SA Footy

Just having an argument with a mate over who is the better player Taylor Walker or Jaryd Roughead.

I dont think my bias is clouding my judgement, Roughead by a fair way for me

Roughead.

Versatility goes along way with the talls as far as having an effect in games. Tex is more important to the crows lineup than what roughy is to the hawks imo.

Tex would have been the premier forward in the competition had he been fit all year. Good forwards are infinitely more valuable than another other type of player on the ground IMHO.

Roughead has a few extra seasons under his belt than Tex. Will be a better comparison in 2 years. Roughy has come back from that achilles tear and playing his best football, hopefully for adelaide Tex can do the same.

At this point in time, Roughead. More consistant than Tex.

I'm a crows fan and easily choose Roughy

Roughead could win a brownlow, Tex couldnt

roughead easily

Hawthorn suck balls but Roughead the better player. He's had two good years compared to Tex's one.

regards,

REB

Browny25 wrote:Roughead could win a brownlow

And I could have a threesome with Sandra Sully and Jennifer Aniston.

I'd prefer Megan Gale and Jennifer Hawkins ...

Browny25 wrote:I'm a crows fan and easily choose Roughy

Roughead could win a brownlow, Tex couldnt

No way would he win a brownlow

Spargo wrote:

Browny25 wrote:Roughead could win a brownlow

And I could have a threesome with Sandra Sully and Jennifer Aniston.

That's who you would pick?

The Sleeping Giant wrote:

Spargo wrote:

Browny25 wrote:Roughead could win a brownlow

And I could have a threesome with Sandra Sully and Jennifer Aniston.

That's who you would pick?

It's late.

Spargo wrote:

The Sleeping Giant wrote:

Spargo wrote:

Browny25 wrote:Roughead could win a brownlow

And I could have a threesome with Sandra Sully and Jennifer Aniston.

That's who you would pick?

It's late.

Still no excuse

Thats quite funny...

Roughy it is for me, runs on the board so to speak.
Tex is an interesting one, id like to see his output with another key forward taking the other key defender, and also some better quality inside 50 delivery, not this rubbish 30m long 30m high rubbish Thompson and co has been giving them for years.

Roughy is a proven gun...
Tex hasn't proven anything.

Can't believe Tex got a vote.
Some Dumb Crows supporters out there.

NO-MERCY wrote:Can't believe Tex got a vote.
Some Dumb Crows supporters out there.

That exactly what started the argument.
Was only ever going to be the most one-eyed Crow supporter that would think Tex is better

daysofourlives wrote:

NO-MERCY wrote:Can't believe Tex got a vote.
Some Dumb Crows supporters out there.

That exactly what started the argument.
Was only ever going to be the most one-eyed Crow supporter that would think Tex is better

Roughy is a gun, if I was GWS id be chasing him before Buddy

Jim05 wrote:

daysofourlives wrote:

NO-MERCY wrote:Can't believe Tex got a vote.
Some Dumb Crows supporters out there.

That exactly what started the argument.
Was only ever going to be the most one-eyed Crow supporter that would think Tex is better

Roughy is a gun, if I was GWS id be chasing him before Buddy

Yep me too, but Roughy doesnt have what they need, they need a big profile player, if they miss out on buddy who would be next to target in terms of marketability. I dont think there is anyone that would get the publicity they need unless they poached a Swans player

There's ur answer