SA Footy

these three have to be top three in the AFL this year

Bartel.

regards,

REB

Bit biased but reckon watson would already have 6 brownlow votes in the bag

Jim05 wrote:Bit biased but reckon watson would already have 6 brownlow votes in the bag

i had a list of twenty but cut it down

may need to re do it i think

after three rounds who is dominating the AFL the best but who can take there team further later in the year....

for me its swan in a great running skillful side he still stands out the best

2nd would be ablett he wont star as much as he did in geelong because of the players around him but he is one of a kind..

3rd for me is goodes, year in and year out he stars for the swans, very loyal and is a two time brownlow winner and has come close to a third

unknown source wrote:

Jim05 wrote:Bit biased but reckon watson would already have 6 brownlow votes in the bag

i had a list of twenty but cut it down

may need to re do it i think

Yeah, should have stuck with ya list of 20

Of those three, Ablett is the best player over all, but I believe THIS YEAR EXCLUSIVELY, Swan has been ahead of him.

If I had got a poll down to three, I would have Judd, Pavlich and Bartel ahead of Goodes in there.

Jim05 wrote:Bit biased but reckon watson would already have 6 brownlow votes in the bag

along with S.Burgoyne

Out of those three, although i think Ablett is the best, Goodes is obviously the most versatile and resiliant

IF Goodes was to win a Brownlow again this year, it would be 3 Brownlows in 3 different positions. As he plays for Sydney, I understand why he doesn't get the accolades he deserves. If he played for Carlton or Collingwood, he would be a superstar.

The Sleeping Giant wrote:IF Goodes was to win a Brownlow again this year, it would be 3 Brownlows in 3 different positions. As he plays for Sydney, I understand why he doesn't get the accolades he deserves. If he played for Carlton or Collingwood, he would be a superstar.

He IS a superstar

I agree, but plenty wouldn't.

Goodes

Watson would have picked up more votes today, maybe all 3

Judd

Turbo wrote:Judd

We know he is the umpires pet but i thought he was only about 4th best for you guys today.

Jim05 wrote:

Turbo wrote:Judd

We know he is the umpires pet but i thought he was only about 4th best for you guys today.

We must have been watching different games cos he was the catalyst for our come back. Inspirational and my non Carlton fans who were also watching agree too

I thought murphy and yarran just shaded him today. Also reckon duigan might have captured the umps eye he had a stellar game. Yarran had a cracker and cut us to bits. Judds touches are nearly 100% effective though

swan is the new star. no fuss bull terrier.

goraw wrote:swan is the new star. no fuss bull terrier.

I agree, but how coem Ivan Maric is not included in this poll?