SA Footy

MVP - Dane Swan 972
Hodge 603
Ablett 562

Most Courageous - Luke Hodge

Best Captain - Brett Kirk

Best 1st year player - Micheal Barlow

Well deserved, you look back over he winners if this award and it's more prestigious than the Brownlow IMHO.

White Line Fever wrote:MVP - [b]Dane Swan 972
Hodge 603
Ablett 562[/b]

Most Courageous - Luke Hodge

Best Captain - Brett Kirk

Best 1st year player - Micheal Barlow

That's a pretty good trifecta...

I'm glad Barlow got picked.
That would be a pick up for him

White Line Fever wrote:MVP - Dane Swan 972
Hodge 603
Ablett 562

Most Courageous - Luke Hodge

Best Captain - Brett Kirk

Best 1st year player - Micheal Barlow

Good to see Brett Kirk getting the recognition he deserves. Will go down as one of the all time greats at the Swans with the likes of Paul Kelly - Just shows how highly he is regarded amongst the other players and teams!

Swan, Hodge, Ablett - Rekon that could be the top 3 to the brownlow as well

Once you free a voting system up from 3-2-1 per game I think you get a better result which is why this award seems often to produce the better (more deserving) winner

Well done Dane Swan. Not only has he had a great year he scored a mountain of points for my supercoach team!

Wedgie wrote:Well deserved, you look back over he winners if this award and it's more prestigious than the Brownlow IMHO.

Agreed Wedgie, That's because it's picked by the people who know the game best, the players.

Well done Swanny and Hodgey, most courageous!! Get around him!

The Dark Knight wrote:

Wedgie wrote:Well deserved, you look back over he winners if this award and it's more prestigious than the Brownlow IMHO.

Agreed Wedgie, That's because it's picked by the people who know the game best, the players.

Well done Swanny and Hodgey, most courageous!! Get around him!

I think prestige comes with longevity and in time the AFLPA MVP will become more valued than the Brownlow but for now, IMO, the Brownlow is more prestigious.

Swan a deserved winner.

How would guys based in Perth know if Kirk is better club captain than Ling or Maxwell ?

Gun.

Top stuff Swanny!

redden whites wrote:How would guys based in Perth know if Kirk is better club captain than Ling or Maxwell ?

They see and hear the qualities he posseses on the field and the way he conducts himself with the media. IMO Maxwell is a little undisciplined, great leader but tends to be a bit clumsy when applying pressure on the ball carrier.
It would have to be a great honour as nearly all captains in the AFL are all deserved captains. Brown, Goodwin, Judd, Pavlich just to name a few.

Hondo wrote:Once you free a voting system up from 3-2-1 per game I think you get a better result which is why this award seems often to produce the better (more deserving) winner

Well done Dane Swan. Not only has he had a great year he scored a mountain of points for my supercoach team!

Isn't the MVP voting system 3-2-1 and the rest are just a single vote?

Wedgie wrote:Well deserved, you look back over he winners if this award and it's more prestigious than the Brownlow IMHO.

I agree that it should be, but the AFL executive and the media still prefer the Brownlow Medal. As a player, I'd prefer to be honored by my peers rather than umpires, but that's me.

The Brownlow Medal concept is flawed. I think there's still room in football for an umpires' award, but it shouldn't carry the prestige it does. To me, the most presitgeous award in football is Best & Fairest in a premiership team.

MVP is a great system because it is not the "best and fairest" just the best. Club Best and Fairest are really just that now days arent they? Not sure if any club would make someone inelligable if they were reproted?

Brownlow has and still will allways have a place though, good to see when a brownlow and MVP are the same player, like last year and im thinking this year.