Page 1 of 1
Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Wed Jul 18, 2012 11:50 am
by D14
A few changes this week with injuries,
Brodie Smith - Ben Rutten - Michael Doughty
David Mackay - Daniel Talia - Brent Reilly
Bernie Vince - Patrick Dangerfield - Nathan van Berlo
Ian Callinan - Josh Jenkins - Chris Knights
Jason Porplyzia - Kurt Tippett - Matthew Wright
Sam Jacobs - Scott Thompson - Rory Sloane
INT
Jared Petrenko - Lewis Johnston - Richard Douglas
SUB
Tom T. Lynch
IN
Kurt Tippett - Jared Petrenko - Lewis Johnston - Michael Doughty
OUT
Henderson (injured) - Martin (Injured) - Shaw (Injured) - Brown
Tippett is a straight swap for Henderson
Petrenko is a straight swap for Martin
Johnston comes in for Shaw. He kicked another 5 goals on the weekend and is showing consistent form so deserves a chance. Lynch was OK last week but I think Johnston would offer more up forward so I would put Lynch as the SUB so he can cover Forward or Back as the 3rd tall with Shaw out of the side
I thought Brown looked good last week but someone will make way for Doughty.
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Wed Jul 18, 2012 12:45 pm
by Footy Smart
To Tall so Johnston wont come in and Lynch wont be sub
They dont have many tall players NicNat, Cox and Lynch, thats it really. Darling out injured Schofield will probably play FWD
Petrenko in for Martin
Tippet in for Shaw
Doughty for Henderson
Brown keeps his spot
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Wed Jul 18, 2012 1:00 pm
by D14
That being the case I would bring Johnston in for Lynch then. With Walker back next week this is a good opportunity to give him a go and see what he's like.
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Wed Jul 18, 2012 1:56 pm
by Brodlach
Lynch did enough last week to keep his spot until Walker comes back.
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Wed Jul 18, 2012 2:13 pm
by Brodlach
Johncock will be in this week IMO
Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Wed Jul 18, 2012 4:50 pm
by the joker
Andy otten will be in for Sam shaw as that third tall in defence. We will need three talks in defence as well. At stages on Saturday west coast will have Cox and Lycett both inside 50
Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Wed Jul 18, 2012 8:39 pm
by the joker
He won't be in the forward 50 then.
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Wed Jul 18, 2012 8:41 pm
by Brodlach
Is Talia good enough to go with Natinui when he goes forward?
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2012 9:23 am
by Sorry Dude
Brodlach wrote:Is Talia good enough to go with Natinui when he goes forward?
maybe. I think Talia will be able to keep up with him inside D50 but if Natinui is moving around I don't think Talia has the motor to go with him.
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2012 9:46 am
by Brodlach
Sorry Dude wrote:Brodlach wrote:Is Talia good enough to go with Natinui when he goes forward?
maybe. I think Talia will be able to keep up with him inside D50 but if Natinui is moving around I don't think Talia has the motor to go with him.
Other than Talia, I dont think we have a match up for him in our back line
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2012 12:13 pm
by Sorry Dude
Brodlach wrote:Sorry Dude wrote:Brodlach wrote:Is Talia good enough to go with Natinui when he goes forward?
maybe. I think Talia will be able to keep up with him inside D50 but if Natinui is moving around I don't think Talia has the motor to go with him.
Other than Talia, I dont think we have a match up for him in our back line
Actually.....I wouldn't be upset if Sando tried Jenkins on him or Cox resting in the forward lines.
Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2012 4:58 pm
by the joker
Apparently danger has a crack in his hand an may miss this week
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Fri Jul 20, 2012 9:19 am
by Sorry Dude
the joker wrote:Apparently danger has a crack in his hand an may miss this week
in his pinky. named and will play. he suits this type of game perfectly.
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Fri Jul 20, 2012 10:27 am
by Psyber
I like the named structure with Tippett at CHF, Jenkins at FF, and Johncock in the rotations rather than the back line.
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Sun Jul 22, 2012 12:39 pm
by bulldog2004
Great win. The tackling and pressure from the start was ruthless. Big Tippo is a bit of a concern maybe give him a rest as we get back Taylor Walker. Next week throws out another challenge against the cats always tough to beat especially at kadinia park.
Re: Rd 17 Crows V West Coast

Posted:
Mon Jul 23, 2012 1:06 pm
by Footy Smart
Couldnt have really asked for a better performance. Tacking pressure was back, skills were A1 and the work rate was fantastic. Big test this week, hardest assignment in AFL.....
Great to see Stiffy back in as well