by Booney » Wed Aug 27, 2025 1:03 pm
by Booney » Wed Aug 27, 2025 1:06 pm
by wenchbarwer » Wed Aug 27, 2025 1:15 pm
by Jim05 » Wed Aug 27, 2025 1:20 pm
Ryan will be at the Saints.wenchbarwer wrote:I don't understand how they think TDK is worth that much coin. I understand Greg Swann wants tweaks to the ruck rules so that rucks actually jump for the ball, which plays into TDK's favour, but by that much???
Heard Ryan was linked to Essendon a month or so ago
by wenchbarwer » Wed Aug 27, 2025 1:26 pm
Jim05 wrote:Ryan will be at the Saints.wenchbarwer wrote:I don't understand how they think TDK is worth that much coin. I understand Greg Swann wants tweaks to the ruck rules so that rucks actually jump for the ball, which plays into TDK's favour, but by that much???
Heard Ryan was linked to Essendon a month or so ago
Definitely won’t be at Essendon
by Brodlach » Wed Aug 27, 2025 1:37 pm
Brodlach wrote:Rory Laird might end up the best IMO, he is an absolute jet. He has been in great form at the Bloods
by whufc » Wed Aug 27, 2025 1:53 pm
Brodlach wrote:Do these players understand that St Kilda have not won a premiership since 1966?
Probably before their parents were born
by amber_fluid » Wed Aug 27, 2025 2:00 pm
Brodlach wrote:Do these players understand that St Kilda have not won a premiership since 1966?
Probably before their parents were born
by Spargo » Wed Aug 27, 2025 2:02 pm
by Jim05 » Wed Aug 27, 2025 2:04 pm
Not sure how they fit under the cap.Spargo wrote:Mate in Melbourne who’s pretty well connected told me the Saints have got another “name player” on their radar. Wouldn’t tell me who, as said player hasn’t told his current club he’s looking elsewhere yet…
by amber_fluid » Wed Aug 27, 2025 2:04 pm
Spargo wrote:Mate in Melbourne who’s pretty well connected told me the Saints have got another “name player” on their radar. Wouldn’t tell me who, as said player hasn’t told his current club he’s looking elsewhere yet…
by gadj1976 » Wed Aug 27, 2025 2:19 pm
wenchbarwer wrote:I don't understand how they think TDK is worth that much coin. I understand Greg Swann wants tweaks to the ruck rules so that rucks actually jump for the ball, which plays into TDK's favour, but by that much???
Heard Ryan was linked to Essendon a month or so ago
by wenchbarwer » Wed Aug 27, 2025 2:22 pm
gadj1976 wrote:wenchbarwer wrote:I don't understand how they think TDK is worth that much coin. I understand Greg Swann wants tweaks to the ruck rules so that rucks actually jump for the ball, which plays into TDK's favour, but by that much???
Heard Ryan was linked to Essendon a month or so ago
My son and I are both Carlton supporters. We were both happy to let him go. No ruckman is worth that much UNLESS they have the ability to go forward and kick 30 goals a season. Currently there wouldn't be one of those in the league. If there was, then I'd be happy to pay for that but he's just not doing it. So yes, you're getting a very good mobile tall, but he's not as damaging as he might become just yet. Noting that the best years of a ruck are later than others.
I think if we paid him that much, we're limited in who we can attract or retain. Best of luck to him, he's set himself up for life!
by amber_fluid » Wed Aug 27, 2025 2:27 pm
wenchbarwer wrote:gadj1976 wrote:wenchbarwer wrote:I don't understand how they think TDK is worth that much coin. I understand Greg Swann wants tweaks to the ruck rules so that rucks actually jump for the ball, which plays into TDK's favour, but by that much???
Heard Ryan was linked to Essendon a month or so ago
My son and I are both Carlton supporters. We were both happy to let him go. No ruckman is worth that much UNLESS they have the ability to go forward and kick 30 goals a season. Currently there wouldn't be one of those in the league. If there was, then I'd be happy to pay for that but he's just not doing it. So yes, you're getting a very good mobile tall, but he's not as damaging as he might become just yet. Noting that the best years of a ruck are later than others.
I think if we paid him that much, we're limited in who we can attract or retain. Best of luck to him, he's set himself up for life!
Great call, you'd be wanting the modern version of Simon Madden for $1.7M a year!
by Booney » Wed Aug 27, 2025 2:28 pm
by wenchbarwer » Wed Aug 27, 2025 2:49 pm
amber_fluid wrote:wenchbarwer wrote:gadj1976 wrote:wenchbarwer wrote:I don't understand how they think TDK is worth that much coin. I understand Greg Swann wants tweaks to the ruck rules so that rucks actually jump for the ball, which plays into TDK's favour, but by that much???
Heard Ryan was linked to Essendon a month or so ago
My son and I are both Carlton supporters. We were both happy to let him go. No ruckman is worth that much UNLESS they have the ability to go forward and kick 30 goals a season. Currently there wouldn't be one of those in the league. If there was, then I'd be happy to pay for that but he's just not doing it. So yes, you're getting a very good mobile tall, but he's not as damaging as he might become just yet. Noting that the best years of a ruck are later than others.
I think if we paid him that much, we're limited in who we can attract or retain. Best of luck to him, he's set himself up for life!
Great call, you'd be wanting the modern version of Simon Madden for $1.7M a year!
I’d take Paul Salmon over Madden but I get what you mean
by amber_fluid » Wed Aug 27, 2025 2:55 pm
wenchbarwer wrote:amber_fluid wrote:wenchbarwer wrote:gadj1976 wrote:
My son and I are both Carlton supporters. We were both happy to let him go. No ruckman is worth that much UNLESS they have the ability to go forward and kick 30 goals a season. Currently there wouldn't be one of those in the league. If there was, then I'd be happy to pay for that but he's just not doing it. So yes, you're getting a very good mobile tall, but he's not as damaging as he might become just yet. Noting that the best years of a ruck are later than others.
I think if we paid him that much, we're limited in who we can attract or retain. Best of luck to him, he's set himself up for life!
Great call, you'd be wanting the modern version of Simon Madden for $1.7M a year!
I’d take Paul Salmon over Madden but I get what you mean
Madden kicked 15 more goals than Salmon did in his career, admittedly from 54 more games.
Fish was a FF who chopped out in the ruck for nearly all of his time at Essendon, only a fulltime ruck at Hawthorn, while Madden rucked and then rested forward.
Madden's ruckwork was also exquisite, Fish very, very good, but not at Madden's level.
by Lightning McQueen » Wed Aug 27, 2025 2:56 pm
Jim05 wrote:Ryan will be at the Saints.wenchbarwer wrote:I don't understand how they think TDK is worth that much coin. I understand Greg Swann wants tweaks to the ruck rules so that rucks actually jump for the ball, which plays into TDK's favour, but by that much???
Heard Ryan was linked to Essendon a month or so ago
Definitely won’t be at Essendon
by wenchbarwer » Wed Aug 27, 2025 3:02 pm
amber_fluid wrote:
Yeah right
I would have bet my house on Salmon kicking more goals
amber_fluid wrote:We had the better Madden anyway
by Jim05 » Wed Aug 27, 2025 3:17 pm
Flanders isn’t a “name player”Spargo wrote:Mate in Melbourne who’s pretty well connected told me the Saints have got another “name player” on their radar. Wouldn’t tell me who, as said player hasn’t told his current club he’s looking elsewhere yet…
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |