Judd or Chapman

[The Sleeping Giant]

With all this talk about Judd being over rated, let's see who people would rather in their team.

I picked Chapman, who I think is the most dangerous midfielder in the game.

[CoverKing]

Chapman for mine

[Media Park]

Big Geelong fan right here, but I would pick Chris Judd any day.

[woodublieve12]

massive fan of both... judd probably better footballer, but i love the way chapman goes bout things.. i personally am a bigger fan of chapman

[gadj1976]

As a Carlton supporter.... how good would it be to have both in your side. Seriously Chappy is a bloke I've always wanted in my side, he is a serious gun.

To split them is tough because they are different players playing predominantly in different positions. The Cats need Chappy more than they need Judd. Carlton need both.

[jointman]

As a Carlton supporter.... how good would it be to have both in your side. Seriously Chappy is a bloke I've always wanted in my side, he is a serious gun.

To split them is tough because they are different players playing predominantly in different positions. The Cats need Chappy more than they need Judd. Carlton need both.

well said both can play

[carey]

a lot like the last post say's if i needed a forward its chapmen and if i was after an onballer it would be judd. the point i'm making is IMO both very good players and both highly important to there clubs.....

[CK]

Great poll question, because many of my mates will attest to the number of times I've said plenty about what a class footballer Chapman is, and how amazing it is that he has only really been seriously rated by many followers in the last 3-4 seasons. This will be a tough one to vote on

[the joker]

Judd all day every day

[Q.]

Chapman. Better contested mark and superior disposal by foot. Also kicks more goals than Judd and IMO is a gutsier player.

[JK]

Bit more flexibility with Chappy might just about sway me toward him.

[Brad]

At this time chapman, but in his prime Judd.

[the joker]

At this time chapman, but in his prime Judd.

Judd will win his third brownlow this year and second in a row. And he is 27 and in his prime

[Mr66]

Neither
(A fit) Luke Hodge

[Bag The Points]

Judd all day every day

x 2

[The Sleeping Giant]

Chapman. Better contested mark and superior disposal by foot. Also kicks more goals than Judd and IMO is a gutsier player.

Thats what I was thinking too.

[gadj1976]

Neither
(A fit) Luke Hodge

now that's laughable.

One of THE most overrated footballers going around.

[Brad]

At this time chapman, but in his prime Judd.

Judd will win his third brownlow this year and second in a row. And he is 27 and in his prime

He was better at West Coast, purely cause of his speed ever since he had groin troubles in 2007 he hasn't been as quick, still a champion player but IMHO not the player he was and that also could be he had gun midfielders around him at the Eagles.

Well the umpires love him so yeah another Brownlow maybe, but I could open that can of worms again but I'll stay quiet for now...

[bayman]

chapman without a doubt

[Adelaide Hawk]

Chapman. Better contested mark and superior disposal by foot. Also kicks more goals than Judd and IMO is a gutsier player.

Yep, my sentiments exactly.