Page 1 of 13
AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Thu Apr 11, 2013 11:07 pm
by GWW
Should be some interesting games this week.
ROUND 3Friday, April 12Frem v Ess, Patersons, 8.40pm
Saturday, April 13NM v Syd, Blundstone, 1.45pm
Melb v WC, MCG, 2.10pm
GWS v StK, Manuka, 4.40pm
Geel v Carl, Etihad, 7.40pm
GC v BL, Metricon, 7.40pm
Sunday, April 14Rich v WB, Etihad, 1.10pm
Coll v Haw, MCG, 3.15pm
PA v Adel, AAMI, 4.40pm
http://livescores.ninemsn.com.au/afl/I'll select Fremantle; North Melbourne; West Coast; GWS; Geelong; Gold Coast; Richmond; Collingwood; Adelaide.
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 8:35 am
by Rik E Boy
Fremantle - chalk and cheese between them and Melbourne. Essendon to face pressure.
North - Sydney will be in shock at not playing in NSW and playing a real team for a change.
West Coast - Melbourne a silly chance but LeCras and Kerr ins add additional class.
St Kilda - Only just as they are copping injuries. GWS at the 'staying in the game longer' stage only.
Geelong - By a couple of goals despite Blues having a ruck edge.
Brisbane - Last chance Lions! Brisbane inspite of the Suns three straight at Metricon.
Richmond - Bulldogs a chance but Richmond are up and about
Hawthorn - Match up well with Pies whose defence has been de-stabilised without Maxwell.
Adelaide - Always tough to pick these but I reckon Cows by 7 with a bit more experience around the ground.
regards,
REB
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 9:49 am
by woodublieve12
Rik E Boy wrote:Fremantle - chalk and cheese between them and Melbourne. Essendon to face pressure.
North - Sydney will be in shock at not playing in NSW and playing a real team for a change.
West Coast - Melbourne a silly chance but LeCras and Kerr ins add additional class.
St Kilda - Only just as they are copping injuries. GWS at the 'staying in the game longer' stage only.
Geelong - By a couple of goals despite Blues having a ruck edge.
Brisbane - Last chance Lions! Brisbane inspite of the Suns three straight at Metricon.
Richmond - Bulldogs a chance but Richmond are up and about
Hawthorn - Match up well with Pies whose defence has been stabilised without Maxwell.
Adelaide - Always tough to pick these but I reckon Cows by 7 with a bit more experience around the ground.
regards,
REB
edited for accuracy

Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 12:05 pm
by CoverKing
Geelong to dominate the ruck v Carlton. Kreuzers performance last week against the pies was severely over rated. Lunch was terrific
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 12:38 pm
by Rik E Boy
CoverKing wrote:Geelong to dominate the ruck v Carlton. Kreuzers performance last week against the pies was severely over rated. Lunch was terrific
Geelong don't dominate anyone in the ruck. Our midfield thrives on roving the other teams taps. Blicavs is quite an athlete but isn't much of a presence in the ruck and West is only servicable at best despite a very solid finals series in 2011.
regards,
REB
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 1:22 pm
by CoverKing
Rik E Boy wrote:CoverKing wrote:Geelong to dominate the ruck v Carlton. Kreuzers performance last week against the pies was severely over rated. Lunch was terrific
Geelong don't dominate anyone in the ruck. Our midfield thrives on roving the other teams taps. Blicavs is quite an athlete but isn't much of a presence in the ruck and West is only servicable at best despite a very solid finals series in 2011.
regards,
REB
I know Geelong don't dominate anyone. I just think Kreuzers rucking is overrated. Better forward IMO
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 2:01 pm
by Zorro
CoverKing wrote:Geelong to dominate the ruck v Carlton. Kreuzers performance last week against the pies was severely over rated. Lunch was terrific
So was mine, I had sushi.
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 2:31 pm
by stan
Zorro wrote:CoverKing wrote:Geelong to dominate the ruck v Carlton. Kreuzers performance last week against the pies was severely over rated. Lunch was terrific
So was mine, I had sushi.
Had a bloody sandwich pretty ordinary really.
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 2:49 pm
by woodublieve12
woodublieve12 wrote:Rik E Boy wrote:Fremantle - chalk and cheese between them and Melbourne. Essendon to face pressure.
North - Sydney will be in shock at not playing in NSW and playing a real team for a change.
West Coast - Melbourne a silly chance but LeCras and Kerr ins add additional class.
St Kilda - Only just as they are copping injuries. GWS at the 'staying in the game longer' stage only.
Geelong - By a couple of goals despite Blues having a ruck edge.
Brisbane - Last chance Lions! Brisbane inspite of the Suns three straight at Metricon.
Richmond - Bulldogs a chance but Richmond are up and about
Hawthorn - Match up well with Pies whose defence has been stabilised without Maxwell.
Adelaide - Always tough to pick these but I reckon Cows by 7 with a bit more experience around the ground.
regards,
REB
edited for accuracy

seriously though, i am baffled how you rate this bloke
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 3:28 pm
by valleys07
stan wrote:Zorro wrote:CoverKing wrote:Geelong to dominate the ruck v Carlton. Kreuzers performance last week against the pies was severely over rated. Lunch was terrific
So was mine, I had sushi.
Had a bloody sandwich pretty ordinary really.
I was waiting for the "dad" responses

Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 3:39 pm
by CoverKing
valleys07 wrote:stan wrote:Zorro wrote:CoverKing wrote:Geelong to dominate the ruck v Carlton. Kreuzers performance last week against the pies was severely over rated. Lunch was terrific
So was mine, I had sushi.
Had a bloody sandwich pretty ordinary really.
I was waiting for the "dad" responses

Yeah good old iPhone predictive text. Love it
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 3:56 pm
by kickinit
Frem v Ess, Fremantle think Essendon might be unsettle
NM v Syd, Tough one have to go with Sydney
Melb v WC, West coast
GWS v StK, GWS saw against port very quick and fit which i think will get them over the line
Geel v Carl, Geelong too much skill for me
GC v BL, Brisbane think this will be the week they turn it around
Rich v WB, Richmond
Coll v Haw, Tough one to pick but I'm going to go with collingwood
PA v Adel, showdown have always gone either way so i'm going out on a limb and saying a tie
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 4:48 pm
by Rik E Boy
woodublieve12 wrote:woodublieve12 wrote:Rik E Boy wrote:Fremantle - chalk and cheese between them and Melbourne. Essendon to face pressure.
North - Sydney will be in shock at not playing in NSW and playing a real team for a change.
West Coast - Melbourne a silly chance but LeCras and Kerr ins add additional class.
St Kilda - Only just as they are copping injuries. GWS at the 'staying in the game longer' stage only.
Geelong - By a couple of goals despite Blues having a ruck edge.
Brisbane - Last chance Lions! Brisbane inspite of the Suns three straight at Metricon.
Richmond - Bulldogs a chance but Richmond are up and about
Hawthorn - Match up well with Pies whose defence has been stabilised without Maxwell.
Adelaide - Always tough to pick these but I reckon Cows by 7 with a bit more experience around the ground.
regards,
REB
edited for accuracy

seriously though, i am baffled how you rate this bloke
I don't rate him as such but his absence will put pressure on those left behind, particularly Harry O'Brien who has been given a new lease of life up the ground. O'Brien is even more dodgy in defense than Maxwell and he'll now be forced into a more lock down type of role which will rob the Magpies of run.
regards,
REB
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 4:55 pm
by Squids
Essendon - (Edited by Mod, statement made in relation to unproven allegations)
Sydney - North a carp, expect Brad Sook to sook after the game
West Coast - 1 million point win
St Kilda - GWS are still really carp
Geelong - Too good
Brisbane - No karnezis = win. Also good luck to the 2nd afl player that has gone into battle with squids.
Richmond - Too average teams but richmond are less average
Hawthorn - Have the wood over the Pies
Adelaide - Port are still carp
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 5:47 pm
by saintal
Ross Lyon has a very ordinary coaching record v Essendon. The Dons used to cut St K to shreds with their run, quick ball movement.
Having said that you'd think Freo would win tonight.
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 7:37 pm
by helicopterking
Freo 25+.
Kangas, catch Sydney off guard
West Coast easily Shuey to kick 5, Kennedy 6.
St Kilda win just
Geelong have to drop one soon, Carlton slowly getting better.
Brisbane win, JB to kick a bag
Richmond, 3-0 but will make it harder then they need too.
Pies, only because Sewell is out
Adelaide, Look a lot quicker, bit more midfield depth
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 7:52 pm
by Interceptor
LATE CHANGES
Fremantle: Nil
Essendon: Nil
FINAL INTERCHANGES
Fremantle: Michael Barlow, Kepler Bradley, Danyle Pearce
Substitute: Cameron Sutcliffe
Essendon: Elliot Kavanagh, David Myers, Ben Howlett
Substitute: Travis Colyer
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 7:59 pm
by Chuck Wepner
saintal wrote:Ross Lyon has a very ordinary coaching record v Essendon. The Dons used to cut St K to shreds with their run, quick ball movement.
Having said that you'd think Freo would win tonight.
This isn't St Kilda circa 2011 V Essendon. Think you'll find his new playing list is a tad quicker & more dynamic than he had before. That is why the Dockers are a genuine top 4 chance.
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 8:07 pm
by Jim05
Chuck Wepner wrote:saintal wrote:Ross Lyon has a very ordinary coaching record v Essendon. The Dons used to cut St K to shreds with their run, quick ball movement.
Having said that you'd think Freo would win tonight.
This isn't St Kilda circa 2011 V Essendon. Think you'll find his new playing list is a tad quicker & more dynamic than he had before. That is why the Dockers are a genuine top 4 chance.
We also beat Freo over there last year when
Re: AFL - Round 3 discussion - (and lives scores)

Posted:
Fri Apr 12, 2013 9:19 pm
by Jim05
Ryder has ko'd McPharlin, will probably get a holiday.
Very greasy conditions, will be a scrappy affair