SANFL clubs v other clubs

[JamesH]

Im trying to compile a list of SANFL clubs results against other clubs/leagues... so far I have 2000-2006

2002 Adelaide ‘B’ 10.6-66 d Central District 3.9-27 (Norwood)
Adelaide 16.9-105 d Norwood 4.4-28 (Norwood)
2003 Adelaide ‘B’ 12.12-84 d Woodville-West Torrens 7.1-43 (Norwood)
Adelaide 18.13-121 d Norwood 3.3-21 (Norwood)
Port Adelaide (AFL) 28.21-189 d Sturt 2.4-16 (Alberton)
2004 Glenelg 1.11.8-83 d Adelaide ‘B’ 7.3-45* (Norwood)
Adelaide 2.14.16-118 d Norwood 4.4-28* (Norwood)
2005 Adelaide d Norwood-North (Norwood) 11.2.05
2006 North Adelaide 14.6-90 d Northern Territory 9.13-67 (Darwin)
Adelaide 19.7-121 d Norwood 8.77 (Norwood)
* played under AFL Pre-Season rules.

Im aware that in 1991 Bris d St, in 1994 Syd d WWT... I also beleive that Claremont and WWT played in the early 90s

[spell_check]

The Brisbane Sturt scores were:

Brisbane 9.2 20.5 -.- 29.15 (189)
Sturt 0.1 2.3 -.- 7.7 (49)
Gabba

I worked out the 1st and 2nd quarter scores from the article; there was only the final score published.

This is a trial match from 1990:
Geelong 3.4 12.8 15.14 22.18 (150)
Port Adelaide 2.5 3.8 10.10 14.14 (98)
Football Park, 30000

[JamesH]

Other known matches

In 1991
WWT v Adelaide 'B' - first match for both clubs

Mid 90s (93/94??)
Port v Collingwood - I remember this match was a big deal at the time for the PAFC... much unlike the others that were nothing bit trials.

1994
WWT v Sydney (Fosters Cup Challenge)

1997/98???
PA 'B' v PAM

[JamesH]

Australia Day matches involving SANFL clubs

1966 NA 9.11-65 d NT 7.9-51
1985 NT 18.18-126 d G 14.7-91
1989 NT 11.20-86 d PAM 12.5-77

[JamesH]

1985-Rep-Dar NT 18.18-126 d G 14.7-91
1989-Rep-Dar NT 11.20-86 d PAM 12.5-77
1990-Oth-FP Geelong 22.18-150 d PAM 14.14-90
1991-Oth-BCG Brisbane 29.15-189 d St 7.7-49
1994-Oth-FP Sydney d WWT
2002-Oth-Nor Adelaide ‘B’ 10.6-66 d CD 3.9-27
2002-Oth-Nor Adelaide 16.9-105 d N 4.4-28
2003-Oth-Nor Adelaide ‘B’ 12.12-84 d WWT 7.1-43
2003-Oth-Nor Adelaide 18.13-121 d N3.3-21
2003-Oth-Alb Port Adelaide (AFL) 28.21-189 d St 2.4-16
2004-Oth-Nor G 1.11.8-83 d Adelaide ‘B’ 7.3-45*
2004-Oth-Nor Adelaide 2.14.16-118 d N 4.4-28*
2005-Oth-Nor Adelaide d Norwood-North (date: 11.2.05)
2006-Rep-Mar NA 14.6-90 d Northern Territory FL 9.13-67
2006-Oth-Nor Adelaide 19.7-121 d N 8.77
* played under AFL Pre-Season rules.

[spell_check]

I did have the Sydney/Eagles score somewhere, I went to that game; we were 4 goals up at quarter time, only to lose 15 goals to 8.

If only SANFL clubs weren't restricted in the salary cap and players weren't poached in the draft, they would be more competitive against the lower ranked AFL sides.

[Adelaide Hawk]

Are you interested in official matches as well as trial matches etc?

[JamesH]

any matches

[Leaping Lindner]

North played the newly formed Brisbane Bears at Carrara pre season 1987. I've got the score somewhere which I'll dig up for you. I can tell you however that North got flogged.

[spell_check]

North played the newly formed Brisbane Bears at Carrara pre season 1987. I've got the score somewhere which I'll dig up for you. I can tell you however that North got flogged.

I wonder how the North players treated Matthew Campbell on that day?

[Magpiespower]

Mid 90s (93/94??)
Port v Collingwood - I remember this match was a big deal at the time for the PAFC... much unlike the others that were nothing bit trials.

Collingwood won by three points.

Port kicked 3 or 4 goals in the last 10 minutes.

Both wore black and white!

