on the rails wrote:Aerie wrote:on the rails wrote:teaoby wrote:I saw a tweet form ABC journalist James Coventry, that NO SA or WA player pre 1960 has been inducted yet into the AUSTRALIAN Football Hall of Fame.
******* Victorians are a joke! every club from SA and WA would have 2-3 players pre that era deserving of the honor!
Well he is wrong and typically ignorant. There are quite a few Dan Moriaty and Ken Farmer are two that spring to mind for starters!
Yeah, pretty sure Hank and Head are too. Perhaps he means "legends"?
True - but if that is the case then Farmer certainly should have been elevated to Legend Status by now! Would be nice to have two Rooster greats as Legends!
And 3 other rooster greats should be members of the Hall of Fame. Tom Leahy, Ian McKay and Don Lindner.
It is a disgrace that the first two in particular aren't members. When Mike Coward and Geoff Kingston did their list of the 40 greatest SANFL players of the first 100 years they rated Leahy number 5 and McKay number 11. I know that it is only two men's opinion, but they would have done a lot of research, more than I believe the selectors for the Hall of Fame do.
Leahy was considered the best ruckman in Australia for over a decade and McKay had a fantastic record at State level, especially standing AFL legend John Coleman. It almost seems as though McKay has been burdened by his famous mark as though it was a one off, when he used to do it regularly. A full back winning the Magarey Medal was unprecedented.