SA Footy

If any.

3. Thompson
2. Petrenko
1. Talia

Can I give all 6 to Thompson?

3 Thompson
2 Rutten (tried hard no help)
1 Petrenko

3. Thompson
2. Petrenko
1. Rutten

NFC wrote:3. Thompson
2. Petrenko
1. Talia

x2

Rutten also good considering he was under seige all game.

Not sure I would include Rutten he needed to hail a cab to keep up with Nick. Shocking coaches decision.
Talia average, very average

tiger07andbeyond wrote:Not sure I would include Rutten he needed to hail a cab to keep up with Nick. Shocking coaches decision.
Talia average, very average

He tried all night, and tonight, that got a vote.

giving votes to anyone besides Thompson seems ludacrist after that performance.

Most exciting list ever

1 Thompson
2 Thompson
3 Thompson

tiger07andbeyond wrote:giving votes to anyone besides Thompson seems ludacrist after that performance.
Most exciting list ever

I think the problem is the game plan/style more than the list.
It worked around 2004-5 but there is a limit to how far you can go with just trying to be fit enough to outrun the opposition all day.
Eventually you reach a physiological limit, and bodies start breaking down.

I'd like to see a longer game with more marking forwards staying forward.
Leaving the opposition defenders outnumbering the few forward targets doesn't work.
A bit more emphasis on body strength rather than running may help too.

Thompson (usual hard nut performance, gave some frees away in frustration, who could blame him)
Jacobs (was only one to grab a couple contested marks, rucked well)
Petrenko (shining light in poor season)

Shirtfront wrote:Thompson (usual hard nut performance, gave some frees away in frustration, who could blame him)
Jacobs (was only one to grab a couple contested marks, rucked well)
Petrenko (shining light in poor season)

Agreed

Final votes

18 - S.Thompson (3)
9 - J.Petenko (2)
4 - S.Jacobs (1)

3 - B.Rutten
2 - D.Talia