[Punk Rooster]

I'm surprised no-one has brought up the obvious?
North Adelaide defeated Carlton, Adel Oval 1972
North Adelaide defeated Melbourne, FP 1986
North Adelaide defeated Collingwood, VFL Park 1986
North Adelaide lost to Hawthorm, VFL Park 1986

[biscuit]

Below is a list of 60 matches I know of that were played between SANFL and VFL clubs between 1901 and 1976.

The list below doesn't include any pre-season trial games, which were relatively common in the 1960's and 1970's.

Of interest is, that in the 60 matches listed below, SANFL clubs won 24, VFL clubs 35, with 1 drawn.

Norwood 8.8 56 lost to Carlton 11.13 79 1/10/1904 Adelaide Oval Exhibition match
Norwood 6.10 46 lost to Collingwood 9.13 67 16/08/1905 Adelaide Oval Exhibition match
Norwood 6.13 49 defeated Essendon 4.12 36 25/07/1906 East Melb. CG Exhibition
Norwood 14.7 91 defeated Fitzroy 8.13 61 1/08/1906 Melbourne Exhibition
Norwood 13.12 90 defeated Carlton 8.10 58 28/09/1907 Adelaide Oval Champions Of A
West Adelaide 12.9 81 defeated Carlton 7.10 52 3/10/1908 Adelaide Oval Champions of A
Port Adelaide 8.11 65 lost to Essendon 9.11 65 10/10/1908 Adelaide Oval Exhibition match
West Adelaide 6.14 50 lost to South Melbourne 11.8 74 9/10/1909 MCG Champions of A
Port Adelaide 15.20 110 defeated Collingwood 7.9 51 15/10/1910 Adelaide Oval Champions of A
North Adelaide defeated Collingwood 00/00/1911 SA Exhibition match
West Adelaide 8.9 57 defeated Essendon 7.12 54 11/10/1911 Adelaide Oval Champions of A
Port Adelaide 9.9 63 defeated Carlton 7.8 50 5/10/1912 Adelaide Oval Exhibition match
Port Adelaide 13.16 94 defeated Fitzroy 4.7 31 8/10/1913 Adelaide Oval Champions of A
South Adelaide 8.13 61 drew with Collingwood 9.7 61 00/08/1914 Brisbane Exhibition match
Port Adelaide 9.16 70 defeated Carlton 5.6 36 3/10/1914 Adelaide Oval Champions of A
North Adelaide 9.14 68 lost to Collingwood 15.17 107 13/10/1920 Jubilee Oval Exhibition match
Norwood 12.9 81 defeated Carlton 10.14 74 22/10/1920 Norwood Oval Exhibition match
North Adelaide lost to St Kilda 00/00/1922 Sydney Exhibition match
West Adelaide 9.12 66 lost to Collingwood 14.10 94 15/10/1927 Wayville S/g Premiers Match
Port Adelaide 17.25 127 defeated Geelong 11.5 71 14/10/1931 Alberton Oval Exhibition match
Port Adelaide 11.14 80 lost to Geelong 14.10 94 17/10/1931 Tanunda Exhibition match
South Adelaide 10.16 76 lost to Carlton 10.22 82 8/10/1938 Wayville S/g Premiers Match
Port Adelaide 12.14 86 lost to Footscray 13.16 94 00/00/1946 Hobart Exhibition match
Port Adelaide 6.18 54 lost to Geelong 8.14 62 6/10/1951 Adelaide Oval Premiers Match
West Torrens 11.13 79 defeated Footscray 8.11 59 7/10/1951 Weigal Oval Exhibition match
Port Adelaide 8.11 59 lost to Richmond 15.16 106 7/10/1954 Norwood Oval Exhibition match
Sturt 13.11 89 lost to South Melbourne 17.17 119 00/00/1954 SA Advertiser Cup
West Adelaide 13.9 87 lost to Hawthorn 13.10 88 00/00/1955 SA Advertiser Cup
Port Adelaide 9.10 64 lost to Melbourne 9.11 65 5/10/1955 Norwood Oval Premiers match
Norwood defeated Carlton 00/00/1956 SA Advertiser Cup
Port Adelaide 11.8 74 lost to Melbourne 13.6 84 10/10/1956 Norwood Oval Premiers Match
Port Adelaide 17.14 116 defeated Footscray 16.9 105 15/10/1957 Norwood Oval Exhibition match
Norwood 11.11 77 lost to Geelong 12.16 88 24/09/1958 Norwood Oval Advertiser Cup
Port Adelaide 12.15 87 lost to Fitzroy 16.17 113 2/10/1958 Norwood Oval Exhibition match
Norwood 6.13 49 lost to Footscray 11.12 78 9/10/1958 Norwood Oval Advertiser Cup
Port Adelaide 14.11 95 lost to Melbourne 20.17 137 7/10/1959 Norwood Oval Premiers Match
North Adelaide 7.10 52 lost to Melbourne 14.15 99 8/10/1960 Adelaide Oval Premiers Match
South Adelaide 9.3 57 lost to Melbourne 9.14 68 8/10/1964 Norwood Oval Premiers Match
Port Adelaide 11.15 81 defeated Geelong 10.10 70 00/10/1965 Norwood Oval Exhibition match
Sturt 18.12 120 defeated Collingwood 11.18 84 8/10/1966 Adelaide Oval Exhibition match
North Adelaide 11.11 77 lost to Geelong 9.26 80 3/10/1967 Norwood Oval Exhibition match
Port Adelaide 13.15 93 defeated Collingwood 12.9 81 5/10/1967 Norwood Oval Exhibition match
Sturt 19.8 122 defeated Carlton 11.15 81 7/10/1967 Adelaide Oval Exhibition match
Sturt 6.20 56 lost to Carlton 13.15 93 5/10/1968 Adelaide Oval Championship match
Sturt 9.10 64 lost to Richmond 15.27 117 11/10/1969 Adelaide Oval Championship match
Sturt 12.22 94 lost to Carlton 21.13 139 00/10/1970 Adelaide Oval Championship match
North Adelaide 10.7 67 lost to Hawthorn 13.13 91 2/10/1971 Adelaide Oval Championship match
Port Adelaide 9.3 57 defeated Richmond 8.8 56 9/10/1971 Perth Rothmans Cup
North Adelaide 5.3 33 lost to Richmond 6.4 40 10/10/1971 Perth Rothmans Cup
North Adelaide 10.13 73 defeated Carlton 10.12 72 15/10/1972 Adelaide Oval Champions of A
Glenelg 16.19 115 lost to Richmond 19.16 130 6/10/1973 Adelaide Oval Champions of A
Sturt 13.17 95 lost to Richmond 27.11 173 14/10/1974 Football Park Champions of A
Norwood 5.11 41 lost to North Melbourne 17.15 117 13/10/1975 Football Park Champions of A
Glenelg 11.10 76 defeated Richmond 9.8 62 17/05/1976 Football Park NFL Wills Cup
Port Adelaide 14.13 97 defeated Footscray 9.9 63 1/06/1976 Norwood Oval NFL Wills Cup
Port Adelaide 5.7 37 lost to North Melbourne 12.15 87 15/06/1976 Norwood Oval NFL Wills Cup
Norwood 22.14 146 defeated Carlton 5.10 40 22/06/1976 Norwood Oval NFL Wills Cup
Sturt 8.5 53 lost to Hawthorn 13.17 95 6/07/1976 Norwood Oval NFL Wills Cup
Glenelg 8.8 56 lost to Hawthorn 11.16 82 27/07/1976 Norwood Oval NFL Wills Cup
Norwood 5.5 35 lost to North Melbourne 8.5 53 3/08/1976 Norwood Oval NFL Wills Cup

