SA Footy

What constitute an A Grader?

Here is my list:
ADEL: Dangerfield, Thompson, Jacobs, Sloane
BRIS: D.Beams, Rockliff
CARL: Murphy, Simpson
COLL: Pendlebury, Swan, Sidebottom
ESS: Heppell, Watson, Stanton, Goddard
FREO: Fyfe, Mundy, Neale, Barlow, Sandilands, Johnson
GEEL: Bartel, Selwood, Enright, Taylor
GC: Ablett, Rischitelli, Prestia
GWS: Ward, Mumford, Treloar, H.Shaw, Sheil, Greene
HAW: Lewis, Hodge, Mitchell, Roughead, Gibson, Lake, Burgoyne
MELB: Jones, Vince
NM: Goldstein, Swallow, Ziebell, Dal Santo
PORT: Gray, Boak, Wingard, Wines
RICH: Ellis, Martin, Rance, Cotchin, Delidio
ST.K: Steven, Montagna, Armitage, Riewoldt
SYD: Hannebery, Kennedy, Parker, Jack, McVeigh, Richards, Franklin
WCE: Gaff, Priddis, Kennedy, Naitanui
WB: Boyd, Macrae, Picken

There's a few borderline players listed there as well as a few that could be in there but aren't. I was looking at consistent performers over a period of 12 months or longer as my criteria.

Quick glance -

GWS missing Cameron

Not sure about Stanton, Lake, Montagna and Richards.

Good effort though mate, I'm in the middle of mine so I'll post it later.

Booney wrote:Quick glance -

GWS missing Cameron

Not sure about Stanton, Lake, Montagna and Richards.

Good effort though mate, I'm in the middle of mine so I'll post it later.

I can see your point with Cameron, managed to score goals when GWS were poo.
Montagna having a stellar season and has carried the midfield torch for the Saints when Hayes was absent, Stanton's racked up 25+ possessions on a regular basis for as long as I can remember, Lake is the best in the business at his craft and has been for a long time, Teddy was a bit of a token addition as I think he's a great nullifying full back and I lacked key defenders, I seem to be heavily grading on-ballers.

Stanton no way, Goddard once was but not any more. I would put Hurley and Hooker above those two

Jim05 wrote:Stanton no way, Goddard once was but not any more. I would put Hurley and Hooker above those two

I was tempted to put Hurley in, Hooker would only be a solid B for mine, watching him kick for goal was painful on the weekend. I have him in my Supercoach team so I tend to pay attention to his game, he's a potential A grader though.

Lightning McQueen wrote:What constitute an A Grader?

Here is my list:
ADEL: Dangerfield, Thompson, Jacobs, Sloane
BRIS: D.Beams, Rockliff
CARL: Murphy, Simpson
COLL: Pendlebury, Swan, Sidebottom
ESS: Heppell, Watson, Stanton, Goddard
FREO: Fyfe, Mundy, Neale, Barlow, Sandilands, Johnson
GEEL: Bartel, Selwood, Enright, Taylor
GC: Ablett, Rischitelli, Prestia
GWS: Ward, Mumford, Treloar, H.Shaw, Sheil, Greene
HAW: Lewis, Hodge, Mitchell, Roughead, Gibson, Lake, Burgoyne
MELB: Jones, Vince
NM: Goldstein, Swallow, Ziebell, Dal Santo
PORT: Gray, Boak, Wingard, Wines
RICH: Ellis, Martin, Rance, Cotchin, Delidio
ST.K: Steven, Montagna, Armitage, Riewoldt
SYD: Hannebery, Kennedy, Parker, Jack, McVeigh, Richards, Franklin
WCE: Gaff, Priddis, Kennedy, Naitanui
WB: Boyd, Macrae, Picken

There's a few borderline players listed there as well as a few that could be in there but aren't. I was looking at consistent performers over a period of 12 months or longer as my criteria.

Not bad LM, In bold are not A graders for mine.

Jaeger O'Meara? He's a gun.

I'm not sure on Rance anymore, think he's dropped away, I would think Jack Reiwoldt would be a consideration?

Zartan wrote:Jaeger O'Meara? He's a gun.

I'm not sure on Rance anymore, think he's dropped away, I would think Jack Reiwoldt would be a consideration?

Booney wrote:

Zartan wrote:Jaeger O'Meara? He's a gun.

I'm not sure on Rance anymore, think he's dropped away, I would think Jack Reiwoldt would be a consideration?

Booney wrote:

Zartan wrote:Jaeger O'Meara? He's a gun.

I'm not sure on Rance anymore, think he's dropped away, I would think Jack Reiwoldt would be a consideration?

Im the opposite. I wasnt sure about Rance but now convinced he's a gun.

Ron Burgundy wrote:

Booney wrote:

Zartan wrote:Jaeger O'Meara? He's a gun.

I'm not sure on Rance anymore, think he's dropped away, I would think Jack Reiwoldt would be a consideration?

Im the opposite. I wasnt sure about Rance but now convinced he's a gun.

Absolute, 20 disposals at half time from a CHB is insane, very high effectiveness too, no one reads the play like he does.

carey wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:What constitute an A Grader?

