SA Footy

Booney wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:

Booney wrote:Talia holds down the key post, Hartigan looks promising as a FB on the gorilla and Shaw looks, like Shoenmakers a good third option.

I'd be after Shoenmakers more than Giles if I were Adelaide.

Why, they've got no need for Giles, they need another defender.

They must have backup for Jacobs .. Little chance he'll get through the year again as unscathed as this one. No reason why they couldn't go after both though, wouldn't think either would really cost them a heap in player/pick.

i can just see shoenmakers making 10 turnovers in a showdown and us looking like idiots

Coach Bombay wrote:i can just see shoenmakers making 10 turnovers in a showdown and us looking like idiots

Yeah, that would only happen if Schoenmakers came over

Coach Bombay wrote:i can just see shoenmakers making 10 turnovers in a showdown and us looking like idiots

All the more reason to sign him

Coach Bombay wrote:i can just see shoenmakers making 10 turnovers in a showdown and us looking like idiots

To be honest, the bloke can kick a ball better than a fair chunk of the Adelaide midfield.

He does get found out on the gorillas and someone with genuine leg speed, but turnovers aren't his achilles heel.

MatteeG wrote:

Coach Bombay wrote:i can just see shoenmakers making 10 turnovers in a showdown and us looking like idiots

To be honest, the bloke can kick a ball better than a fair chunk of the Adelaide midfield.

He does get found out on the gorillas and someone with genuine leg speed, but turnovers aren't his achilles heel.

I thought being a very average footaller allround was...

Gee, when Spangher is getting a gig before you. i think it's time to move on

MatteeG wrote:

Coach Bombay wrote:i can just see shoenmakers making 10 turnovers in a showdown and us looking like idiots

To be honest, the bloke can kick a ball better than a fair chunk of the Adelaide midfield.

He does get found out on the gorillas and someone with genuine leg speed, but turnovers aren't his achilles heel.

talia would take the best defender every week too. even with rutten in the side talia had been taking the biggest and best, even if they could have been more suited for truck.

at the moment we would be completely screwed if talia or jacobs went down, so this is the areas we need to get someone, even more than a pacy mid

woodublieve12 wrote:

MatteeG wrote:

Coach Bombay wrote:i can just see shoenmakers making 10 turnovers in a showdown and us looking like idiots

To be honest, the bloke can kick a ball better than a fair chunk of the Adelaide midfield.

He does get found out on the gorillas and someone with genuine leg speed, but turnovers aren't his achilles heel.

I thought being a very average footaller allround was...

Gee, when Spangher is getting a gig before you. i think it's time to move on

Going on that notion WUB, that Tom Mitchell must be a spud when he cant get a game ahead of that GF midfield....

Are the Crows even trying to do a trade?

MatteeG wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:

MatteeG wrote:

Coach Bombay wrote:i can just see shoenmakers making 10 turnovers in a showdown and us looking like idiots

To be honest, the bloke can kick a ball better than a fair chunk of the Adelaide midfield.

He does get found out on the gorillas and someone with genuine leg speed, but turnovers aren't his achilles heel.

I thought being a very average footaller allround was...

Gee, when Spangher is getting a gig before you. i think it's time to move on

Going on that notion WUB, that Tom Mitchell must be a spud when he cant get a game ahead of that GF midfield....

well played sir.... except kennedy he was good. Luke Parker went all Ballintyne on the big stage

spangher is still rubbish though

Dutchy wrote:Are the Crows even trying to do a trade?

nope

They have their man lol
seriously though, they way they have been with the CEO and Head Coach, I dare say there might be stuff going on we just don't know about

MW wrote:They have their man lol
seriously though, they way they have been with the CEO and Head Coach, I dare say there might be stuff going on we just don't know about

seemingly you get what you deserve

MatteeG wrote:

Coach Bombay wrote:i can just see shoenmakers making 10 turnovers in a showdown and us looking like idiots

To be honest, the bloke can kick a ball better than a fair chunk of the Adelaide midfield.

He does get found out on the gorillas and someone with genuine leg speed, but turnovers aren't his achilles heel.

Totally agree with the above Mattee. There are far worse currently on AFL lists the Schoey (Z.Dawson comes to mind). To back Talia up and then dependent on matchups play Hartigan at points of the year is not the worst thing to happen. Schoey is only 23 and from SA, and I think he needs to be backed in to do a job, gain some confidence and Walsh could be the man to do it.

Dutchy wrote:Are the Crows even trying to do a trade?

Nope, why would they, they have a top 4 side already.

To be honest, the bloke can kick a ball better than a fair chunk of the Adelaide midfield.

He does get found out on the gorillas and someone with genuine leg speed, but turnovers aren't his achilles heel.[/quote]
I thought being a very average footaller allround was...

Gee, when Spangher is getting a gig before you. i think it's time to move on[/quote]

Going on that notion WUB, that Tom Mitchell must be a spud when he cant get a game ahead of that GF midfield.... [/quote]
well played sir.... except kennedy he was good. Luke Parker went all Ballintyne on the big stage

spangher is still rubbish though[/quote]

Stitched up that billion dollar forward line when it mattered. and thats Matt Spangher, premiership player, to you wubby.
Swans could do with another tall defender, Richards on the way out and Grundy already there.
Why didnt you guys try and get Patfull? Maybe we could ship Schoey off to our Sydney franchise

Spanger is still rubbish... Those players you mentioned are premiership players to ya goose

woodublieve12 wrote:Spanger is still rubbish... Those players you mentioned are premiership players to ya goose

Yeah they are but they are close to the end of their careers and u have no back up, why wouldnt you trade in some key defenders?
If you lost one of them you could kiss goodbye to any chance of a premiership coming during the Lance era.

daysofourlives wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Spanger is still rubbish... Those players you mentioned are premiership players to ya goose

Yeah they are but they are close to the end of their careers and u have no back up, why wouldnt you trade in some key defenders?
If you lost one of them you could kiss goodbye to any chance of a premiership coming during the Lance era.

How about you stop worrying bout the swans. We are finished according to you.

Can you guys piss off out of the crows thread? It's getting a little tired