Hope that this is helpful!

[Adelaide Hawk]

Some 1969 Trial Matches:

Hawthorn 18-10, d. Woodville 14-10
Footscray 14-9, d. Central District 10-12
Subiaco 21-10, d. Norwood 12-16 29th March, Norwood Oval
Sturt 22-10, d. Perth 14-16
Port Adelaide 9-8, d. South Melbourne 3-11
Fitzroy 8-15, d. North Adelaide 7-18
East Perth 20-18, d. Glenelg 10-21
Melbourne 15-12, d. Port Adelaide 10-15
Richmond 22-21, d. Glenwlg 12-3
St.Kilda 8-12, d. North Adelaide 7-11

1970: Footscray 21-20, d. Norwood 14-16 19th March, Norwood Oval

1971
March 20
Carlton 22-14, d. South Adelaide 14-12 St.Marys
Essendon 21-16, d. North Adelaide 11-12 Prospect
Melbourne 27-18, d. Norwood 9-11 MCG
Footscray 19-17, d. Central District 9-4 Western Oval
Richmond 27-21, d. Glenelg 17-12 VFL Park

March 27
Footscray 23-30, d. Glenelg 10-19 Glenelg Oval
East Fremantle 9-9, d. Central District 8-13 Perth
Port Adelaide 13-7, d. South Melbourne 11-16 Albert Park
North Melbourne 17-16, d. West Torrens 10-14 Arden Street
St.Kilda 14-17, d. Sturt 9-10 Moorabbin

[spell_check]

In 1908 in Sydney:

Norwood 2.3 8.6 12.8 13.9 (87)
New South Wales 1.2 1.3 1.3 2.6 (18)

Practice Matches in 1973:

St Kilda 4.2 8.11 11.18 16.22 (118)
North Adelaide 2.2 3.8 7.11 10.12 (72)
Moorabbin