Here is my list:
ADEL: Dangerfield, Thompson, Jacobs, Sloane
BRIS: D.Beams, Rockliff
CARL: Murphy, Simpson
COLL: Pendlebury, Swan, Sidebottom
ESS: Heppell, Watson, Stanton, Goddard
FREO: Fyfe, Mundy, Neale, Barlow, Sandilands, Johnson
GEEL: Bartel, Selwood, Enright, Taylor
GC: Ablett, Rischitelli, Prestia
GWS: Ward, Mumford, Treloar, H.Shaw, Sheil, Greene
HAW: Lewis, Hodge, Mitchell, Roughead, Gibson, Lake, Burgoyne
MELB: Jones, Vince
NM: Goldstein, Swallow, Ziebell, Dal Santo
PORT: Gray, Boak, Wingard, Wines
RICH: Ellis, Martin, Rance, Cotchin, Delidio
ST.K: Steven, Montagna, Armitage, Riewoldt
SYD: Hannebery, Kennedy, Parker, Jack, McVeigh, Richards, Franklin
WCE: Gaff, Priddis, Kennedy, Naitanui
WB: Boyd, Macrae, Picken

There's a few borderline players listed there as well as a few that could be in there but aren't. I was looking at consistent performers over a period of 12 months or longer as my criteria.

Not bad LM, In bold are not A graders for mine.

I think Ellis is a jet, averages 27 disposals per game, Heath Shaw is the best running defender going around currently and Montagna is in career best form, the rest I could have left out.

carey wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:What constitute an A Grader?

Here is my list:
ADEL: Dangerfield, Thompson, Jacobs, Sloane
BRIS: D.Beams, Rockliff
CARL: Murphy, Simpson
COLL: Pendlebury, Swan, Sidebottom
ESS: Heppell, Watson, Stanton, Goddard
FREO: Fyfe, Mundy, Neale, Barlow, Sandilands, Johnson
GEEL: Bartel, Selwood, Enright, Taylor
GC: Ablett, Rischitelli, Prestia
GWS: Ward, Mumford, Treloar, H.Shaw, Sheil, Greene
HAW: Lewis, Hodge, Mitchell, Roughead, Gibson, Lake, Burgoyne
MELB: Jones, Vince
NM: Goldstein, Swallow, Ziebell, Dal Santo
PORT: Gray, Boak, Wingard, Wines
RICH: Ellis, Martin, Rance, Cotchin, Delidio
ST.K: Steven, Montagna, Armitage, Riewoldt
SYD: Hannebery, Kennedy, Parker, Jack, McVeigh, Richards, Franklin
WCE: Gaff, Priddis, Kennedy, Naitanui
WB: Boyd, Macrae, Picken

There's a few borderline players listed there as well as a few that could be in there but aren't. I was looking at consistent performers over a period of 12 months or longer as my criteria.

Not bad LM, In bold are not A graders for mine.

So Johnson of Freo who hasn't played for weeks is an A Grader and Enright, who is coming back to some really good form in recent weeks is not? He's not as good as he once was but he's still an A Grader for me. LM's list is an excellent effort. I reckon Stanton stands out he is bog average.

regards,

REB

Good list LM

From that list my A grade side would be:

Shaw Taylor Enright
Hodge Rance Burgoyne
Fyfe Pendles Gaff
Reiwoldt Franklin Gray
Wingard Kennedy Roughhead
Ruck: Goldstien, GAJ, Mitchell
Bench: NicNat Selwood Dangerfield

Tricky, tried to add players to where they play (or played at stages) added Gaff for his run and carry and plays as a genuine HBF (i think). The players on the bench you could have 10 different players make those 3 spots

I'd separate that list to move some into another category for Elite (or A+) .. Ablett, Fyfe, Pendles, Rought etc.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Ron Burgundy wrote:

Booney wrote:

Zartan wrote:Jaeger O'Meara? He's a gun.

I'm not sure on Rance anymore, think he's dropped away, I would think Jack Reiwoldt would be a consideration?

Im the opposite. I wasnt sure about Rance but now convinced he's a gun.

Absolute, 20 disposals at half time from a CHB is insane, very high effectiveness too, no one reads the play like he does.

McGovern does.

helicopterking wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:Absolute, 20 disposals at half time from a CHB is insane, very high effectiveness too, no one reads the play like he does.

McGovern does.

I'd expect that from an Eagles supporter, obviously take more notice of him than I, I do rate McGovern very highly though and is definitely up there.

Footy Smart wrote:Good list LM

From that list my A grade side would be:

Shaw Taylor Enright
Hodge Rance Burgoyne
Fyfe Pendles Gaff
Reiwoldt Franklin Gray
Wingard Kennedy Roughhead
Ruck: Goldstien, GAJ, Mitchell
Bench: NicNat Selwood Dangerfield

Tricky, tried to add players to where they play (or played at stages) added Gaff for his run and carry and plays as a genuine HBF (i think). The players on the bench you could have 10 different players make those 3 spots

Who the hell lists teams from backs to forwards?

A B+ list would be pretty cool too, then we could reflect on it in 12 months time and see how many graduated.

Zartan wrote:

Footy Smart wrote:Good list LM

From that list my A grade side would be:

Shaw Taylor Enright
Hodge Rance Burgoyne
Fyfe Pendles Gaff
Reiwoldt Franklin Gray
Wingard Kennedy Roughhead
Ruck: Goldstien, GAJ, Mitchell
Bench: NicNat Selwood Dangerfield

Tricky, tried to add players to where they play (or played at stages) added Gaff for his run and carry and plays as a genuine HBF (i think). The players on the bench you could have 10 different players make those 3 spots

Who the hell lists teams from backs to forwards?

Someone who played on a half back flank