed Hondo. The Eagles have been the most consistent of all clubs in that time frame in the terms of playing finals footy. Allthough not enjoying as much premiership success as Central I believe the Eagles form would warrant outstanding in the terms of the original post.

Central, Eagles and Port the have been the comp leaders 1991-2007

Number of grand finals in that span not involving one of those teams = 1 (1991)

eaglehaslanded wrote:

hondo71 wrote:If you are going to span 1991-2007 you have to put Port as 'outstanding'

Premiers 92,94,95,96,98,99 runners up 97

If you spanned 2000-2007 then just 'acceptable'

Plus Eagles with 2 premierships in 93 and 06 + runners up in 94, 00, 01, 04, 05 thats 7 GF appearances - better than 'acceptable' IMO

It needs more than 3 groups unless you are just trying to plug the Doggies (well deserved 'outstanding' rating)

Agreed Hondo. The Eagles have been the most consistent of all clubs in that time frame in the terms of playing finals footy. Allthough not enjoying as much premiership success as Central I believe the Eagles form would warrant outstanding in the terms of the original post.

In terms of consistency it's us and Central, then Port close behind, Port would have of course been miles ahead up until 2001.

I think its pretty clearcut taking into account spellys stats.

1. Port
2. Central
3. Eagles
4. Norwood
5. North
6. Sturt
7. Glenelg
8. West
9. South

Wedgie wrote:I think its pretty clearcut taking into account spellys stats.

1. Port
2. Central
3. Eagles
4. Norwood
5. North
6. Sturt
7. Glenelg
8. West
9. South

I think you have Glenelg and West the wrong way around

We have double the grand final appearances

More finals appearances

Less spoons

We would also be above Sturt apart from that Premiership of theirs.....

Re Grand Finals
Magpies record is amazing 6 flags from 7 appearances = 86% win record

Centrals 5 from 9 = 55%

Eagles 2 from 7 = 28%

Col D
Personal Post Only

cd wrote:Re Grand Finals
Magpies record is amazing 6 flags from 7 appearances = 86% win record

Centrals 5 from 9 = 55%

Eagles 2 from 7 = 28%

Col D
Personal Post Only

The Eagles are like the Bays in the 80's 2 from 7

However, do not forget that PAM only existed from the mid 1990's onwards

Not this again

Who cares about the pre 2000 period

Well said, Doggies, who is worried about what happened last millennium. That is like going back into the Stone Age *grins*
Cheers

Rocket, good to see I got a bite!. I thought it would be from a Port supporter though! *grins*

bulldogproud wrote:Well said, Doggies, who is worried about what happened last millennium. That is like going back into the Stone Age *grins*
Cheers

Rocket, good to see I got a bite!. I thought it would be from a Port supporter though! *grins*

Nah, mate just bracing for the inevitable 10 pages of replies arguing back and forth about your point. Who really cares.

I sure don't. It was before 2000, so before real football started.