Footscray 5.1 18.4 21.6 29.14 (188)
South Adelaide 5.3 5.6 9.10 10.11 (71)

Geelong 6.4 13.8 16.8 22.9 (141)
West Torrens 2.1 3.3 8.8 10.11 (71)

South Melbourne 3.3 11.6 15.8 15.12 (102)
Port Adelaide 1.2 4.4 6.7 12.12 (84)


1985 VFL Night Series
Norwood 3.3 3.7 7.10 12.11 (83)
Geelong 1.3 3.7 5.12 5.14 (44)
Football Park, 7446

[Macca19]

Mid 90s (93/94??)
Port v Collingwood - I remember this match was a big deal at the time for the PAFC... much unlike the others that were nothing bit trials.

Collingwood won by three points.

Port kicked 3 or 4 goals in the last 10 minutes.

Both wore black and white!

I remember that. I thought it was 1992 but It could have been later. Yes both teams both wore their usual guernseys. Surprsingly, there wasnt that much conflict.

Port Adelaide also played Fremantle in a trial game in the 1995 pre season. Darren Forrsman played his only game for the Magpies. Darryl Borlace got reported for charging and it saw the first viewing of a young flashy kid with long white hair charging off of half back in Clive Waterhouse.

Fremantle won by 4-5 goals if memory serves. Ill try and discover the score.

[JamesH]

current list od recent matches- not inlcuding VFL night series

1985-Rep-Dar Northern Territory 18.18-126 d G 14.7-91
1987-Oth-Car Brisbane d NA
1989-Rep-Dar Northern Territory 11.20-86 d PAM 12.5-77
1990-Oth-FP Geelong 22.18-150 d PAM 14.14-90
1991-Oth-BCG Brisbane 29.15-189 d St 7.7-49
1992?-Oth-FP Collingwood d PAM
1994-Oth-FP Sydney d WWT
1995-Oth-FP Fremantle 11.10-76 d PAM 5.8-38
2002-Oth-Nor Adelaide ‘B’ 10.6-66 d CD 3.9-27
2002-Oth-Nor Adelaide 16.9-105 d N 4.4-28
2003-Oth-Nor Adelaide ‘B’ 12.12-84 d WWT 7.1-43
2003-Oth-Nor Adelaide 18.13-121 d N3.3-21
2003-Oth-Alb Port Adelaide (AFL) 28.21-189 d St 2.4-16
2004-Oth-Nor G 1.11.8-83 d Adelaide ‘B’ 7.3-45*
2004-Oth-Nor Adelaide 2.14.16-118 d N 4.4-28*
2005-Oth-Nor Adelaide d Norwood-North (date: 11.2.05)
2006-Rep-Mar NA 14.6-90 d Northern Territory FL 9.13-67
2006-Oth-Nor Adelaide 19.7-121 d N 8.77
* played under AFL Pre-Season rules.

[drebin]

North also played Essendon Seconds in 2002 from memory and lost by a kick. Players went over and back in a bus with no stopover!

From memory the Bears beat us by about 66 points in 1986 or 87?

[JamesH]

the ever expanding list

1985-Rep-Dar Northern Territory 18.18-126 d G 14.7-91
1987-Oth-Car Brisbane d NA
1989-Rep-Dar Northern Territory 11.20-86 d PAM 12.5-77
1990-Oth-FP Geelong 22.18-150 d PAM 14.14-90
1991-Oth-BCG Brisbane 29.15-189 d St 7.7-49
1992-Oth-??? Adelaide v CD Sat March 14
1993-Oth-FP Collingwood 13.12-90 d PAM 13.9-87
1994-Oth-FP Sydney 15.17-107 d WWT 8.6-54
1995-Oth-FP Fremantle 11.10-76 d PAM 5.8-38
2002-Oth-Nor Adelaide ‘B’ 10.6-66 d CD 3.9-27
2002-Oth-Nor Adelaide 16.9-105 d N 4.4-28
2003-Oth-Nor Adelaide ‘B’ 12.12-84 d WWT 7.1-43
2003-Oth-Nor Adelaide 18.13-121 d N3.3-21
2003-Oth-Alb Port Adelaide (AFL) 28.21-189 d St 2.4-16
2004-Oth-Nor G 1.11.8-83 d Adelaide ‘B’ 7.3-45*
2004-Oth-Nor Adelaide 2.14.16-118 d N 4.4-28*
2005-Oth-Nor Adelaide d Norwood-North (date: 11.2.05)
2006-Rep-Mar NA 14.6-90 d Northern Territory FL 9.13-67
2006-Oth-Nor Adelaide 19.7-121 d N 8.77
* played under AFL Pre-Season rules.

[Magpiespower]

Reakon Crows Reserves played Port Magpies Reserves one year, too...