Page 1 of 5
All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 3:58 pmby Booney
So, who have you got from your side in the AA?
For mine, Ryder is the stand out with Wingard mounting a case for inclusion over the last 6 to 8 weeks.
So.....?
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:04 pmby woodublieve12
Franklin & Kennedy shoe ins I reckon
By seasons end, Parker, Rampe, Grundy and Zac Jones may be in the discussion.
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:05 pmby mots02
Booney wrote:So, who have you got from your side in the AA?
For mine, Ryder is the stand out with Wingard mounting a case for inclusion over the last 6 to 8 weeks.
So.....?
Can anyone provide some stats to back up Ryders claim for AA?
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:06 pmby Jim05
Hurley and Zerrett locks and reckon Daniher close to a certainty
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:07 pmby MW
Laird and Betts are locks IMO
Lynch should but tough competition in his role to hold out true midfielders who they need to find spots for.
Talia possibly, but will likely miss with Rance and Hurley playing better.
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:15 pmby Booney
Betts v R.Gray for the small forward and in reality it should come down to goals kicked at seasons end.
Betts 41 v Gray 40 at the moment.
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:21 pmby morell
Betts IMO. His goal assists are a class above.
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:30 pmby Booney
morell wrote:Betts IMO. His goal assists are a class above.
Gray 26
Betts 18
*insert some chart here*
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:36 pmby Jim05
Booney wrote:Betts v R.Gray for the small forward and in reality it should come down to goals kicked at seasons end.
Betts 41 v Gray 40 at the moment.
4 way race for the small forward role between Betts, Gray, Greene and Walters IMO.
May also make a bench spot available for 1 of them
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:37 pmby bertiebeatle
Jim05 wrote:Booney wrote:Betts v R.Gray for the small forward and in reality it should come down to goals kicked at seasons end.
Betts 41 v Gray 40 at the moment.
4 way race for the small forward role between Betts, Gray, Greene and Walters IMO.
May also make a bench spot available for 1 of them
Greene will miss out i reckon in the end. Missed too many weeks. 3 with suspension & 2 with the hammy - is that correct?
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:39 pmby Booney
Jim05 wrote:Booney wrote:Betts v R.Gray for the small forward and in reality it should come down to goals kicked at seasons end.
Betts 41 v Gray 40 at the moment.
4 way race for the small forward role between Betts, Gray, Greene and Walters IMO.
May also make a bench spot available for 1 of them
Not Greene this year IMO, well down on goals and goal assists to Betts and Gray.
Green 32 goals 14 assists.
Gray 40 / 26
Betts 41 / 18
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:41 pmby Wedgie
Booney wrote:Jim05 wrote:Booney wrote:Betts v R.Gray for the small forward and in reality it should come down to goals kicked at seasons end.
Betts 41 v Gray 40 at the moment.
4 way race for the small forward role between Betts, Gray, Greene and Walters IMO.
May also make a bench spot available for 1 of them
Not Greene this year IMO, well down on goals and goal assists to Betts and Gray.
Green 32 goals 14 assists.
Gray 40 / 26
Betts 41 / 18
Averages would be quite close taking into account games missed, Menzel might not be far behind them too.
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:42 pmby Booney
MW wrote:Laird and Betts are locks IMO
Lynch should but tough competition in his role to hold out true midfielders who they need to find spots for.
Talia possibly, but will likely miss with Rance and Hurley playing better.
I don't think Talia is close this year at all. Rance, Hurley, Grundy, McGovern ( WC ) and McDonald ( Melb ) are all ahead of him IMO.
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:42 pmby Booney
Wedgie wrote:Booney wrote:Jim05 wrote:Booney wrote:Betts v R.Gray for the small forward and in reality it should come down to goals kicked at seasons end.
Betts 41 v Gray 40 at the moment.
4 way race for the small forward role between Betts, Gray, Greene and Walters IMO.
May also make a bench spot available for 1 of them
Not Greene this year IMO, well down on goals and goal assists to Betts and Gray.
Green 32 goals 14 assists.
Gray 40 / 26
Betts 41 / 18
Averages would be quite close taking into account games missed, Menzel might not be far behind them too.
Agreed, but I'm pretty sure they go on output across the year and not averages.
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:45 pmby mighty_tiger_79
Tuohy gets a gig across halfback
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 4:46 pmby Jim05
Booney wrote:Wedgie wrote:Booney wrote:Jim05 wrote:[quote="Booney"]Betts v R.Gray for the small forward and in reality it should come down to goals kicked at seasons end.
Betts 41 v Gray 40 at the moment.
4 way race for the small forward role between Betts, Gray, Greene and Walters IMO.
May also make a bench spot available for 1 of them
Not Greene this year IMO, well down on goals and goal assists to Betts and Gray.
Green 32 goals 14 assists.
Gray 40 / 26
Betts 41 / 18
Averages would be quite close taking into account games missed, Menzel might not be far behind them too.
Agreed, but I'm pretty sure they go on output across the year and not averages.[/quote]
They go on consistency too not just stats.
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 5:02 pmby bennymacca
mighty_tiger_79 wrote:Tuohy gets a gig across halfback
yeo docherty roberton simpson lloyd laird would all give him a run for his money
From the crows I think Betts is the only lock.
Lynch and Tex should be in the conversation now
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 5:06 pmby Corona Man
bennymacca wrote:mighty_tiger_79 wrote:Tuohy gets a gig across halfback
yeo docherty roberton simpson lloyd laird would all give him a run for his money
From the crows I think Betts is the only lock.
Lynch and Tex should be in the conversation now
Subdued from you Benny I was expecting you to nominate 6 at least. Jokes! Rory surely in the mix?
Mitchell the only Hawk in the mix, and an outside chance at best.
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 5:11 pmby Booney
Corona Man wrote:bennymacca wrote:mighty_tiger_79 wrote:Tuohy gets a gig across halfback
yeo docherty roberton simpson lloyd laird would all give him a run for his money
From the crows I think Betts is the only lock.
Lynch and Tex should be in the conversation now
Subdued from you Benny I was expecting you to nominate 6 at least. Jokes! Rory surely in the mix?
Mitchell the only Hawk in the mix, and an outside chance at best.
Sloane no chance IMO, been shut out of too many games.
Mitchell the most touches, must be in the mix.
Re: All Australian Team 2017 discussion
Posted:
Wed Jul 19, 2017 5:13 pmby MatteeG
Corona Man wrote:Mitchell the only Hawk in the mix, and an outside chance at best.
Have to agree, Big Boy may get close to the initial 40 but certainly wont get to the 22.