SA Footy

Michael Gardiner will not be available this week due to injury, if the Saints win will he recieve a premiership medal? Same applies for Leon Davis who looks likely to be dropped.

If Lenny Hayes was to win the Norm Smith again would he be a dual Norm Smith Medalist?

What are some other weird scenarios that could be posed?

If they players are to be for playing another game how does this affect both clubs salary caps, re: bonus, match payments and so forth.

What if its a draw at the end of extra time? Golden point?

whufc wrote:Michael Gardiner will not be available this week due to injury, if the Saints win will he recieve a premiership medal? Same applies for Leon Davis who looks likely to be dropped.

No. Need to play in a winning team.

If Lenny Hayes was to win the Norm Smith again would he be a dual Norm Smith Medalist?

Yes

If the players are to be for playing another game how does this affect both clubs salary caps, re: bonus, match payments and so forth.

All payments etc are included outside of the cap. Show me the money

Gardiner may be awarded a medal yet! AFL could possibly change it tomorrow!!

CoverKing wrote:Gardiner may be awarded a medal yet! AFL could possibly change it tomorrow!!

Joke

SJABC wrote:

CoverKing wrote:Gardiner may be awarded a medal yet! AFL could possibly change it tomorrow!!

Joke

I disagree! Good move in my mind, although Leon neon deserves nothing

However I don't think the AFL should of waited for a drawn match before the changed it

SJABC wrote:

CoverKing wrote:Gardiner may be awarded a medal yet! AFL could possibly change it tomorrow!!

Joke

perhaps St Kilda should win the GF first...

Punk Rooster wrote:

SJABC wrote:

CoverKing wrote:Gardiner may be awarded a medal yet! AFL could possibly change it tomorrow!!

Joke

perhaps St Kilda should win the GF first...

well obvious example as he is the only one that is certain to miss this week!
Although some could argue for Leon Davis to miss

Lockyear in for Davis?
McEvoy in for Gardnier?

McEvoy will definately come in for gardiner.....cant see the pies making a change personally

[quote="MW"]Lockyear in for Davis?
McEvoy in for Gardnier?[/quote]

I thought the same as you MW, he would be a handy replacement.
A player that will give you something in the midfield & up forward, he finds the ball.

Yep, agreed, Lockyear should play infront of Davis for sure

I think Medhurst might come in for Davis.

westozfalcon wrote:I think Medhurst might come in for Davis.

what about Goldsack for Davis

At first I was leaning toward Lockyer in for Davis. Is generally composed and effective and could rack up 10-15 more possessions than Davis. However, he hasn't been getting games because he lacks pace (think Ling vs Pies in the PF) and this could be even more exposed in a Grand Final (and we all saw how hectic it was on Saturday).

I'm now leaning in favour of retaining Davis. Kicked a crucial goal on saturday and obviously has the ability to kick two, maybe three, of these types of goals. Having played on saturday he will be familiar with the intensity of the game moreso than his replacement and has the potential to play much better than he did. Surely he is overdue to have an impact in finals!

brod wrote:

westozfalcon wrote:I think Medhurst might come in for Davis.

what about Goldsack for Davis

a tall defender for a small crumbing forward?

Quichey wrote:At first I was leaning toward Lockyer in for Davis. Is generally composed and effective and could rack up 10-15 more possessions than Davis. However, he hasn't been getting games because he lacks pace (think Ling vs Pies in the PF) and this could be even more exposed in a Grand Final (and we all saw how hectic it was on Saturday).

I'm now leaning in favour of retaining Davis. Kicked a crucial goal on saturday and obviously has the ability to kick two, maybe three, of these types of goals. Having played on saturday he will be familiar with the intensity of the game moreso than his replacement and has the potential to play much better than he did. Surely he is overdue to have an impact in finals!

i was thinking meddy in for leon. but having read your post, i kinda agree. it's basically a 50/50 risk.

Might be a chance Stanley in for Gardiner.