1991 GF Tribunal Help

[Mark_Beswick]

Can anyone help with regards to the final outomes of the 1991 tribunal of the WA v NA GF - I have the following from some hard to read handwritten notes - I have a feeling I have missed some or got a fact or two wrong - Any help appreciated

KLOMP, Kim - 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Abbott, M. D.)
MELLOR, Gregory John Outcome ?????

SIMS, Steven John 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Argent, L. J.)
SIMPSON, Kevin Matthew Striking Guilty Suspension 12 (Also reported by Goal Umpire Peter Symons)

PARSONS, Michael Wayne 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Argent, L. J.) GOSS, Glenn John Striking (Outcome???)

SCHUMANN, Dean Maxwell 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Argent, L. J.) KLOMP, Kim - Striking Guilty Suspension 2

BLYTHE, Sean Darrell 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Argent, L. J.) SIMS, Steven John Striking Guilty Suspension 3

SIMPSON, Kevin Matthew 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Review)) HART, Darel Peter Striking Not Guilty Dismissed 0

SCHUMANN, Dean Maxwell 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Review)) HAMILTON, Steven Kerry Striking Guilty Suspension 3

KLOMP, Kim - 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Review)) SCHUMANN, Dean Maxwell Unduly Rough Play Outcome ?????

MARSHALL, Marc - 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviewer)) BLYTHE, Sean Darrell Striking Not Guilty Dismissed 0

PERKINS, Timothy Roy 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviwer)) BLYTHE, Sean Darrell Striking Guilty Suspension 2

PERKINS, Timothy Roy 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, North Adelaide Vrs West Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviwer)) BANFIELD, Peter Charles Striking Guilty Suspension 1

FITZSIMMONS, Shane Levi 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviwer)) KRIEG, Peter Anthony Striking Guilty Suspension 3

GOSS, Glenn John 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviwer)) PARSONS, Michael Wayne Striking Guilty Suspension 1

BANFIELD, Peter Charles 5/10/1991, SANFL, 99, GF at Football Park, West Adelaide Vrs North Adelaide (Major, R. (Video Reviwer)) Striking Guilty Suspension 2

[spell_check]

This is what I've got from it:

Kim Klomp (North) - by Mick Abbott for striking Greg Mellor during the 1st quarter
Steven Sims (North) - by Laurie Argent and goal umpire Peter Symons for strking Matthew Simpson during the 2nd quarter - 12 matches
Mike Parsons (North) - by Argent for striking Glen Goss in the 2nd quarter.
Dean Schumann (West) - by Argent for attempting to strike a North player "at least 10 times to the head" - 2 matches
Sean Blythe (West) - by Argent for striking Steven Sims - 3 matches

Then after the head of the Umpires Board Roger Magor reviewed the tape, the following charges were laid:
Matthew Simpson (West) - striking Darel Hart in the 1st quarter - not guilty
Dean Schumann (West) - striking Steven Hamilton in the 3rd quarter - 3 matches
Kim Klomp (North) - unduly rough play towards Schumann in the 3rd quarter
Marc Marshall (North) - striking Sean Blythe in the 3rd quarter - not guilty
Tim Perkins (North) - attempting to strike Blythe in the 3rd quarter - 2 matches
Tim Perkins (North) - striking Peter Banfield in the last quarter - 1 match
Peter Banfield (West) - striking Perkins in the 4th quarter - 1 match
Shane Fitzsimmons (West) - striking Krieg in the 4th quarter - 3 matches

If anyone can help out on the verdicts of both Klomps' (that was postponed for 2 weeks as he was unavailable on a buisness trip, I think) and the Parsons and Goss reports - it wasn't reported in the Advertiser as far as I can see, that would be good.

[spell_check]

The only differences in info I can see is you have the Banfield suspension for two matches - I have one. And you have the Goss report and suspension while I don't.

[JK]

Dean Schumann (West) - by Argent for attempting to strike a North player "at least 10 times to the head" - 2 matches

How funny is that!!! "Yeah it was only 10 times, 2 weeks oughta cover it" lol

[Pseudo]

Dean Schumann (West) - by Argent for attempting to strike a North player "at least 10 times to the head" - 2 matches

How funny is that!!! "Yeah it was only 10 times, 2 weeks oughta cover it" lol

And attempted striking? So he tried it 10 times and missed each one?

[Adelaide Hawk]

Dean Schumann (West) - by Argent for attempting to strike a North player "at least 10 times to the head" - 2 matches

How funny is that!!! "Yeah it was only 10 times, 2 weeks oughta cover it" lol

And attempted striking? So he tried it 10 times and missed each one?

He must have gotten 2 matches for impersonating someone who could fight.

[Macca19]

haha. Reminds me of Lynch in the 04 AFL GF who threw about 30 punches at Wakelin, missed every one of them and got given 9 matches.

[redandblack]

Dean Schumann (West) - by Argent for attempting to strike a North player "at least 10 times to the head" - 2 matches

How funny is that!!! "Yeah it was only 10 times, 2 weeks oughta cover it" lol

And attempted striking? So he tried it 10 times and missed each one?

Sims was on my lap on the bench when Schumann belted him.

I was running water later and Sims couldn't see out of one eye, so Schumann didn't just attempt to strike him.