SA Footy

got really bored at work today so tryed to bust out an all aust side i'm sure its going to start plenty of people throwing abuse at me but hey here's my crack at it!


FORWARDS - lecras (wc) fev (calt) brown (bris)
HALF FORWARDS - didak (coll) riewoldt (stk) vince (adel)
CENTERS - murphy (carlt) ablett (gee) selwood (gee)
HALF BACK - goddard (stk) bolton (syd) fisher (stk)
BACKS - mackie (gee) lake (dogs) otten (adel)

RUCKS - clarke (bris) swan (coll) montagna (stk)

INTER (from) gibbs (carlt) Davis (coll) porplyzia (adel) davey (melb)

peoples thoughts????????????????????????????

unlucky- del santo, mitchell, tarrant, cassisi, goodwin and many more

ohh add RICH to that unlucky list

Adam Goodes?

Good on you for having a crack mate.

I'd say Otten isn't AA material yet, Sammy Gilbert probably takes his place, Maxwell a defensive possibility also.

He won't make it this year, but if Harbrow continues his form of this year, he'll be in there someday.

I think Judd and Goodes will squeeze in there somehow too.

The Real Number 3 wrote:Adam Goodes?

unlucky list

forgot him but nah he aint in!

Constance_Perm wrote:Good on you for having a crack mate.

I'd say Otten isn't AA material yet, Sammy Gilbert probably takes his place, Maxwell a defensive possibility also.

He won't make it this year, but if Harbrow continues his form of this year, he'll be in there someday.

I think Judd and Goodes will squeeze in there somehow too.

all fair points just thought ottens form week in week out and in the back pocket has been fantastic .

judd yeah probably should be in dont know who i'd take out tho.

goodes hmmm i'm not a huge fan

Petrie will go close

Dutchy wrote:Petrie will go close

i like petrie but just dont think 2 good weeks out of every 4 is good enough but has taken some huge steps as a leader of a very proud club whilst harvey was out he pretty much won the port and st kilda games.

Dutchy wrote:Petrie will go close

ahead of MacIntosh you reckon?

With Cox missing 8 weeks I was thinking Clark & H-Mac if they pick 2 ruckmen

hondo71 wrote:

Dutchy wrote:Petrie will go close

ahead of MacIntosh you reckon?

With Cox missing 8 weeks I was thinking Clark & H-Mac if they pick 2 ruckmen

Petrie forward, would be suprised if Mac makes it, others seem to rate him higher than I do

i would've thought jolly and sandilands would be ahead of H-MAC

Oh yeah .... Sandilands

Forgot about him

hondo71 wrote:Oh yeah .... Sandilands

Forgot about him

It's easily done mate, it's not like there's any features that make him stand out or anything

Matty Scarlett??? A certainty to make it this year.

I wonder how close Porplyzia might be? Maybe I'm biased but I think he's had a better (more consistent) year than Didak.

hondo71 wrote:I wonder how close Porplyzia might be? Maybe I'm biased but I think he's had a better (more consistent) year than Didak.

You'd imagine they'll think long and hard about Porps, and probably Milne also (Schneider been big in the games IVe seen too, but not sure whether he would have done enough over the course of the year), maybe even Akker.

Stevie Johnson a chance based on the first half of the year?

I think Stevie J was a lock if they'd picked the team at round 12. I don't know if he did enough to cover off the last half of the season. What about Chapman?

Woops ... I see carey actually put Porps on his bench

What about Lenny Hayes

I would have Lenny Hayes, Steve Johnson, Harry O'Brien, Pendulbry, Daniel Rich, Adam Goodes, Jimmy Bartel in there before Vince, Porplyzia, Davey, Otten, Gibbs and Murphy.

carey wrote:

The Real Number 3 wrote:Adam Goodes?

unlucky list

forgot him but nah he aint in!

He'll probably win the Brownlow now, based on statistics from his years that he did win, he's in with a big sniff, probably has had less team-mates do well to counteract the less games won.

BluesBrother08 wrote:What about Lenny Hayes

I would have Lenny Hayes, Steve Johnson, Harry O'Brien, Pendulbry, Daniel Rich, Adam Goodes, Jimmy Bartel in there before Vince, Porplyzia, Davey, Otten, Gibbs and Murphy.

Rich is the clear rookie of the year, but I don't think he's had an AA season.