SA Footy

Watched the Vic Metro and WA U18 game and WOW there is some serious talent coming through not just this year but next.

Cant believe I heard Melbourne considering not to take Viney as a Father Son selection?

Daniher is a no brainer and already training with the Dons.

But WA had some real talent, couple of indigenous lads Martin and Simpson look like the total package pace, reasonable size and not affraid to get the contested ball. They also had a big fella at CHF Hogan who is to young for this draft but looks like possible No1 with his ability to take a contested mark and he has a body ready for AFL footy already.

Anyone else see much of the carnival?

I think the scouts are saying the 2013 draft is set to be a bottler with plenty of big lads coming through who are not old enough for this year.

Footy Smart, I think Melbourne are thinking that they may be safe to pick up Viney without having to use their father son. I think that they are worried that if they select him as a father son, GWS & GC can bid for him also thus raising his order higher, leaving GWS & GC to get a better pick of the rest. Not sure of the draft order for clubs or if I've made much sense.

The FS rule is great now. The demons don't see viney as a top 5 pick. So they need to hope that all other sides don't see him as a first rounder. If other clubs see him as there second pick the demons will take him with there second pick but if clubs like the crows or collingwood see him as a their first pick at around pick 14 to 18. The demons will be forced to take him with pick 2 or 3

As for daniher, the bombers are in a real pickle. They Badly want Josh Caddy who they almost got last year and only signed for one year with GC. But to get him they will need to give GC their first round pick and maybe second or a player. And of coarse the GC are going to Nominate Daniher as a first rounder, but other clubs will too. So they may have to trade a decent player out to get a second first round pick.
Fun times ahead in the trade period that is a month this year

the joker wrote:As for daniher, the bombers are in a real pickle. They Badly want Josh Caddy who they almost got last year and only signed for one year with GC. But to get him they will need to give GC their first round pick and maybe second or a player. And of coarse the GC are going to Nominate Daniher as a first rounder, but other clubs will too. So they may have to trade a decent player out to get a second first round pick.
Fun times ahead in the trade period that is a month this year

Do they really need a month - when its a week now and nothing happens for the first 4 days!

Bit different this year with Free agency

the joker wrote:As for daniher, the bombers are in a real pickle. They Badly want Josh Caddy who they almost got last year and only signed for one year with GC. But to get him they will need to give GC their first round pick and maybe second or a player. And of coarse the GC are going to Nominate Daniher as a first rounder, but other clubs will too. So they may have to trade a decent player out to get a second first round pick.
Fun times ahead in the trade period that is a month this year

I was under the impression it was a done deal and he has started training with them. This was from the Hanger on Fox footy............ I would be taking Daniher over Caddy for sure, there will always be plenty of midfield options come through and a 200+cm athletic 18 year old who plucks grabs and kicks goals for fun dont come round that often.

As for Viney, well from what I have seen of him he wouldnt be slipping into the second round thats for sure.... but hey who are we

the joker wrote:As for daniher, the bombers are in a real pickle. They Badly want Josh Caddy who they almost got last year and only signed for one year with GC. But to get him they will need to give GC their first round pick and maybe second or a player. And of coarse the GC are going to Nominate Daniher as a first rounder, but other clubs will too. So they may have to trade a decent player out to get a second first round pick.
Fun times ahead in the trade period that is a month this year

What happens say if Essendon do trade their first round pick to someone. Then opt to take Daniher as f/s & other clubs say they would take as a first rouneder, do Essendon still get first grab at him with their first pick say it was a round 3 selection or do they other clubs?

No essendon have to offer the same round pick offered by other clubs

With the current ladder positions the draft order will be for round 1
1 gold coast
2 GWS
3 Melbourne
4 melbourne Tom scully pick
5 Port
6 Bulldogs
7 Bulldogs Callan Ward pick
8 Brisbane
9 Fremantle
10 North Melbourne
11 Richmond
12 Carlton
13 Melbourne Tom Scully pick
14 St Kilda
15 Geelong
16 Essendon
17 Hawthorn
18 Collingwood
19 Adelaide
20 GWS Luke brown and brad crouch trade
21 West Coast
22 Sydney
23 Brisbane Rischitelli pick

Booney wrote:I think the scouts are saying the 2013 draft is set to be a bottler with plenty of big lads coming through who are not old enough for this year.

Apparently Rendell said just before 'the incident' that on paper it was shaping up as the best draft ever.

Adelaide first pick at 19? WTF!

IS this the last of the drafts compromised by the expansion clubs?

Nah. Some clubs still haven't activated their compensation picks. Like Gerlong with the gazza picks

Sa will have three top 5 picks
Jimmy toumpas
Brodie Grundy
Troy menzel
And two more in the top 10
Ben Kennedy
Sam Mayes

Don't be so sure.

the joker wrote:Sa will have three top 5 picks
Jimmy toumpas
Brodie Grundy
Troy menzel
And two more in the top 10
Ben Kennedy
Sam Mayes

With menzels knee issues and other injuries, could slip to past pick 10.

Taking a ruckman with an early pick is always risky

the joker wrote:Sa will have three top 5 picks
Jimmy toumpas
Brodie Grundy
Troy menzel
And two more in the top 10
Ben Kennedy
Sam Mayes

Colquhoun will also be in the top 15